Stainless Steel v Ply\Clad pans
Stainless Steel v Ply\Clad pans
Author
Discussion

JimM169

Original Poster:

847 posts

153 months

Looking at getting a saucier\sauteuse\chef style pan but going to go a bit more cheffy and give the non-stick a miss

Procook do a SS one with a pretty thick base for a reasonable price

https://www.procook.co.uk/product/procook-professi...

or is the additional cost of a multiply one like the Made In worth the extra expense ie double the price!

https://www.madeincookware.co.uk/products/stainles...

it'll be used on a induction hob and the Aga when I fire it back up for winter

Thanks

Scabutz

8,911 posts

111 months

Dont have experience of either make, but I cant see how one pan is going to be double as good. I would buy another pan from the cheaper range. However, the more expensive one does come with a lid which would be useful so not sure. Not helpful I know!

Big Nanas

4,344 posts

115 months

I've got a Samuel Groves chefs pan, which is good but is only 3 ply compared to the 5 ply from Made In, and it's more expensive than the Made In.

I think those Made In pans look superb, actually.

jodypress

2,129 posts

305 months

JimM169 said:
Looking at getting a saucier\sauteuse\chef style pan but going to go a bit more cheffy and give the non-stick a miss

Procook do a SS one with a pretty thick base for a reasonable price

https://www.procook.co.uk/product/procook-professi...

or is the additional cost of a multiply one like the Made In worth the extra expense ie double the price!

https://www.madeincookware.co.uk/products/stainles...

it'll be used on a induction hob and the Aga when I fire it back up for winter

Thanks
I ditched all my non-stick stuff as got fed up with them being stick after a while. Went fully stainless steel. Pots were from John Lewis and very good.
My frying pans are Merten & Storck 20cm, 26cm and 30cm Frying Pan and switched to a Procook wok.

https://www.procook.co.uk/product/elite-triply-sig...

I have to say the Procook Elite Signature Wok is excellent. Wish I'd got their frying pans too (the Merten & Storck are ok but have discoloured compared to the John Lewis and Procook stuff)

I've heard good things about Made In but they're a bit pricier for me tbh,.

21TonyK

13,406 posts

240 months

28cm is a large pan for induction where it will heat the centre and not to the edge as your aga will (I'm assuming its a solid top?)

A pan with a base made from various layers which improve heat conductivity and distribution will help a bit but to be honest, probably not enough.

I'd just go with he procook pan with a lid which is another 26 quid but its glas which is better than the other one anyway.

JimM169

Original Poster:

847 posts

153 months

21TonyK said:
28cm is a large pan for induction where it will heat the centre and not to the edge as your aga will (I'm assuming its a solid top?)

A pan with a base made from various layers which improve heat conductivity and distribution will help a bit but to be honest, probably not enough.

I'd just go with he procook pan with a lid which is another 26 quid but its glas which is better than the other one anyway.
I did wonder about the size especially as mainly cook for myself at the moment but there are 3 of us in the household so the extra capacity may be useful at times. Shame the Procook doesn't come in a 25cm like the Made In (the 18cm cooking surface would be better fit to the induction as well )


21TonyK

13,406 posts

240 months

JimM169 said:
21TonyK said:
28cm is a large pan for induction where it will heat the centre and not to the edge as your aga will (I'm assuming its a solid top?)

A pan with a base made from various layers which improve heat conductivity and distribution will help a bit but to be honest, probably not enough.

I'd just go with he procook pan with a lid which is another 26 quid but its glas which is better than the other one anyway.
I did wonder about the size especially as mainly cook for myself at the moment but there are 3 of us in the household so the extra capacity may be useful at times. Shame the Procook doesn't come in a 25cm like the Made In (the 18cm cooking surface would be better fit to the induction as well )
A 28cm pan is not good for one portion. Most of mine are that sort of size and now the kids are gone and its just two of use I use 24cm pans for most stuff.

Half way?

https://www.amazon.co.uk/Samuel-Groves-Compatible-...

Not used one of these but they have a decent reputation.

MajorMantra

1,718 posts

143 months

I have 3 Procook pans from the top tri-ply range and they're very nice. I previously had one from the middle range and it was decent but I reckon the heat distribution was worse.

I have a cheap induction hob and it does 'hotspot' with all pans to some degree, but some are definitely worse than others. I miss my old gas hob but getting gas in my current place would be more trouble than it's worth...


JimM169

Original Poster:

847 posts

153 months

Yesterday (14:37)
quotequote all
21TonyK said:
A 28cm pan is not good for one portion. Most of mine are that sort of size and now the kids are gone and its just two of use I use 24cm pans for most stuff.

Half way?

https://www.amazon.co.uk/Samuel-Groves-Compatible-...

Not used one of these but they have a decent reputation.
Was tempted by that SG pan then found this

https://kuhnrikon.com/ch_en/culinary-fiveply-wok-u...

It's a bit smaller at 24cm but has higher sides which is more the style I'm after (not sure I'd call it a wok though!). Also a bit thicker, reading the reviews the SG is actually 2.5mm whereas the KR is a proper 3.2mm so should be a bit more induction proof if my daughter gets her hands on it! Best of all it was only £80 on the KR Outlet shop on ebay (Think I got the last one!!) smile



netherfield

3,209 posts

215 months

Yesterday (20:06)
quotequote all
Lodge Cast Iron

MajorMantra

1,718 posts

143 months

Yesterday (20:26)
quotequote all
netherfield said:
Lodge Cast Iron
Again it's maybe an issue with my not-brilliant (Stoves) induction hob, but the heat distribution with cast iron is really not great. The middle of the pan can be absolutely ripping hot while the edges are just warm. Cast iron is a poor thermal conductor so maybe that's not surprising.

When I had a gas hob I had a good method for indoor pizza where I'd blast it in a cast iron pan to cook the base, and then stick it under the grill to finish. I've struggled to reproduce this with the induction hob as the middle of the base burns before the edges are cooked.