Critique my Photos
Author
Discussion

Smurfsarepeopletoo

Original Poster:

1,022 posts

88 months

Saturday
quotequote all
Evening All,Currently on holiday, and been taking some pictures that im really happy with, I dont do any editing other than cropping, but just wondered if people could give their opinions or ideas on how to make the images batter.Thanks in advance.

mike80

2,426 posts

247 months

The main thing I noticed is that some seemed low resolution - are they extreme crops, or not very sharp?

A couple had busy backgrounds which which were a bit distracting, and the ones of the birds with bits of wings missing I probably wouldn't include.

But some nice stuff there as well!

StevieBee

15,513 posts

286 months

I like this one:

Smurfsarepeopletoo said:
Shame the rock or trunk is in frame otherwise that would have been a calendar-worthy shot.

As above, backgrounds a bit distracting on a few.

You say you don't do editing other than cropping but some of these would benefit from the shadows being lifted a bit. If you're shooting RAW there's bags of scope to really make these images sing.

What set up you using?

Smurfsarepeopletoo

Original Poster:

1,022 posts

88 months

Currently using a Nikon D500, with a Sigma 150-600mm, still relatively new to this, so working on the shutter setting, and then adjusting the exposure.Most of these are taken at the 600mm length, and still a fair distance away.These images are wirelessly transferred from the camera, and then cropped on the phone, so not sure the quality is as good as the RAW image.This is the uncropped image of the Grey Heron, I was about 50m away, at full length.I also think I would benefit from using a Tripod/Monopod as these are in Lanzarote, and was a bit difficult in the wind.

Last Visit

3,721 posts

219 months

Composition is always important, you have some good photos there, plenty of positives to take. I really like photo 6 of the heron in flight, it has a nice bit of background blur to help frame the bird.

Compare that to where you've clipped off wings in other photos and you can see the stark difference.

With wildlife photos a busy background, as mentioned above, can lesson the impact of the photo.

Simpo Two

93,096 posts

296 months

Can't really add anything to what's already been said but a 150-600mm lens doesn't seem the best choice for small things like dragonflies and bees. Generally perhaps you tend to take things from too far away and then crop, which loses quality, rather than trying to get closer.

I wouldn't do any processing on a phone. Take the RAWs home and do them properly on a nice big calibrated monitor.

Whoozit

3,891 posts

300 months

Some hopefully helpful thoughts smile

There are nice images here. Focus on the eye + environmental background + well exposed.

So, some things to check.

The camera-to-phone interface will always be jpg which is inherently less information than raw
Raw on a computer has much more latitude for processing, to deal with highlights, shadows, pixel quality
So cropping in phone, will be inferior to doing it on a computer
Processing on a computer, jpg or raw, brings an easy ability to add artistic interpretation ie add or remove contrast, exposure, sharpness, and many more

Go back and look at the crops. Given the bird subjects, are they centred/complementary to the environment, well positioned in the frame, leaping out at you? If not, maybe it gives you something to improve on.

Remember, even pro photographers say an image is never perfect, but processed as far as is possible.



Edited by Whoozit on Tuesday 17th November 11:03

Russet Grange

3,220 posts

57 months

Yes, as above. Transfer the RAW files, mess about with them in Lightroom (grab a free trial if you don't have it).

GravelBen

16,555 posts

261 months

Russet Grange said:
Yes, as above. Transfer the RAW files, mess about with them in Lightroom (grab a free trial if you don't have it).
Or get an alternative like LightCraft or RapidRaw for free and avoid getting sucked into adobe's subscription scheme... hehe

Agree with other comments in general - good potential there, mainly need to work on getting closer and picking angles / framing for cleaner backgrounds. Getting closer to the subject will help throw the background out of focus more too.

Edited by GravelBen on Monday 16th November 11:15

kestral

2,270 posts

238 months

Smurfsarepeopletoo said:
Currently using a Nikon D500, with a Sigma 150-600mm, still relatively new to this, so working on the shutter setting, and then adjusting the exposure.


Most of these are taken at the 600mm length, and still a fair distance away.


These images are wirelessly transferred from the camera, and then cropped on the phone, so not sure the quality is as good as the RAW image.


This is the uncropped image of the Grey Heron, I was about 50m away, at full length.


I also think I would benefit from using a Tripod/Monopod as these are in Lanzarote, and was a bit difficult in the wind.


No matter what you do at that distance you will not overcome the haze, you need to get closer.

Smurfsarepeopletoo

Original Poster:

1,022 posts

88 months

Been out again today, no editing or cropping on these, tried to get closer.

Simpo Two

93,096 posts

296 months

I'll turn it round. Looking just at the first two, what do you think might be issues?

Smurfsarepeopletoo

Original Poster:

1,022 posts

88 months

Yesterday (09:35)
quotequote all
I have no idea tbh.

Simpo Two

93,096 posts

296 months

Yesterday (10:56)
quotequote all
OK. Well the first thing that strikes me about #1 is the big stick that goes right across the body of the bird you're trying to photograph. So to photograph the bird you need to move round to the left, if possible, to get the stick out of the way. Or if you can't, look for a better opportunity.

2 is a nice interesting composition but most of the bird is in heavy shadow. I would use fill flash to throw some light on the subject.

3 - bird is lost against the background.

4 - pigeon - can't fault that one.

5 - messy, bird is over-exposed.

6 - much better, but an awful lot of leaves as well. Presume this is as close as you could get or couldn't crop further.

7 - that's an interesting one. It seems a little dark but if you brighten the whole image the bird will go over. Maybe a little blue.

This is a tricky subject so you're likely to get lots of misses as well as the ones you actually want smile


I make no claim to be a wildlife photographer but when I saw this from my desk I had to get the camera (D500 + 70-300VR). For me, the berries make it:



Oh and a squirrel, much easier smile




Whoozit

3,891 posts

300 months

Yesterday (11:18)
quotequote all
Good work! These show you have taken on the feedback. Definitely seeing more of the environment, although the sky is distracting as Simpo said. It's one of the downsides of bird photography, they tend to stay in the trees when you'd prefer them to pose nicely against a background of distant foliage.

My picks:

  1. 2 - I like the pose as it seems to be looking coyly over its shoulder, and the little catchlight in its eye brings it to life. The tail is out of focus which is a shame, as is the crossing branch. Processing - crop out the top and right so the bird is centred, use colour sliders to reduce brightness of the yellow in the background and make more green to bring closer to the other leaves
  1. 4 - Nice 3/4 pose, perfect eye and profile, love the iridescent sheen. Feet are hidden which is a slight shame. The front half of the head in the dark shadowed background is great, makes it pop. You could have stepped to the right to position the head entirely in the dark. The steps going out of focus gives a nice 3D quality to the image. Background distracting, although I quite like the fact it's a palm as it creates a bit of wonder about where this is shot.
  1. 5+6 - good examples of you including more environment. #5, try a portrait crop to make it a cleaner comp. The lighting is harsh, one thing to watch for.
  1. 7 - Iike it. The foreground needles frame the bird and it's interacting with you, solid shot. Nice catchlight. Processing, reduce the blue intensity, and the brights of the foreground needles. A good example of where a polarising filter would have helped.

Smurfsarepeopletoo

Original Poster:

1,022 posts

88 months

Yesterday (11:35)
quotequote all
Nice Photos, unfortunately there wasnt a better angle due to the dense foliage.I have done squirrels back home, was just trying to get some wildlife abroad.

Simpo Two

93,096 posts

296 months

Yesterday (12:07)
quotequote all
Smurfsarepeopletoo said:
Nice Photos, unfortunately there wasnt a better angle due to the dense foliage.
It's often the case. Nature doesn't go to plan; sometimes you just have to walk away and find a better subject.

One thing - all your photos seem to suffer from smudgy pixels to a varying extent. What ISO and JPG compression are you using? I resize mine to 2000px longest side and sometimes sharpen a little.