Showrooms - why such a miserable experience?
Discussion
The lease on my company Polestar 2 is up in February so I'm looking for a new car.
I've been to a couple of dealers and I've been struck by what a crap experience it is considering the amount of money involved.
What's been mostly good, from memory - Polestar 4 years ago. It was a unit in Westfield shopping centre. I booked a test drive and turned up. In the unit there was a car to sit in, all the colours and trims available in large samples so, if I'd had the budget, I could have compared how the various grey paints looked against the various grey seat fabrics.
The test drive was being shown a car, and being told to drive to the Albert Hall and back using the route pre-programmed into the sat nav.
My local Volvo, again has swatches of fabric and paints and a large area with desks and wi-fi so I can work while my car is being serviced or MOT'd. Actually getting hold of someone when I actually want to pay for the service is another thing altogether...
As we've got an XC40 as a family car I don't need anything as big as a Polestar this time round.
I thought I'd try a Renault 5 so I book a test drive on Saturday afternoon.
First problem when I get there? Nowhere to park. I got lucky as someone was leaving so I shoehorned the Polestar into a space in the back of the dealership.
The drive consisted of a trip around the industrial estate with the salesman.
I swear that a Big Yellow Storage depot has more ambience than that Renault/Dacia dealership. What got me was that there were no samples of the paints or stickers that I could see and I'm not going to choose based on a render on the configurator.
Perfectly nice car.
This afternoon I went to sit in an Alfa Romeo Junior. Again, this is a big dealership out of the town centre and there were literally no parking spaces. The front of the lot was full of stock. They were even parking stock on the verge outside the dealership. I had to park in a muddy lane and walk. Stop ordering so much f
king stock if you've nowhere to put it.
At least for the Alfa Romeos they had paint samples and little seats. For the other brands of cars, which were Jeep, MG and Subaru, I couldn't see anything of the sort.
Seriously, if you went into Sainsbury's and you couldn't park because the car park was full of stock and delivery lorries or you couldn't see the produce but had to choose from a not very accurate picture you'd walk off so why do dealers make customers the last thing on their minds?
Is it too much to ask that there are 5 spaces reserved for customers, that there's samples of the colours and trims, that test drives take in a variety of different roads and perhaps the showrooms have a few posters of cars or something to lift them from being scruffy white boxes?
I've been to a couple of dealers and I've been struck by what a crap experience it is considering the amount of money involved.
What's been mostly good, from memory - Polestar 4 years ago. It was a unit in Westfield shopping centre. I booked a test drive and turned up. In the unit there was a car to sit in, all the colours and trims available in large samples so, if I'd had the budget, I could have compared how the various grey paints looked against the various grey seat fabrics.
The test drive was being shown a car, and being told to drive to the Albert Hall and back using the route pre-programmed into the sat nav.
My local Volvo, again has swatches of fabric and paints and a large area with desks and wi-fi so I can work while my car is being serviced or MOT'd. Actually getting hold of someone when I actually want to pay for the service is another thing altogether...
As we've got an XC40 as a family car I don't need anything as big as a Polestar this time round.
I thought I'd try a Renault 5 so I book a test drive on Saturday afternoon.
First problem when I get there? Nowhere to park. I got lucky as someone was leaving so I shoehorned the Polestar into a space in the back of the dealership.
The drive consisted of a trip around the industrial estate with the salesman.
I swear that a Big Yellow Storage depot has more ambience than that Renault/Dacia dealership. What got me was that there were no samples of the paints or stickers that I could see and I'm not going to choose based on a render on the configurator.
Perfectly nice car.
This afternoon I went to sit in an Alfa Romeo Junior. Again, this is a big dealership out of the town centre and there were literally no parking spaces. The front of the lot was full of stock. They were even parking stock on the verge outside the dealership. I had to park in a muddy lane and walk. Stop ordering so much f
king stock if you've nowhere to put it.At least for the Alfa Romeos they had paint samples and little seats. For the other brands of cars, which were Jeep, MG and Subaru, I couldn't see anything of the sort.
Seriously, if you went into Sainsbury's and you couldn't park because the car park was full of stock and delivery lorries or you couldn't see the produce but had to choose from a not very accurate picture you'd walk off so why do dealers make customers the last thing on their minds?
Is it too much to ask that there are 5 spaces reserved for customers, that there's samples of the colours and trims, that test drives take in a variety of different roads and perhaps the showrooms have a few posters of cars or something to lift them from being scruffy white boxes?
Ah yes the fight for parking at main dealer. Audi is always a roll of the dice because if you get all the way in and there isn’t a space, it can be a hell of a job reversing back out if people have dumped them in places they shouldn’t be. Local Volvo and the BMW dealer are the same. Merc is pretty good to park though.
When I was a kid I used to love going to the dealer. Especially the Ford dealership. They used to have bright coloured alloy wheels at the door you could buy for a small fortune. Usually some interesting pictures and Magazines kicking about plus a tv with takeshis castle on loop. Pester for some coins to go in the hot chocolate machine. Salesmen would let me have a sit in an ST or RS and answer all my questions about it.
Then I went to that dealer to buy my first car about 10 years later and oh god had it changed. Salesman was a pain in the arse. The place lost all its charm. It was just cold and dull. No interesting cars in the showroom either. Worst of all, the seating area had been shrunk and moved behind a dingy corner so you just sat looking at a vending machine listening to the service department booking people in and taking calls. Add in the boarded up window and water damage to the carpet and it really spoiled my childhood memories.
It’s changed to a car supermarket now and seems to be doing alright. Popped in to have a look around and I’ll admit it’s a lot better than how it was before. Not got the charm I remember but the sales team seemed switched on without doing the hard sell. Drinks were all complimentary which was nice and they had some fancy air freshener going around.
Miss the old dealerships though
When I was a kid I used to love going to the dealer. Especially the Ford dealership. They used to have bright coloured alloy wheels at the door you could buy for a small fortune. Usually some interesting pictures and Magazines kicking about plus a tv with takeshis castle on loop. Pester for some coins to go in the hot chocolate machine. Salesmen would let me have a sit in an ST or RS and answer all my questions about it.
Then I went to that dealer to buy my first car about 10 years later and oh god had it changed. Salesman was a pain in the arse. The place lost all its charm. It was just cold and dull. No interesting cars in the showroom either. Worst of all, the seating area had been shrunk and moved behind a dingy corner so you just sat looking at a vending machine listening to the service department booking people in and taking calls. Add in the boarded up window and water damage to the carpet and it really spoiled my childhood memories.
It’s changed to a car supermarket now and seems to be doing alright. Popped in to have a look around and I’ll admit it’s a lot better than how it was before. Not got the charm I remember but the sales team seemed switched on without doing the hard sell. Drinks were all complimentary which was nice and they had some fancy air freshener going around.
Miss the old dealerships though
All manufacturers have their idea of what ball tickling experience they want to off customers. And generally it really really sucks.
Who thought of the idea of a dolly bird saying Welcome to XYZ, and then saying "Have a lovely rest of your day" to the 300th person that walks out. There's a complete lack of sincerity. And brand ambassdors. f
k Right Off.
Then you have the Sales Advisors, their smarmy role play as they play games with the sales manager. The whole corporate thing sucks which is why I've bought so many cars on Drive The Deal etc.
When I collect a new car I say to the salesperson: Do you want a 5 star handover rating? Invariably they say yes. And the condition is that I don't want flowers, fake champagne, a bow tie reveal etc. Give me an umbrella if you must. I'll turn up 30 mins early, check the car over, sign anything you want and you get 5 stars for not pissing me off. I'm a real bundle of joy!
But secretly I think salespeople like this, no BS, no fake stuff
Who thought of the idea of a dolly bird saying Welcome to XYZ, and then saying "Have a lovely rest of your day" to the 300th person that walks out. There's a complete lack of sincerity. And brand ambassdors. f
k Right Off. Then you have the Sales Advisors, their smarmy role play as they play games with the sales manager. The whole corporate thing sucks which is why I've bought so many cars on Drive The Deal etc.
When I collect a new car I say to the salesperson: Do you want a 5 star handover rating? Invariably they say yes. And the condition is that I don't want flowers, fake champagne, a bow tie reveal etc. Give me an umbrella if you must. I'll turn up 30 mins early, check the car over, sign anything you want and you get 5 stars for not pissing me off. I'm a real bundle of joy!
But secretly I think salespeople like this, no BS, no fake stuffRecent experience:
Renault have a good online booking system for test drives, booked on the Sunday for the following Saturday. Dealer phoned Monday, agreed afternoon rather than morning as suited everyone best. Parting comment raised an alarm. Phone call on Friday afternoon to tell me test drive was off as car had been leant to another customer whilst there's was in the workshop, fair enough. "Will be in touch to get you out, you're gonna love it". Still waiting.
Cupra have a good online booking system, turned up to be shown around the electric car with 8% charge. Asked for a bit more to be squeezed in, told to go get a coffee. Fine, except the machine is broken. Nice person made us a couple, then got given the keys and left to our own devices. Had it for an hour on a variety of roads, sales person was helpful when we got back.
Don't know if BMW have a booking system, turned up for a look and was pretty quickly offered a test drive and sketched out a deal before we left. Accompanied drive was on a variety of roads for 40 minutes, deal offered at the end was close, bit of haggling and it was done. Would be 10/10 but on collection the valeters err hadn't. Oh well, it was straight into a 300 mile round trip anyway.
That was the test drives, the visiting showrooms to narrow the list was mostly an experience of being mostly left to have a look, but struggling to get assistance when we wanted it, and often not finding the new car we were interested in on display.
Renault have a good online booking system for test drives, booked on the Sunday for the following Saturday. Dealer phoned Monday, agreed afternoon rather than morning as suited everyone best. Parting comment raised an alarm. Phone call on Friday afternoon to tell me test drive was off as car had been leant to another customer whilst there's was in the workshop, fair enough. "Will be in touch to get you out, you're gonna love it". Still waiting.
Cupra have a good online booking system, turned up to be shown around the electric car with 8% charge. Asked for a bit more to be squeezed in, told to go get a coffee. Fine, except the machine is broken. Nice person made us a couple, then got given the keys and left to our own devices. Had it for an hour on a variety of roads, sales person was helpful when we got back.
Don't know if BMW have a booking system, turned up for a look and was pretty quickly offered a test drive and sketched out a deal before we left. Accompanied drive was on a variety of roads for 40 minutes, deal offered at the end was close, bit of haggling and it was done. Would be 10/10 but on collection the valeters err hadn't. Oh well, it was straight into a 300 mile round trip anyway.
That was the test drives, the visiting showrooms to narrow the list was mostly an experience of being mostly left to have a look, but struggling to get assistance when we wanted it, and often not finding the new car we were interested in on display.
Is another of the challenges that in days gone by the salesman/woman might have been a bit of a car nerd who were there to sell a car? Now its more a case of flogging a finance deal - the car is a secondary aspect of it. My recent experiences are that the financing of the car starts to get talked about before a car has actually been sold to me... (hello Audi York).
DaveyBoyWonder said:
Is another of the challenges that in days gone by the salesman/woman might have been a bit of a car nerd who were there to sell a car? Now its more a case of flogging a finance deal - the car is a secondary aspect of it. My recent experiences are that the financing of the car starts to get talked about before a car has actually been sold to me... (hello Audi York).
The saleswoman at Polestar Leeds tried to sell me GAP/wheel insurance and finance even before viewing the car!scot_aln said:
Isn't one of the challenges dealers must have is that many of the booked drives are people who are never going to be buying from them but are just going to lease from elsewhere. That just brings them cost with no benefit?
In which case the Manufacturers need to change their business model so that those people leasing / getting company cars can properly test drive them. As much as I don't like Elon Musk, it appears he solved this problem quite easily.
I went to my local BMW to look at an M5 and had to sit on a chair in a corridor like a schoolboy waiting outside the headmaster's office until a salesman was free before I was even allowed to step into the showroom.
Their service department is literally in a different county to the main showroom so you can't even browse their new cars when dropping off/picking up your car once you've bought it.
Their service department is literally in a different county to the main showroom so you can't even browse their new cars when dropping off/picking up your car once you've bought it.
Truckosaurus said:
I went to my local BMW to look at an M5 and had to sit on a chair in a corridor like a schoolboy waiting outside the headmaster's office until a salesman was free before I was even allowed to step into the showroom.
Their service department is literally in a different county to the main showroom so you can't even browse their new cars when dropping off/picking up your car once you've bought it.
You got further than I did.Their service department is literally in a different county to the main showroom so you can't even browse their new cars when dropping off/picking up your car once you've bought it.
Just wanted them to unlock a 3series so that I could see if would be too low for my missus. Was blocked in by other cars but didn’t want a test drive there and then, just to unlock it and they were ‘too busy’ despite hardly any customers in the showroom.
And that’s another thing, showroom only had ‘X’ this and ‘M’ that on display which they must sell minimal of and no bread and butter 1,3 or 5 series which must be the bulk of sales. Most odd.
DaveyBoyWonder said:
My recent experiences are that the financing of the car starts to get talked about before a car has actually been sold to me...
Similar experience (and has been of the past 10+ years). As soon as a dealer finds out you aren't using their finance the whole thing changes. I don't need a sales pitch, I don't need coffee and extras. Here's the cash, give me the keys.Not... two hours of faffing around and delay of a week+ to collect a car that's in stock.
But... nice showroom, lots of TV's and stock to play with and a big viewing window into their workshops
Having had the short drive round the block with the salesman in the car experience in the UK, I was pleasantly surprised when car hunting in the Netherlands.
Volvo, BMW, Toyota and Lexus all arranged a time, either in person or on the phone, and when we showed up gave us the keys and said see you in an hour or so. We could have had the XC60 even longer as the guy who'd given us the keys then went off shift we had to hunt around to find someone to give the keys to when we got back
Volvo, BMW, Toyota and Lexus all arranged a time, either in person or on the phone, and when we showed up gave us the keys and said see you in an hour or so. We could have had the XC60 even longer as the guy who'd given us the keys then went off shift we had to hunt around to find someone to give the keys to when we got back

I’m not a car dealer but as I understand it they will overstock to achieve quarterly bonuses. And that stock has to go somewhere.
And it seems it’s in customer parking spaces more often that not. Which defeats the object to some extent.
Secondly the experience. I think cars have become a ‘white good’ to many and not a passion purchase. Therefore the sales experience is slanted that way. More like going to Curry’s.
And it is a shame.
And it seems it’s in customer parking spaces more often that not. Which defeats the object to some extent.
Secondly the experience. I think cars have become a ‘white good’ to many and not a passion purchase. Therefore the sales experience is slanted that way. More like going to Curry’s.
And it is a shame.
ninjag said:
What I've noticed is that the sales people don't seem to know the cars they are selling. Not only the actual mechanics of the car (such as telling me it's a DCT when it's actually a torque convertor) but also not knowing about major reported issues (or lying about it).
Had a Volvo “product specialist” absolutely insist that the year old XC40 EV we were looking at was FWD.It wasn’t, the later ones are RWD - but when I queried it he told me he was the product specialist so he would know.
21TonyK said:
DaveyBoyWonder said:
My recent experiences are that the financing of the car starts to get talked about before a car has actually been sold to me...
Similar experience (and has been of the past 10+ years). As soon as a dealer finds out you aren't using their finance the whole thing changes. I don't need a sales pitch, I don't need coffee and extras. Here's the cash, give me the keys.Not... two hours of faffing around and delay of a week+ to collect a car that's in stock.
But... nice showroom, lots of TV's and stock to play with and a big viewing window into their workshops
Sheepshanks said:
Had a Volvo product specialist absolutely insist that the year old XC40 EV we were looking at was FWD.
It wasn t, the later ones are RWD - but when I queried it he told me he was the product specialist so he would know.
lol, it's frustrating because it takes away any confidence with believing the aftercare will be any better. On the plus side, I recently had a test drive and he was left to take it away myself for up to around an hour. It gave me a real good chance to check out the various features, different road conidtions etc. What a difference compared to the previous test drive where the salesman came with me and it lasted about 5 mins and felt like he really couldn't be bothered. It wasn t, the later ones are RWD - but when I queried it he told me he was the product specialist so he would know.
It's annoying because it's tens of thousands of pounds you are spending, not a thousand pound TV, yet I experience better treatment in somewhere like Richer Sounds over £350 rear speakers.
I hate dealers. Last time I had to deal with one this is more or less how it went.
I'd like to buy this car.
Ok great. (Precedes to go through a load of the preliminary bumf)
I'd like it in Red.
It doesn't come in red.
Err, yes it does.
No it doesn't.
I gave up at that point and bought from a different dealership.
I'd like to buy this car.
Ok great. (Precedes to go through a load of the preliminary bumf)
I'd like it in Red.
It doesn't come in red.
Err, yes it does.
No it doesn't.
I gave up at that point and bought from a different dealership.
Sheepshanks said:
21TonyK said:
DaveyBoyWonder said:
My recent experiences are that the financing of the car starts to get talked about before a car has actually been sold to me...
Similar experience (and has been of the past 10+ years). As soon as a dealer finds out you aren't using their finance the whole thing changes. I don't need a sales pitch, I don't need coffee and extras. Here's the cash, give me the keys.Not... two hours of faffing around and delay of a week+ to collect a car that's in stock.
But... nice showroom, lots of TV's and stock to play with and a big viewing window into their workshops
Gassing Station | Car Buying | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


