Bike journey time vs car
Bike journey time vs car
Author
Discussion

okgo

Original Poster:

42,396 posts

229 months

Yesterday (22:34)
quotequote all
Is there a good rule of thumb you use for commuting by bike? I’m talking about the south east where at peak times a lot of the roads are busy, so a bike could give a real advantage.

If it’s of any use I’m thinking about the Surrey hills into London or at least a very quick terminal station near London.

MrGman

1,672 posts

237 months

Yesterday (23:02)
quotequote all
I’ve ridden bikes all year round, for commuting, chores and pleasure and I don’t think I could answer this, sometimes a car will be quicker if you take getting kitted up, unlocking and getting the bike out, sometimes it might save you a chunk of time if the traffic is stationary. It really is hard to give an answer.

I wouldn’t switch to a bike expecting it to save time. What it will do, is give you the ability to make progress through traffic jams and keep moving 99% of the time, it will most likely be cheaper too if you choose a bike wisely.

I don’t have much experience with central London though.

Michael_B

1,915 posts

131 months

Yesterday (23:16)
quotequote all
I commuted by motorcycle from Walton/Weybridge to the West End from 1992-1999 before moving to Switzerland, and it was massively better/quicker than the alternatives. At least 50% reduction in travel time compared to a car and at the time, free parking.

A bit of a challenge during the colder winter months, but still preferable to being stacked like a sardine with The Great Unwashed in a stty delayed train carriage.

okgo

Original Poster:

42,396 posts

229 months

Yesterday (23:20)
quotequote all
Yes I suspected it wouldn’t be an easy answer.

I cycled from surbiton to London for a decade and I’d often meet a motorbike around Ham area and we’d often see each other again around Temple so I figured maybe it wasn’t as quick in central as I’d hoped. But rather for getting from say Shere to even somewhere like Walton or Surbiton I wondered if it would make a difference there

croyde

26,548 posts

261 months

Yesterday (23:22)
quotequote all
I tended to find that once a journey was done by bike you could pretty much know how long it'd take to get to work, whilst car could take a bit more to a lot longer, and a train could take many times longer with the odd day when it all worked.

But because it rarely worked you'd have to allow longer.

Birky_41

4,668 posts

215 months

Yesterday (23:25)
quotequote all
I would half my car time on Google maps when on the bike going to any of my jobs within 50ish miles of my house

Was ridiculous how much time I would save when there was an accident and heavy traffic

Down side was the bike kit. Fortunately I could secure my bike in workshops but that would also play a massive factor

Steve Bass

10,757 posts

264 months

When I used to commute from Kent to London, bike times were typically 50 to 60% of the time by car including the time taken to gear up in winter. The really noticeable thing was the consistency of the bike commute time.In the car, anything would add an hour. Small accident on the A2, traffic at the Blackwall, take your pick The ability to filter at a speed that wasn't excessively above the nominal traffic speed was nice, jumping lines was nicer and following another decent filterer was king all added up to a pretty consistent commute time. It allows a lot of benefits by being pretty sure what time you're going to be home vs the lottery of using the car.On the downside, winter can be a bit grim, the bike gets minging and your gear needs a chance to dry out or run alternating outfits but time on a bike even commuting was reasonably enjoyable whereas being stuck in the car was soul destroying.

Neal H

533 posts

225 months

A few years ago before I retired, I had to commute a couple of times a week between Norfolk and Oxford - 133 miles door to door.

In the car, a good day would be 3 hours but it could easily be 4+ hours with road works and accidents, both of which were depressingly common.

On the bike it was always 2 hours 45 minutes, so the bike would vary between slightly faster and much faster, but it was the predictability of the journey time on the bike that was the real benefit.

LosingGrip

8,921 posts

190 months

25 mile commute for me. An hour in the car (and £8 in fuel) compared to 35 minutes on thr bike and £4 fuel.

black-k1

12,817 posts

260 months

I commuted daily, 7 to 8 months a year, from Suffolk to the near Waterloo station, 5 days a week, from 2013 to COVID. I can't comment on bike vs car times as I never commuted by car, but bike vs train time, home to office, including the time for kitting up and unkitting, was pretty comparable if I timed exactly right to catch the next train.

What I did notice that was surprising to me, was how consistent the commuting time by bike was. Unless there was a major incident, the journey time office to home or or home to office, 75 miles each way, was consistently within a 5 minute window. That meant that bike commuting was more reliable around arrival time than commuting by train. (That's aside from being cheaper, much more fun - even in poor weather, and far more flexible to fit with my work)




James_0541

137 posts

13 months

I commute to Barrow from Driffield a couple of times a month, on a good day in the car it's 3:40ish, stop at Scotch Corner to grab a coffee, adds about 10 minutes.

On the bike it can take 20 min longer. I can't get a take out coffee and drink it on the bike, the way I can in my car, so a sit down drink gives me a bit of a break.


stu67

892 posts

219 months

Yep I'd say it's generally 1/2 the time of a car. Mine is a 35 mile commute into the city, 50 mins to hour on the bike. The same journey can easily take 2 hours in the car or even longer if the traffic is bad. As others have said it's the time consistency on the bike, in the car it's just random.

okgo

Original Poster:

42,396 posts

229 months

I’m thinking perhaps the easiest and least stress option would be to ride said bike to somewhere that isn’t in zone 1 but gives very quick train link to desired London terminal.

I suppose the next issue is bike theft..!

P675

904 posts

63 months

Filtering through dual carriageways and junctions makes the travel time much more consistent. But if you can't filter it's the same plus gear on and off time.

RazerSauber

2,951 posts

91 months

Hard to say exactly but the more congested your route is, and the braver you are with filtering, the more time you'll save. On my former commute, a bike could save me half an hour easily. My other half's current short commute would take longer on a bike due to faff getting dressed and getting it out etc.

stang65

606 posts

168 months

okgo said:
I m thinking perhaps the easiest and least stress option would be to ride said bike to somewhere that isn t in zone 1 but gives very quick train link to desired London terminal.

I suppose the next issue is bike theft..!
Assuming you have somewhere secure to park, change out of gear and secure gear and are still willing to risk train delays it might be worthwhile? To be honest, I've never known anyone do this. I used to work with someone with a Maxi-Scooter, whose plan was always to go Kensington to Victoria by scooter before train direct to Mid-Sussex. Once the scooter was out it always came to Mid-Sussex and never got left in Victoria. I guess the mentality is that once you're on your way you finish the job. It would also be grim getting back to your bike at the end of the day to put cold and wet gear on. At least most offices have somewhere warm to hang gear, even a coat hook is better than a pannier for drying gear. As you've seen from these posts everyone is going end-to-end.....

okgo

Original Poster:

42,396 posts

229 months

True enough. My concern would be how common bike theft is in Liverpool St area.

Google AI is recommending a Honda NC750 which has full auto like a car, sounds ideal to me.

jrich123

135 posts

223 months

Worth giving it a go, but bear in mind the standard of driving is shocking esp zone 1 & 2, people on their phones, ebikes, 20 mph limits and there is a LOT of traffic lights put in place.

A lot more now vs when I used to commute regularly zone 3 to Paddington up to 2020. Used to really enjoy it but it's just not pleasant any more (my opinion of course!)




okgo

Original Poster:

42,396 posts

229 months

jrich123 said:
Worth giving it a go, but bear in mind the standard of driving is shocking esp zone 1 & 2, people on their phones, ebikes, 20 mph limits and there is a LOT of traffic lights put in place.

A lot more now vs when I used to commute regularly zone 3 to Paddington up to 2020. Used to really enjoy it but it's just not pleasant any more (my opinion of course!)
Yes I can imagine. I commuted by road bike for years from surbiton to various locations in town. WAY preferred it in 2012 era when there were no cycle lanes and traffic flowed. It’s a pain in the arse for a competent person to cycle in London now.

thepawbroon

1,310 posts

215 months

My experience is similar to others......(Carshalton to various places in London - City, Knightsbridge, Euston etc)

Until a few years commuting by motorbike was OK - if you got up early and had a reasonable ride into town. But now it just sucks the joy of of motorbiking for me. I'll be on the train or WFH.

It really depends on the specifics - if you are in Surrey Hills and working in central London, commuting by car in roughly normal working hours all the way, is an absolutely insane idea. You'll average about 2 hours each way, spend a fortune on congestion charge and parking. And get fatigued and frustrated.

A small motorbike will take 20-30 mins off that some days, and in the lighter months some of that ride will be a pleasure. A lot if it will be grim.

If time is most important, you'll probably best best riding to Redhill or Guildford (or similar, whichever is closer) and getting the fast train in. Maybe even Surbrion or Wimbledon - underground car park there! If you don't have a motorbike already, just spent the very minimum to see if you like it.