M3 or F type
Author
Discussion

e30 racer

Original Poster:

8 posts

2 months

Wednesday
quotequote all
I'm seriously considering selling my E46 M3 to get an F Type.
What are you views? Especially from anyone who has owned both.

DannyScene

8,360 posts

186 months

Wednesday
quotequote all
Surely it depends which F-Type you're looking at

ImFeelingSaucy

548 posts

55 months

Wednesday
quotequote all
e30 racer said:
I'm seriously considering selling my E46 M3 to get an F Type.
What are you views? Especially from anyone who has owned both.
Having had both, I would say they are quite different.
M3 is a lot more practical (4 seats and a decent boot) vs no rear seats and a tiny boot in the F-Type.
The M3 felt a bit sharper and more analogue (mine was polybushed with fresh springs and dampers)

F Type was an animal with the 5.0 V8.
More of a hot rod than a precision instrument.
Great fun in a loud and lairy way.
And a lot faster in a straight line.





Edited by ImFeelingSaucy on Wednesday 18th November 12:39

e30 racer

Original Poster:

8 posts

2 months

Wednesday
quotequote all
DannyScene said:
Surely it depends which F-Type you're looking at
It would probably be one of the V6 's.

e30 racer

Original Poster:

8 posts

2 months

Wednesday
quotequote all
ImFeelingSaucy said:
e30 racer said:
I'm seriously considering selling my E46 M3 to get an F Type.
What are you views? Especially from anyone who has owned both.
Having had both, I would say they are quite different.
M3 is a lot more practical (4 seats and a decent boot) vs no rear seats and a tiny boot in the F-Type.
The M3 felt a bit sharper and more analogue (mine was polybushed with fresh springs and dampers)

F Type was an animal with the 5.0 V8.
More of a hot rod than a precision instrument.
Great fun in a loud and lairy way.
And a lot faster in a straight line.

Which did you enjoy the most?



Edited by ImFeelingSaucy on Wednesday 18th November 12:39

ImFeelingSaucy

548 posts

55 months

Yesterday (10:43)
quotequote all
e30 racer said:
ImFeelingSaucy said:
e30 racer said:
I'm seriously considering selling my E46 M3 to get an F Type.
What are you views? Especially from anyone who has owned both.
Which did you enjoy the most?


Edited by ImFeelingSaucy on Wednesday 18th November 12:39
Over the long term, I probably enjoyed the M3 more - but I am a bit of an old BMW fanboy.

The Jaguar was a lot more exciting initially but after a while it was 'a bit much'.
You don't always want a blaring V8, or unintentional (code brown) oversteer pulling out of junction on a winter morning.
At times it felt like being handcuffed to Conor McGregor on a stag do.

That maybe a specific fault of the full fat the 5.0 though - and mine was an early car - they may have tamed them a bit over time?



DonkeyApple

70,901 posts

200 months

Yesterday (10:44)
quotequote all
They're quite different. I'd say the F Type is the sillier car in v8 form and so better but it just depends so much on how you use the car.

e30 racer

Original Poster:

8 posts

2 months

Yesterday (11:46)
quotequote all
Thanks all. I think the only thing is to go and try a few.

Edited by e30 racer on Thursday 19th November 12:59

Belle427

12,052 posts

264 months

Yesterday (12:56)
quotequote all
The V6 is probably more than enough no matter what people may tell you.
I look at them a lot but it's a tough one for me as I would not want to use it every day but also it would be a shame to have it as a weekend car.

e30 racer

Original Poster:

8 posts

2 months

Yesterday (13:00)
quotequote all
I think the 380bhp V6 is probably what I would go for. But it would only be used in the summer. I have a Skoda for daily use.

Belle427

12,052 posts

264 months

Yesterday (15:31)
quotequote all
They are certainly wonderful looking and sounding cars but you do need to do your research as they do have some potential big bill issues.

e30 racer

Original Poster:

8 posts

2 months

Yesterday (15:42)
quotequote all
Thank you will do. The M3 has some big bill issues too 😀

brillomaster

1,913 posts

201 months

Yesterday (18:17)
quotequote all
What are you hoping to get out of a v6 f type that you dont get from an e46 m3? Why an f type, as opposed to maybe a mustang, an e92 m3 or a cayman? Or even an amv8 or an early r8?

Knowing what you want it to be will help determine whether its the car for you.

e30 racer

Original Poster:

8 posts

2 months

Yesterday (18:26)
quotequote all
Well I haven't really thought about that yet. I guess I just feel like a change but i'm really torn. The M3 was my dream car. I still love it. So it really comes down to some test drives. I might decide to keep the M3 yet. I might with the lottery in which case I'd have both. I like the looks of the F Type, the interior and of course the engines and the noise they make.

T1547

1,248 posts

165 months

Yesterday (22:00)
quotequote all
Never had an M3, but currently have an F Type P450 AWD. If you value sense of occasion, sound, looks and Jekyll & Hyde character where you can pootle about in a nice cabin or let rip when desired it’s a great car. Gets a lot of positive attention - never had so many comments on a car.

The Caymans and GR86 I’ve had previously were undoubtedly more nimble down a country road and better ‘sports cars’, but whether it’s an age thing or not I’m really appreciating the Jag’s more refined take on things and GT capabilities.

Obligatory pic:


e30 racer

Original Poster:

8 posts

2 months

Thank you. That does .look great.