Thorney.
Author
Discussion

Zorbathegreek

Original Poster:

239 posts

15 months

Monday 9th November
quotequote all
Posted on a Thorney Facebook group.


Grey_Area

4,384 posts

284 months

Monday 9th November
quotequote all
rolleyes

John being John.

Edited by Grey_Area on Monday 9th November 18:22

Zorbathegreek

Original Poster:

239 posts

15 months

Monday 9th November
quotequote all
Grey_Area said:
rolleyes

John being John.

Edited by Grey_Area on Monday 9th November 18:22
The McLaren he fell out with a few years ago isn’t the same as it is today - different management- different owners - different strategies etc. They have immense wealth behind them. Choking him off from parts would be disastrous for the business.

Frankychops

2,097 posts

40 months

Tuesday 10th November
quotequote all
strange how no one else is saying this. Just his usual diatribe.

Zorbathegreek

Original Poster:

239 posts

15 months

Tuesday 10th November
quotequote all
Frankychops said:
strange how no one else is saying this. Just his usual diatribe.
There s always some sort of controversy. The likes of V, Litchfield and Jack Webb are passive and just get on with it. If access to parts is to be choked-off how on earth will SoR and servicing be provided. Must be quite a desperate situation to go public with it.

Edited by Zorbathegreek on Tuesday 10th November 10:22

TBCTBC

1,693 posts

120 months

Tuesday 10th November
quotequote all
He's protecting his business, as I would expect anyone in a similar position to do.

If it happened, it would destroy his trade but it is also illegal so he's using social media to get on the front foot.

I imagine his customers won't be too chuffed if this happened.

davek_964

11,400 posts

206 months

Tuesday 10th November
quotequote all
TBCTBC said:
He's protecting his business, as I would expect anyone in a similar position to do.

If it happened, it would destroy his trade but it is also illegal so he's using social media to get on the front foot.

I imagine his customers won't be too chuffed if this happened.
The last time it "happened" - it didn't seem to happen to anybody else.

I suspect this will be the same - my car is currently at V, and they certainly haven't phoned me to say they can't get the parts.

I guess you can't create a video promoting how you've beaten the establishment (again) - unless you post one first saying that they're trying to screw you.....

Zorbathegreek

Original Poster:

239 posts

15 months

Tuesday 10th November
quotequote all
TBCTBC said:
He's protecting his business, as I would expect anyone in a similar position to do.

If it happened, it would destroy his trade but it is also illegal so he's using social media to get on the front foot.

I imagine his customers won't be too chuffed if this happened.
As is McLaren.

I did t think it is illegal not to provide parts to indies. I thought the right to repair was only limited to build data, manuals and diagnostics. Parts are made directly available to owners/consumers throuh the approved network of dealers. I recall (from many years ago) that JT raised issue over the cost of diagnostic equipment. I imagine that the agreement between McLaren and the approved network has some sort of grey reselling restriction. Remember that Thorney has expanded the reach internationally through what he refers to as his dealers (grey reselling to grey resellers?) To legally challenge across different countries won’t be straightforward. Will need some very deep pockets and a lot of time/distraction.

Not sure how long you ve followed the JT and McLaren relationship. There s quite a bit of history there.

Edited by Zorbathegreek on Tuesday 10th November 12:57

Smooth Smith

636 posts

195 months

Tuesday 10th November
quotequote all
I dare say that this would hurt the resale market if this is true. Like him or not, Thorney has done a lot to bolster confidence in used McLarens, and is a credible option to the main dealers. Same for V, and more recently, JWM. Without the likes of the indies, depreciation will hit hard again if a main dealer is the only option for servicing and repairs.

Zorbathegreek

Original Poster:

239 posts

15 months

Tuesday 10th November
quotequote all
Smooth Smith said:
I dare say that this would hurt the resale market if this is true. Like him or not, Thorney has done a lot to bolster confidence in used McLarens, and is a credible option to the main dealers. Same for V, and more recently, JWM. Without the likes of the indies, depreciation will hit hard again if a main dealer is the only option for servicing and repairs.
Probably just a Thorney thing. Scare videos about issues and slagging off management doesn’t do the brand image any good. JT and McLaren HQ haven’t had a good relationship. Luxury brands are notorious for brand protection. McLaren look to be going through a reinvention of the brand. There’s more to this story,,, I think. Plenty of choice for indies now.

cgt2

7,505 posts

219 months

Tuesday 10th November
quotequote all
V Engineering actually work closely with MSO and Woking as their staff were there on the production line. And usually they have multiple P1's in as they are the acknowledged company with premier expertise in that particular model. A different level of expertise and technical knowledge to some indies who employ young lads to work on cars. Sure you can train them to be very good but it's not the same as people who actually built the cars in the first place and have decades of experience.

RSbandit

3,072 posts

163 months

Tuesday 10th November
quotequote all
While it's great to have a couple of indies to choose from outside the Mclaren dealer network (some of whom are really useless) I doubt the new Mclaren Automotive owners are too bothered about the used mkt in generally speaking scruffy 10 plus yr old sports and super series cars which Thorney specialises in bringing up to saleable quality. V haven't mentioned anything about this at this stage either.

Frankychops

2,097 posts

40 months

Tuesday 10th November
quotequote all
Zorbathegreek said:
Frankychops said:
strange how no one else is saying this. Just his usual diatribe.
There s always some sort of controversy. The likes of V, Litchfield and Jack Webb are passive and just get on with it. If access to parts is to be choked-off how on earth will SoR and servicing be provided. Must be quite a desperate situation to go public with it.

Edited by Zorbathegreek on Tuesday 10th November 10:22
doesn't the name 'thorney' come from what all of his relationships end up being? It'd be nuts to think he's telling the truth, i'd bet people are just bored of dealing with them.



TBCTBC

1,693 posts

120 months

Tuesday 10th November
quotequote all
Zorbathegreek said:
As is McLaren.

I did t think it is illegal not to provide parts to indies. I thought the right to repair was only limited to build data, manuals and diagnostics. Parts are made directly available to owners/consumers throuh the approved network of dealers. I recall (from many years ago) that JT raised issue over the cost of diagnostic equipment. I imagine that the agreement between McLaren and the approved network has some sort of grey reselling restriction. Remember that Thorney has expanded the reach internationally through what he refers to as his dealers (grey reselling to grey resellers?) To legally challenge across different countries won t be straightforward. Will need some very deep pockets and a lot of time/distraction.

Not sure how long you ve followed the JT and McLaren relationship. There s quite a bit of history there.

Edited by Zorbathegreek on Tuesday 10th November 12:57
Yes, I've read about their relationship for a long time and it's has its ups and downs for sure. I think he even fell out with the MOC at some point, although I could be mistaken?

There's a book in there somewhere, but whether it'll be short story or a novel, I don't know.



TBCTBC

1,693 posts

120 months

Tuesday 10th November
quotequote all
cgt2 said:
V Engineering actually work closely with MSO and Woking as their staff were there on the production line. And usually they have multiple P1's in as they are the acknowledged company with premier expertise in that particular model. A different level of expertise and technical knowledge to some indies who employ young lads to work on cars. Sure you can train them to be very good but it's not the same as people who actually built the cars in the first place and have decades of experience.
Yes, I think I read that some indies operate with factory support, others don't.

I think we can guess which one doesn't.

Skye5

175 posts

1 month

Tuesday 10th November
quotequote all
RSbandit said:
While it's great to have a couple of indies to choose from outside the Mclaren dealer network (some of whom are really useless) I doubt the new Mclaren Automotive owners are too bothered about the used mkt in generally speaking scruffy 10 plus yr old sports and super series cars which Thorney specialises in bringing up to saleable quality. V haven't mentioned anything about this at this stage either.
Actually they do care.

I have a 2013 12c still under extended warranty and I’ve had great service from them including Woking helping to source hard to find parts, a fair amount of free goodwill stuff that shouldn’t technically be covered and arranging factory visits etc.

Hopefully the idea that they don’t care about ‘legacy’ models is a thing of the past.

I’m pretty happy with the service

cgt2

7,505 posts

219 months

Tuesday 10th November
quotequote all
Skye5 said:
Actually they do care.

I have a 2013 12c still under extended warranty and I ve had great service from them including Woking helping to source hard to find parts, a fair amount of free goodwill stuff that shouldn t technically be covered and arranging factory visits etc.

Hopefully the idea that they don t care about legacy models is a thing of the past.

I m pretty happy with the service
Same experience, my 12c Spider was under factory warranty until I switched to V Engineering a couple of years ago. Ascot and Hatfield were very proactive and helpful (Hatfield less so recently). Which is why I'm considering a GTS from Ascot now.

AMRicardo

164 posts

32 months

Tuesday 10th November
quotequote all
I’ve only spoken to John the once but it’s not hard to imagine him getting into self-created conflicts on a regular basis. A simple enquiry handled like you’ve poured a pint over him!

Regardless, he and the other UK specialists have done a fantastic job and have helped solve the residuals issue that has weighed heavily on the brand.

The ‘new’ McLaren really need to prioritise getting their dealership house in order. On my third, owned in three different countries and the after-sales/servicing received in all three countries has been shockingly bad. At least in the UK there are the likes of V and Thorney.

Now they appear to have solved the P13/P14 onwards quality dip, can’t think of a bigger issue they face. The cars are absolutely superb. Sort the dealers, you sort residuals and cement a loyal customer base.

Frankychops

2,097 posts

40 months

Saturday 14th November
quotequote all
AMRicardo said:
I ve only spoken to John the once but it s not hard to imagine him getting into self-created conflicts on a regular basis. A simple enquiry handled like you ve poured a pint over him!

Regardless, he and the other UK specialists have done a fantastic job and have helped solve the residuals issue that has weighed heavily on the brand.

The new McLaren really need to prioritise getting their dealership house in order. On my third, owned in three different countries and the after-sales/servicing received in all three countries has been shockingly bad. At least in the UK there are the likes of V and Thorney.

Now they appear to have solved the P13/P14 onwards quality dip, can t think of a bigger issue they face. The cars are absolutely superb. Sort the dealers, you sort residuals and cement a loyal customer base.
there was a thread on FB where he said it was just him. to be fair, in my work i'd choose not to work with thorney also. it seems Mclaren are still supporting everyone else.

JDH1

1,018 posts

270 months

Monday 16th November
quotequote all
My admittedly limited experience with him is that he could start a fight in an empty room.