Who' to blame?
Author
Discussion

jmorgan

Original Poster:

36,010 posts

308 months

Sunday 17th November 2002
quotequote all
Where is the blame? Fiesta breaks down. Home call on the breakdown cover called and diagnose starter motor. OK its towed to a local garage and replaced. All seems OK. Next day wife is pulling into Tesco's and the car dies. The garage that repaired it is near by and she asks them to look into it as they are the last to touch it. Late in the day and all mechanics gone home, manager looks at it and says the battery is flat, not our problem. Whacks a bit of charge on to get her home. The car dies 200 yds from home so she has to call her father to tow to the house,bit too worried to call the break down again. Whilst trying to park the car, by hand, local resident..sorry git says its in the way so more grief.
I arrive home from working away and look into it at around 22:00 to find the wire that should be attached to the changed starter motor not attached. The wire had broken off the connector thus not charging the battery. It was obviously a dodgy joint in the first place, looking at the state of the bare cable. Heat damage and corrosion etc. Should the mechanic have spotted it? Or do the train them just to undo and redo nuts etc nowadays?

Dazren

22,612 posts

285 months

Sunday 17th November 2002
quotequote all
shoot local resident.

DAZ

jmorgan

Original Poster:

36,010 posts

308 months

Sunday 17th November 2002
quotequote all

Dazren said: shoot local resident.

DAZ


Where? the head, no brain. Could shoot out the knuckles to prevent him walking

Byff

4,427 posts

285 months

Sunday 17th November 2002
quotequote all
I'm puzzled, why would the starter motor have any effect on the cars reliability once its going?

Starter motors I know all have two wires - big one straight to battery for yanking and a little one to pull the solenoid in to crank it.

Is it not the alternator thats been changed?

jmorgan

Original Poster:

36,010 posts

308 months

Sunday 17th November 2002
quotequote all
The charging lead for the battery from the alternator goes via the positive on the starter. Looking at it this morning in daylight and not torch light it was never reconnected. Result is the battery recieves no charge but the alternator thinks all is well so ignition lamp does not come on.

Jason F

1,183 posts

308 months

Sunday 17th November 2002
quotequote all
If the starter motor was changed but not correctly then it is the garages fault. Let them know it is their fault, give them a bill for repairs etc.. and inconvenience. I would be sorting out a claim for negligence right now if I was you.

jmorgan

Original Poster:

36,010 posts

308 months

Sunday 17th November 2002
quotequote all
Have been away for a bit. Will be having a word with the manager.
Cheers

dennisthemenace

15,605 posts

292 months

Sunday 17th November 2002
quotequote all
the garage should have spotted the corroded connector and replaced it

jmorgan

Original Poster:

36,010 posts

308 months

Sunday 17th November 2002
quotequote all
In the cold light of day it was never connected. I am very miffed. Wife was stuck with this. Not me. I was miles away working.