Isn't it going to be carnage with mass ev adoption?
Isn't it going to be carnage with mass ev adoption?
Author
Discussion

MrCheese

Original Poster:

362 posts

214 months

Yesterday (20:10)
quotequote all
This thread will probably go pear shaped quite quickly but I'm curious what other people's views on what will happen with mass ev adoption.

Short story is that we did our first holiday in an ev6. 177 miles away to the Yorkshire coast. On the surface it was absolutely fine, topped up with ultrafast charger on M1, had slow charging at destination. Car in sports mode the whole time.

But below the surface it could be very different if more cars are EVs.

The Gridserve on the motorway had 36 bays. First one we tried didn't work. Only half are ultra rapid. Several of the charging points were incompatible connectors. There were only 1-2 free bays on both visits and a single lane to the charging area which cut through 2 parking areas. If there were many more cars, there would be a queue and some gridlock. You set the car charging and look up at the vast normal car park - if even a fairly small fraction of cars were electric the major motorway services wouldn't be able to cope.

At the destination there were 4 3.6kw charging points for the entire village. Again, we always got a spot but you had to leave the car plugged in overnight to sensibly charge. If these bays were full, it's a 30-mile round trip to a slightly faster charger and probably 3-4 hours out of a holiday.

I'm an ev fan but I can see absolute carnage on busy holiday travel days in future....

HughG

3,751 posts

272 months

Yesterday (20:15)
quotequote all
It sounds like it worked out alright for you this trip.

I’d expect as more cars become EVs the investment in infrastructure will adjust. With pay per mile and the increase in EV BIK rates I suspect the increasing popularity will be more steady.

M4cruiser

5,246 posts

181 months

Yesterday (20:29)
quotequote all
OP, yes I think you have a point.
I'm a frequent user of a Super Hub, and at present there is always space. It takes up a huge area of land, and the necessary build rate may not keep up with demand.
I'm also finding the "pump" I've chosen doesn't work, perhaps 1 in 10 times. With petrol it was very rare.


stevemcs

10,403 posts

124 months

Yesterday (20:35)
quotequote all
HughG said:
It sounds like it worked out alright for you this trip.

I d expect as more cars become EVs the investment in infrastructure will adjust. With pay per mile and the increase in EV BIK rates I suspect the increasing popularity will be more steady.
This is the Uk, do you really think they will think that far ahead ? If you think the ppm has anything to do with building infrastructure as more people want to charge then that will never happen either. Ppm is nothing more than picking up where petrol/diesel drivers get rinsed, as they drop off ppm will go up for ev owners.

Caddyshack

15,362 posts

237 months

Yesterday (20:43)
quotequote all
The route to EV was a cheaper way to run a car, no road tax, subsidies, and cheap ish to charge. That will all change and then we will be paying what we were with petrol and not have the stuff that brought us to pistonheads.

Rich1973

1,286 posts

208 months

Yesterday (20:49)
quotequote all
Caddyshack said:
The route to EV was a cheaper way to run a car, no road tax, subsidies, and cheap ish to charge. That will all change and then we will be paying what we were with petrol and not have the stuff that brought us to pistonheads.
It can be seen coming from a mile off. All the billions in fuel duty / VAT will have to come from EV drivers eventually. I pity the naivety of the electric car drivers who think it won't.

SpeckledJim

34,555 posts

284 months

Yesterday (20:57)
quotequote all
The network grows in concert with the EV parc. It has been doing this for a decade and is not going to just stop.

SpeckledJim

34,555 posts

284 months

Yesterday (20:58)
quotequote all
Rich1973 said:
Caddyshack said:
The route to EV was a cheaper way to run a car, no road tax, subsidies, and cheap ish to charge. That will all change and then we will be paying what we were with petrol and not have the stuff that brought us to pistonheads.
It can be seen coming from a mile off. All the billions in fuel duty / VAT will have to come from EV drivers eventually. I pity the naivety of the electric car drivers who think it won't.
Keep your special ICE. Enjoy it. Use an EV for shopping and commuting if you want. Do what you like.

CABC

6,317 posts

132 months

Yesterday (21:00)
quotequote all
the standing charge for providers is set to increase. if it does we could see £1+ kwh
policy wonks don't really like any private car anyway.

Caddyshack

15,362 posts

237 months

Yesterday (21:03)
quotequote all
SpeckledJim said:
Rich1973 said:
Caddyshack said:
The route to EV was a cheaper way to run a car, no road tax, subsidies, and cheap ish to charge. That will all change and then we will be paying what we were with petrol and not have the stuff that brought us to pistonheads.
It can be seen coming from a mile off. All the billions in fuel duty / VAT will have to come from EV drivers eventually. I pity the naivety of the electric car drivers who think it won't.
Keep your special ICE. Enjoy it. Use an EV for shopping and commuting if you want. Do what you like.
Maybe. My Rangie costs me 900 per yr in tax. I think I pay about another 2000 per yr on cars and bikes…I suspect many will be taxed off the road.

SpeckledJim

34,555 posts

284 months

Yesterday (21:13)
quotequote all
Caddyshack said:
SpeckledJim said:
Rich1973 said:
Caddyshack said:
The route to EV was a cheaper way to run a car, no road tax, subsidies, and cheap ish to charge. That will all change and then we will be paying what we were with petrol and not have the stuff that brought us to pistonheads.
It can be seen coming from a mile off. All the billions in fuel duty / VAT will have to come from EV drivers eventually. I pity the naivety of the electric car drivers who think it won't.
Keep your special ICE. Enjoy it. Use an EV for shopping and commuting if you want. Do what you like.
Maybe. My Rangie costs me 900 per yr in tax. I think I pay about another 2000 per yr on cars and bikes I suspect many will be taxed off the road.
Ask your Irish, French and Dutch friends what their Range Rovers cost in tax. Or just an EV. You can choose to, or choose not to.

Caddyshack

15,362 posts

237 months

Yesterday (21:19)
quotequote all
SpeckledJim said:
Caddyshack said:
SpeckledJim said:
Rich1973 said:
Caddyshack said:
The route to EV was a cheaper way to run a car, no road tax, subsidies, and cheap ish to charge. That will all change and then we will be paying what we were with petrol and not have the stuff that brought us to pistonheads.
It can be seen coming from a mile off. All the billions in fuel duty / VAT will have to come from EV drivers eventually. I pity the naivety of the electric car drivers who think it won't.
Keep your special ICE. Enjoy it. Use an EV for shopping and commuting if you want. Do what you like.
Maybe. My Rangie costs me 900 per yr in tax. I think I pay about another 2000 per yr on cars and bikes I suspect many will be taxed off the road.
Ask your Irish, French and Dutch friends what their Range Rovers cost in tax. Or just an EV. You can choose to, or choose not to.
I do not agree. You have a choice until your pips start to squeak. You can make the choice to keep going until it would be totally foolish to keep paying.


SpeckledJim

34,555 posts

284 months

Yesterday (21:35)
quotequote all
Caddyshack said:
SpeckledJim said:
Caddyshack said:
SpeckledJim said:
Rich1973 said:
Caddyshack said:
The route to EV was a cheaper way to run a car, no road tax, subsidies, and cheap ish to charge. That will all change and then we will be paying what we were with petrol and not have the stuff that brought us to pistonheads.
It can be seen coming from a mile off. All the billions in fuel duty / VAT will have to come from EV drivers eventually. I pity the naivety of the electric car drivers who think it won't.
Keep your special ICE. Enjoy it. Use an EV for shopping and commuting if you want. Do what you like.
Maybe. My Rangie costs me 900 per yr in tax. I think I pay about another 2000 per yr on cars and bikes I suspect many will be taxed off the road.
Ask your Irish, French and Dutch friends what their Range Rovers cost in tax. Or just an EV. You can choose to, or choose not to.
I do not agree. You have a choice until your pips start to squeak. You can make the choice to keep going until it would be totally foolish to keep paying.
Try an EV Range Rover then. Really nice. 👍

TomTheTyke

672 posts

178 months

Yesterday (21:37)
quotequote all
My C63 is £790 to tax at the moment. When it was new (excluding first year premium) it was £435.

£435 in 2010 adjusted by CPI inflation = £724 today. So in real terms it’s not far off stood still, interestingly.

Doesn’t change the fact they’ll need to raise some more from EVs, but puts those 15 years of increases into context.

Caddyshack

15,362 posts

237 months

Yesterday (21:43)
quotequote all
SpeckledJim said:
Caddyshack said:
SpeckledJim said:
Caddyshack said:
SpeckledJim said:
Rich1973 said:
Caddyshack said:
The route to EV was a cheaper way to run a car, no road tax, subsidies, and cheap ish to charge. That will all change and then we will be paying what we were with petrol and not have the stuff that brought us to pistonheads.
It can be seen coming from a mile off. All the billions in fuel duty / VAT will have to come from EV drivers eventually. I pity the naivety of the electric car drivers who think it won't.
Keep your special ICE. Enjoy it. Use an EV for shopping and commuting if you want. Do what you like.
Maybe. My Rangie costs me 900 per yr in tax. I think I pay about another 2000 per yr on cars and bikes I suspect many will be taxed off the road.
Ask your Irish, French and Dutch friends what their Range Rovers cost in tax. Or just an EV. You can choose to, or choose not to.
I do not agree. You have a choice until your pips start to squeak. You can make the choice to keep going until it would be totally foolish to keep paying.
Try an EV Range Rover then. Really nice. ?
Lovely, £170k and then the govt will wind on the taxes for evs and be screwed.


SpeckledJim

34,555 posts

284 months

Yesterday (21:46)
quotequote all
Caddyshack said:
SpeckledJim said:
Caddyshack said:
SpeckledJim said:
Caddyshack said:
SpeckledJim said:
Rich1973 said:
Caddyshack said:
The route to EV was a cheaper way to run a car, no road tax, subsidies, and cheap ish to charge. That will all change and then we will be paying what we were with petrol and not have the stuff that brought us to pistonheads.
It can be seen coming from a mile off. All the billions in fuel duty / VAT will have to come from EV drivers eventually. I pity the naivety of the electric car drivers who think it won't.
Keep your special ICE. Enjoy it. Use an EV for shopping and commuting if you want. Do what you like.
Maybe. My Rangie costs me 900 per yr in tax. I think I pay about another 2000 per yr on cars and bikes I suspect many will be taxed off the road.
Ask your Irish, French and Dutch friends what their Range Rovers cost in tax. Or just an EV. You can choose to, or choose not to.
I do not agree. You have a choice until your pips start to squeak. You can make the choice to keep going until it would be totally foolish to keep paying.
Try an EV Range Rover then. Really nice. ?
Lovely, £170k and then the govt will wind on the taxes for evs and be screwed.
Keep the one you’ve got then. That’s nice too.

paradigital

1,111 posts

183 months

Yesterday (21:47)
quotequote all
I always wonder how many times a “broken” charger is actually broken. I stopped on the M5 a few weeks back on the way home from Devon (to Cheshire) and had no issues at all. Drove up, tapped payment card, plugged in. The guy next to me tried three chargers (one being the second plug of the one I was using) before giving up exclaiming that they were all broken.

Caddyshack

15,362 posts

237 months

Yesterday (21:54)
quotequote all
SpeckledJim said:
Caddyshack said:
SpeckledJim said:
Caddyshack said:
SpeckledJim said:
Caddyshack said:
SpeckledJim said:
Rich1973 said:
Caddyshack said:
The route to EV was a cheaper way to run a car, no road tax, subsidies, and cheap ish to charge. That will all change and then we will be paying what we were with petrol and not have the stuff that brought us to pistonheads.
It can be seen coming from a mile off. All the billions in fuel duty / VAT will have to come from EV drivers eventually. I pity the naivety of the electric car drivers who think it won't.
Keep your special ICE. Enjoy it. Use an EV for shopping and commuting if you want. Do what you like.
Maybe. My Rangie costs me 900 per yr in tax. I think I pay about another 2000 per yr on cars and bikes I suspect many will be taxed off the road.
Ask your Irish, French and Dutch friends what their Range Rovers cost in tax. Or just an EV. You can choose to, or choose not to.
I do not agree. You have a choice until your pips start to squeak. You can make the choice to keep going until it would be totally foolish to keep paying.
Try an EV Range Rover then. Really nice. ?
Lovely, £170k and then the govt will wind on the taxes for evs and be screwed.
Keep the one you ve got then. That s nice too.
We’re going around in circles. My Rangie is getting old now and it starts to get a bit old when your thoroughly depreciated car is costing nearly £1000 to tax each year when cars we are supposed to be driving in the govt eyes are nil to £100 per yr. as said, we are being taxed out of our older cars and that may continue to get so bad we are forced to comply without a choice…make that a rational choice.

MrCheese

Original Poster:

362 posts

214 months

Yesterday (22:14)
quotequote all
stevemcs said:
HughG said:
It sounds like it worked out alright for you this trip.

I d expect as more cars become EVs the investment in infrastructure will adjust. With pay per mile and the increase in EV BIK rates I suspect the increasing popularity will be more steady.
This is the Uk, do you really think they will think that far ahead ? If you think the ppm has anything to do with building infrastructure as more people want to charge then that will never happen either. Ppm is nothing more than picking up where petrol/diesel drivers get rinsed, as they drop off ppm will go up for ev owners.
This exchange summarises my thoughts exactly, the trip did work out fine but here is my worry - according to AI

"Across a full 24-hour period, a typical UK motorway service fuel station will average around 15 to 30 cars per hour filling up. However, because motorway traffic is heavily concentrated during the day, peak daytime hours will often see 50 to 80+ cars per hour."

I have no confidence at all that UK infrastructure will keep up with that type of demand which I don't see fundamentally changing. There just isn't the space at services, let alone the infra.

CABC

6,317 posts

132 months

Yesterday (22:20)
quotequote all
MrCheese said:
stevemcs said:
HughG said:
It sounds like it worked out alright for you this trip.

I d expect as more cars become EVs the investment in infrastructure will adjust. With pay per mile and the increase in EV BIK rates I suspect the increasing popularity will be more steady.
This is the Uk, do you really think they will think that far ahead ? If you think the ppm has anything to do with building infrastructure as more people want to charge then that will never happen either. Ppm is nothing more than picking up where petrol/diesel drivers get rinsed, as they drop off ppm will go up for ev owners.
This exchange summarises my thoughts exactly, the trip did work out fine but here is my worry - according to AI

"Across a full 24-hour period, a typical UK motorway service fuel station will average around 15 to 30 cars per hour filling up. However, because motorway traffic is heavily concentrated during the day, peak daytime hours will often see 50 to 80+ cars per hour."

I have no confidence at all that UK infrastructure will keep up with that type of demand which I don't see fundamentally changing. There just isn't the space at services, let alone the infra.
many EVs charge overnight. I can see summer & bank holidays presenting problems but weekday traffic maybe/hopefully less so.