Home WiFi set up
Author
Discussion

sib8292

Original Poster:

27 posts

202 months

First off, for me the whole way in which technology works is a mystery - I can use it but I don't really understand how it works other than at a very superficial level. So go easy on me!

I have a 3 storey house in France, and as yet no fibre service. I have an Orange Livebox, which is a combined router and modem and is WiFI 5 compatible. The house has a very thick granite wall which runs across the middle, meaning that the wireless signal from the router is effectively confined to the side of the house where it is located.

Until recently I used a Powerline extender to provide WiFi to the other side of the wall, which was sufficient but an upgrade of the Livebox seems to have resulted in the extender no longer working. Some sort of compatibility problem I expect.

So I've been considering a move to a mesh system, at my home in England I have an Eero set up which works well. So is there any obvious reason why I could not buy 2 or 3 Eero 6 or 6+ units (currently on offer from Amazon) and link them up to the Livebox? The ethernet cable between the Livebox and the first Eero box uses the same connectors as UK so they are compatible in that respect.

Bearing in mind my lack of tech understanding and limited French, dealing with providers in France isn't too easy, so I'm trying to sort out the issue here before travelling to the house to install whatever I buy.


.:ian:.

3,193 posts

234 months

Mesh does require a WiFi connection between nodes, unless you can wire them together. Wifi 5 and 6 use 5ghz and will be equally affected by the granite.

The best way to try and overcome this is if the floors are better at allowing the signal through, place one node above the room with the router connected node, then hopefully a node in the other room below can connect to that node.

You can get WiFi mapping apps on your phone, start with 1 node, find a location that gets the best connection, place a node there, then rinse and repeat.

biggiles

2,190 posts

256 months

sib8292 said:
Until recently I used a Powerline extender to provide WiFi to the other side of the wall, which was sufficient but an upgrade of the Livebox seems to have resulted in the extender no longer working. Some sort of compatibility problem I expect.
Changes in the livebox (I remember those!) shouldn't "break" the Powerline or extender- they work on basic ethernet functionality which hasn't really changed for decades. So you should be able to fix it with some config - my bet is that it's probably static vs. DHCP IP settings in the config of either device.

Much as I'd like to recommend Deco/other mesh, with those sorts of walls I'd suggest best to fix the powerline setup.

If you want to throw a bit of money at the problem and just know it will work when you get there, then look at the Deco Powerline mesh units (P9?) to replace your Powerline+extender setup.

onny

358 posts

293 months

Yesterday (04:40)
quotequote all
biggiles said:
sib8292 said:
Until recently I used a Powerline extender to provide WiFi to the other side of the wall, which was sufficient but an upgrade of the Livebox seems to have resulted in the extender no longer working. Some sort of compatibility problem I expect.
Changes in the livebox (I remember those!) shouldn't "break" the Powerline or extender- they work on basic ethernet functionality which hasn't really changed for decades. So you should be able to fix it with some config - my bet is that it's probably static vs. DHCP IP settings in the config of either device.

Much as I'd like to recommend Deco/other mesh, with those sorts of walls I'd suggest best to fix the powerline setup.

If you want to throw a bit of money at the problem and just know it will work when you get there, then look at the Deco Powerline mesh units (P9?) to replace your Powerline+extender setup.
Totally agree. Its definitely something with the Livebox. Your powerline extender is the best bet with your house walls etc. Much easier and cheaper to either check the Livebox settings as the update has reset some setting there or get a new modem router to replace the Orange Livebox.

From your brief description sounds like you have copper ADSL/VDSL2 connection so a cheap compatible modem / router will be under 40 quid. If you can't connect into the admin setting of the Livebox via wifi or ethernet cable then just google your current Livebox model and get one that is compatible and you should be good after a quick setup.


Edited by onny on Tuesday 17th November 04:46