RE: London Toll Zone
Friday 22nd November 2002

London Toll Zone

Govt report suggests tolls for 50 mile radius around London


Author
Discussion

DTWD

Original Poster:

14 posts

284 months

Friday 22nd November 2002
quotequote all
It's about bloody time something unfavourable happend to people in London. I was fully expecting it to be tested in a Northen City. Cos the governments of the past have always been happy to screw everyone above London for everything they have.

Paul

PetrolTed

34,461 posts

324 months

Friday 22nd November 2002
quotequote all
eh?

What exactly is it that Londoners get that you want?

Dazren

22,612 posts

282 months

Friday 22nd November 2002
quotequote all

PetrolTed said: eh?

What exactly is it that Londoners get that you want?

Red Ken as mayor perhaps?


>> Edited by Dazren on Friday 22 November 09:29

hwassall

280 posts

305 months

Friday 22nd November 2002
quotequote all
Read about this in the paper this morning. The report said that this scheme would be a test before it is possibly rolled out to the rest of the country so I wouldn't gloat to much. The report also said that they are considering it covering all types of road. The scheme would require a satellite receiver in every car. I'm positive that this would never be used to check for speeding.

joust

14,622 posts

280 months

Friday 22nd November 2002
quotequote all
Oh god - the GPS system again. It won't work, it can't be policed, and a simple 20p tuned RC circuit on a 9V battery would render it totally useless in tracking you, but wouldn't appear any different to the unit than you were driving under a bridge.

If you want a great example of the problems with it - look at the total hash of E911 in the us - they have all junked GPS systems in favour of easier E-OTD systems...

Any GPS based system won't work!

J

markda

836 posts

279 months

Friday 22nd November 2002
quotequote all
The future of our roads is doom and gloom, not satisfied with charging us drugs money for fuel and road tax. They now want us to pay tolls for roads? Where is our road tax going then?????

PetrolTed

34,461 posts

324 months

Friday 22nd November 2002
quotequote all
The thing is that they've already demonstrated that people can't be priced out of their cars. Who would have dreamed that we'd stump up the amount for a gallon of petrol that we now do? The petrol price escalator hasn't made any impact on road usage.

- Widen all motorways. It's not PC and for the sake of an extra 15 yards each side of the road it will make a huge difference to traffic flow. It will be good for the environment to have traffic moving rather than crawling

- Improve the railways. Stop dicking about with them and just improve them. Why can't we have a system like the Japanese?

- Remove bureacracy. Treat it as an issue of national importance and sort out the UK transport system.

- Funding? Let's get prisoners in work gangs rather than locked up all day. They can do the prep and unskilled labouring. That may even give them some sense of purpose or sense of opportunity/training.

- Funding? Don't pay long term unemployed people to sit on their arses all day. Ship 'em to work sites and train them on the job. Low paid workers? Yes, but they'll get a skill and contribute to society and they might even enjoy themselves.

- Funding? Put a stop to compensation culture. If someone is found to be at blame then let the law take its course. Compensation should only provide for physical needs rather than for 'mental anguish'. Money won't cure your anguish.

- Funding? Shut the door on illegal/financial immigrants. Let the countries that they travel through to get here deal with them.

Time for a coffee...

Dan

1,068 posts

305 months

Friday 22nd November 2002
quotequote all
You get my vote Ted, when are you standing?

apeebles

267 posts

305 months

Friday 22nd November 2002
quotequote all
In total agreement with you Ted. I have just sold my house in Reading ready for a year off in Australia. The question is do I come back looking at the way the UK has gone. I.e High taxes on just about everything. For example if I book a free flight on airmiles I still have to pay £50 ish in government taxes!!!! What the !&$% !

v8thunder

27,647 posts

279 months

Friday 22nd November 2002
quotequote all
And where do you suppose they're going to get their revenue once they've priced us all out of our cars, then? Bicycle tax? Renationalise everything? They're digging themselves into a hole and all they do is order more shovels.

Captain Muppet

8,540 posts

286 months

Friday 22nd November 2002
quotequote all
The real problem causing congestion (and a huge array of other problems in this country) is simply too many people. We need to cull the Stupid.

Getting rid of the Feckless, Apathetic and people called Lee would also be a good idea. (joking about Lees - don't start).

rev-erend

21,596 posts

305 months

Friday 22nd November 2002
quotequote all
Ted - brilliant.

Please stand for Parliament.... down with the
Blairite goverment and the useless opposition..

hertsbiker

6,443 posts

292 months

Friday 22nd November 2002
quotequote all
Oh fine. So I HAVE to use the M25 'cos of no public transport, that's going to cost me about £1.20 a day. May not sound much, but over a year...

Why are we being made to pay TWICE ? surely road tax ought to cover this?

Carl

Captain Muppet

8,540 posts

286 months

Friday 22nd November 2002
quotequote all

hertsbiker said: Oh fine. So I HAVE to use the M25 'cos of no public transport, that's going to cost me about £1.20 a day. May not sound much, but over a year...

Why are we being made to pay TWICE ? surely road tax ought to cover this?

Carl


Road tax isn't for roads - it's to discourage people from owning more than one car each.

hertsbiker

6,443 posts

292 months

Friday 22nd November 2002
quotequote all
Very good Cap'n!

I hadn't realised the 50 mile radius thing will cover 95% of my journeys. This is going to be VERY expensive at 30-40,000 miles per year.

What's that work out to? say 35000 * 3ppm = £1050 ???!

FFS ! that's taking the P.



apache

39,731 posts

305 months

Friday 22nd November 2002
quotequote all
look out Ted's thrown a paddy again, does mean a Porsche/Ariel merger coming up?....does anyone know what radius this 50 miles covers? I live in Herts, 43 miles from London and I never go near the place

northernboy

12,642 posts

278 months

Friday 22nd November 2002
quotequote all
Although I am strongly against restricting road access to only the well off, it will definitely make my life easier.

The cost over my 50k miles per year will be less than I currently pay for a parking space at work, and it might actually let me commute at the time I want, without sitting in traffic jams for hours on end.

If I weren't so public spirited, I'd be on the blower now, campaigning for it to extend further out, and to be at a higher level.

Bloody champagne socialists, eh?

IPAddis

2,494 posts

305 months

Friday 22nd November 2002
quotequote all
I have no problem with this idea as long as they put a nice 4 lane wide motorway going due north from Southampton to Inverness. And I mean due north as in a straight line, don't even waiver for Birmingham.

Do not go near London, do not collect 200 pounds or pay the same amount in toll charges, do not get stuck behind M3 commuters who have no concept of what is around them, do not pass through the irritating M25 variable speed limit and do not go anywhere near Red Ken.

It works in transport tycoon anyway

Ian A.

DanH

12,287 posts

281 months

Friday 22nd November 2002
quotequote all


The cost over my 50k miles per year will be less than I currently pay for a parking space at work, and it might actually let me commute at the time I want, without sitting in traffic jams for hours on end.



That's where you are wrong. People can't be priced out their cars. Traffic won't subside, it will just cost you.

Which sadly is exactly the fate in store for the central London toll.

Everyone is kidding themselves that these taxes will be ok, because they'll be able to scoot around/through London in no time, so it will be worth it. Well newsflash guys, its going to stay exactly as shit as it is now *, its just going to cost a fortune.

But that’s ok right, because the cost of living in the SE is so low…

* TfL are predicting a 10% cut in traffic from congestion charging. That isn't going to make any difference, and sounds highly optimistic anyway.

northernboy

12,642 posts

278 months

Friday 22nd November 2002
quotequote all
Oh, I reckon that people could be priced out of their cars.

What about a 40 pounds per day useage fee?

On the other hand, the tolls would probably be more about shifting people off the safe motorways, and through my village, which would not be a good thing.