Billing problem or not
Author
Discussion

Storrmsacomin'

Original Poster:

1 posts

Yesterday (20:49)
quotequote all
Evening all, first post of many probably given I've got 4 cars and 4 bikes This is a long one, grab a coffee and a pillow.

I feel like I've had a standard stealership experience but thought I'd reality check it.

I've taken 4 cars to the local dealership garage over the last month for MOTs, all cars are 10+years old and nothing of the dealerships brand. It's just a local garage that I've used a few times before, although not for a couple of years.

Cars are the wife's, both kids and mine. The universe has seen fit to make all MOTs and insurance due in the same month, or just incredibly bad timing on my part. Either way, October's a a kick in the sack

Wife's car needed £500 worth of work (shocker, macpherson strut) with a list of advisories not flagged up last year (cracked tyres, all indicators, 2 oil leaks).

One kids had £500 for both headlights not aligning and a list of advisories not flagged up last year including rust, bushes, shocker misting, bulbs, etc. Originally the garage said they couldn't align the headlights so they needed replacing and had found some aftermarket ones for £370 fitted. 5 mins later they called back and said they could only find OEM Ford ones for £535 fitted. I had a look later and local motor factors can source aftermarket headlights no bother.

Other kids failed on emissions and shocker but the garage said I'd need to take it to a diesel specialist to get any work done. Advisories read like the car had been found in the desert after having been submerged in water for the last 20 years...rust, brake pipes, oil leaks, cracked tyres, total litany of failure not flagged up in last 5 mots. Kids at uni so car is scrap.

Mine, well. I booked it in for a service and MOT a month prior to it running out thinking if it needs any work to pass I'll get it done. So drop it in on Monday morning, 2 hrs later get a call saying it needs rear pads and discs, a shocker (expecting the shocker though) and there are two nails in the rear tyres, they can repair one but one tyre is needed. I say ok.

They test the car later that day and it fails and they list all of the work that I've agreed to, plus advisories for oil leaks, bushes, front pads and discs, steering leak, etc. Again, it now reads like Elon Musk has found the car floating around in space and grabbed it for salvage.

The work for the rear discs and pads and tyres are listed as advisories, not work that needs done for the MOT. They also note that the tyre they could fix is cracked and perishing but it's only 18 months old and doesn't look cracked at all. Crucially, it's also failed on emissions (smoke opacity test). It's been as clean as a whistle on all previous tests, bar a few tyre/wiper issues and the last one was with Kwikfit.

They call on Tuesday saying they are starting the work but don't actually tell me it's failed the first MOT. They then call on Wednesday and tell me the bill is £800 and that it's failed on emissions and I'll have to take it to a diesel specialist.

Thankfully they let me take it without paying to get the emissions work done and re-tested with them. However, I've booked it in at Kwikfit and will take it in screaming hot after emptying 1/2 tank of V-power and DPF cleaner to see about the emissions.

I'm thinking I've been well rogued here by a garage that has had the best part of £1800 (if I pay the latest bill) for four MOTs and pretty much made all the cars scrap to anyone who cares to look at the MOT history now. Not to mention made one car actual scrap. They're not expensive cars but I might have sold them at some point. If mine needs any expensive DPF work done it's not happening so it'll be scrap with a £800 recent bill.

I'm disputing the £800 or am I being a whiny baby?

shed driver

3,103 posts

191 months

Yesterday (21:06)
quotequote all
DPF problems are going to kill a lot of cars. There's going to be huge numbers of pretty new cars that fail and with diesel values tanking it will be uneconomic to fix.

SD.

Tighnamara

2,868 posts

184 months

Yesterday (22:00)
quotequote all
Why would you continue to use a garage you obviously have concerns with, to have issues / concerns with work on the first car then have the same garage carry out work on 3 other cars seems strange.

What have you said to the garage you are actually disputing ?

Sheepshanks

41,366 posts

150 months

Yesterday (22:45)
quotequote all
Why did you switch to this garage - what was wrong with the old place?

New one sounds like it's a franchise dealer? It's completely mental taking an older car of their own franchise to a dealer, and taking an off-franchise one is scarcely believable.