Internet banking, scam or what?
Internet banking, scam or what?
Author
Discussion

TeamD

Original Poster:

5,060 posts

263 months

Tuesday 28th February 2006
quotequote all
I currently have two issues with banks and internet banking. I wonder if anyone else shares my concerns?

Scenario #1: The bank that gives you that bit extra in the way of charges.

Internet banking with this establishment provides you with access to your statements and a view of the current balance and available funds. However, the available funds indicator is very misleading. The balance figure is that after the overnight run and represents your opening balance for the current day. obviously this can be out of date in respect of transactions conducted post the start of the overnight batch, with me so far? Right, now, let's say that I use my debit card and for some unknown reason it allows me to go overdrawn, I have no idea from the information supplied by internet banking that this is the case, unless I'm smart enough to realise that when the available funds figure is 0, it may well be that my effective balance may be negative (or over my overdraft allowance). But I really have no way of knowing unless I go to a branch or phone them up. Call me a cynic, but if the systems supporting the internet banking have enough info to determine your available funds, they also have enough info to determine your effective balance taking into account transactions ongoing, odd really that this information isn't made available UNLESS, the entire reason for not making it available is to catch you out as regards excess OD charges etc. What do you think?

Scenario #2: The horse likes it this way.

Another effective balance, stroke, available funds issue. So I look at my available funds, I know that I have two transactions that are ongoing for figure X. So it should not be too difficult to say my effective balance is start of day balance minus X, therefore, available funds should be start of day balance - X? Easy huh? Not so, available funds is less than expected, how so? Query bank and discover that reason is a number of reserves on bank account regarding debit card transactions, transactions that have already appeared on statement and have been deducted from the start of day balance. How do you work that one out eh? So my money is being held to cover payments that I've already made.

Just because you're paranoid, it doesn't mean that they're not out to get you!


Tyre Smoke

23,018 posts

292 months

Tuesday 28th February 2006
quotequote all
I think you should consider yourself lucky you cannot remember the days before internet banking, ATMs, etc when you could only use your bank Monday to Friday between the hours of 0930 and 1530.

Honestly, chill out a bit and manage your account better so you know if you are likely to overdraw - or do you expect the bank to wwipe your ass for you too.

TeamD

Original Poster:

5,060 posts

263 months

Tuesday 28th February 2006
quotequote all
Tyre Smoke said:
I think you should consider yourself lucky you cannot remember the days before internet banking, ATMs, etc when you could only use your bank Monday to Friday between the hours of 0930 and 1530.

Honestly, chill out a bit and manage your account better so you know if you are likely to overdraw - or do you expect the bank to wwipe your ass for you too.


Fine, scenario 1 could be addressed by account mangement, but scenario 2 is just downright wrong. It's procedurally fked! Do you work for a bank? Am I supposed to be sooooo grateful for your services that I PAY FOR? I reckon you should brush that chip off of your shoulder before you do yourself an injury.

Tyre Smoke

23,018 posts

292 months

Tuesday 28th February 2006
quotequote all
TeamD said:
Tyre Smoke said:
I think you should consider yourself lucky you cannot remember the days before internet banking, ATMs, etc when you could only use your bank Monday to Friday between the hours of 0930 and 1530.

Honestly, chill out a bit and manage your account better so you know if you are likely to overdraw - or do you expect the bank to wwipe your ass for you too.


Fine, scenario 1 could be addressed by account mangement, but scenario 2 is just downright wrong. It's procedurally fked! Do you work for a bank?No Am I supposed to be sooooo grateful for your services that I PAY FOR? Err, no again I reckon you should brush that chip off of your shoulder before you do yourself an injury. I don't have one, it would appear you do though


Perhaps you should calm down a little?

This is an internet forums section of a motoring based website. My understanding is it provided for entertainment, not for you to wind yourself into a coronary.

falcemob

8,248 posts

267 months

Tuesday 28th February 2006
quotequote all
TeamD said:
I currently have two issues with banks and internet banking. I wonder if anyone else shares my concerns?

Scenario #1:blah blah blah
Scenario #2: The horse likes it this way.

Another effective balance, stroke, available funds issue. So I look at my available funds, I know that I have two transactions that are ongoing for figure X. So it should not be too difficult to say my effective balance is start of day balance minus X, therefore, available funds should be start of day balance - X? Easy huh? Not so, available funds is less than expected, how so? Query bank and discover that reason is a number of reserves on bank account regarding debit card transactions, transactions that have already appeared on statement and have been deducted from the start of day balance. How do you work that one out eh? So my money is being held to cover payments that I've already made.

Just because you're paranoid, it doesn't mean that they're not out to get you!



Could you explain that in English please.....

TeamD

Original Poster:

5,060 posts

263 months

Tuesday 28th February 2006
quotequote all
Tyre Smoke said:
TeamD said:
Tyre Smoke said:
I think you should consider yourself lucky you cannot remember the days before internet banking, ATMs, etc when you could only use your bank Monday to Friday between the hours of 0930 and 1530.

Honestly, chill out a bit and manage your account better so you know if you are likely to overdraw - or do you expect the bank to wwipe your ass for you too.


Fine, scenario 1 could be addressed by account mangement, but scenario 2 is just downright wrong. It's procedurally fked! Do you work for a bank?No Am I supposed to be sooooo grateful for your services that I PAY FOR? Err, no again I reckon you should brush that chip off of your shoulder before you do yourself an injury. I don't have one, it would appear you do though


Perhaps you should calm down a little?

This is an internet forums section of a motoring based website. My understanding is it provided for entertainment, not for you to wind yourself into a coronary.


I wasn't aware that I started this thread as a rant, I expect nothing more or less than the bank to give me the information that I need to manage my account properly and to make my money available to me when I want it. But both of the scenarios that I mention are wrong, agreed scenario 2 more so than scenario 1. What does p1ss me off is your "you've never had it so good" and "do you expect them to wipe your arse" dumbass comments. This thread was opened for discussion, not so you could have a go at me about your preconceived ideas of what my reasons for posting may have been in the first place.

jeff m

4,066 posts

289 months

Tuesday 28th February 2006
quotequote all
Sorry Team D, I'm inclined to agree.
You have to keep a track of your own debits and use the bank as a "check" reconciling any un-presented cheques.

If you mail a cheque to somebody then rush to the computer do you really expect that amount on the screen to be realistic.

dogwatch

6,387 posts

253 months

Tuesday 28th February 2006
quotequote all
Never had any trouble with reservations that I am aware of in donkey's years of using debit cards. If the debit item has appeared on your statement the trader must have made multiple reservations? Should complain to the card issuer.

There was a newspaper story of some poor bloke who got stranded in South Africa because his hotel kept ringing to check the card still had enough credit. However with each call the free balance was reduced by his expected bill and when he finally came to pay it the card was refused - insufficient credit! Had to borrow to pay the bill even though there were no transactions on the card, just a load of reservations.

Tyre Smoke

23,018 posts

292 months

Tuesday 28th February 2006
quotequote all
TeamD said:
Tyre Smoke said:
TeamD said:
Tyre Smoke said:
I think you should consider yourself lucky you cannot remember the days before internet banking, ATMs, etc when you could only use your bank Monday to Friday between the hours of 0930 and 1530.

Honestly, chill out a bit and manage your account better so you know if you are likely to overdraw - or do you expect the bank to wwipe your ass for you too.


Fine, scenario 1 could be addressed by account mangement, but scenario 2 is just downright wrong. It's procedurally fked! Do you work for a bank?No Am I supposed to be sooooo grateful for your services that I PAY FOR? Err, no again I reckon you should brush that chip off of your shoulder before you do yourself an injury. I don't have one, it would appear you do though


Perhaps you should calm down a little?

This is an internet forums section of a motoring based website. My understanding is it provided for entertainment, not for you to wind yourself into a coronary.


I wasn't aware that I started this thread as a rant, I expect nothing more or less than the bank to give me the information that I need to manage my account properly and to make my money available to me when I want it. But both of the scenarios that I mention are wrong, agreed scenario 2 more so than scenario 1. What does p1ss me off is your "you've never had it so good" I never said thatand "do you expect them to wipe your arse" dumbass comments. This thread was opened for discussion, not so you could have a go at me about your preconceived ideas of what my reasons for posting may have been in the first place.



I didn't actually say you were wrong, just that your post seems like a rant. Clearly your level of personal abuse directed at me indicates you are wound up about this and seem unable to have a reasoned discussion.

If you can't discuss this without getting abusive, go and have a ciggy and some caffeine and come back later.

TeamD

Original Poster:

5,060 posts

263 months

Tuesday 28th February 2006
quotequote all
falcemob said:
Could you explain that in English please.....


Okay...an example

Opening Balance 159.62 (one would expect available funds to be 159.62 yes?)
Available Balance 24.72 (ok what's going on here?)

Outstanding transactions: 50.00 cash withdrawal

Alright where's the other 84.90?

Ask bank and in answer get told ah! there is 84.90 worth of reserves against debit card transactions.

My answer, oh!, what the transactions that have already been deducted from the previous days balance to provide the opening balance of 159.62. So what's going on? They've taken money to cover all the transactions but are still restricting access to the 84.90, why? There's something wrong with the process of dealing with the debit card transactions. ie. A bug, deliberate or not? I dunno, but nevertheless something is screwed.

Clearer now?

>> Edited by TeamD on Tuesday 28th February 17:15

TeamD

Original Poster:

5,060 posts

263 months

Tuesday 28th February 2006
quotequote all
Tyre Smoke said:
I didn't actually say you were wrong, just that your post seems like a rant. Clearly your level of personal abuse directed at me indicates you are wound up about this and seem unable to have a reasoned discussion.

If you can't discuss this without getting abusive, go and have a ciggy and some caffeine and come back later.


Wrong. As pointed out previously, it's your attitude that I find annoying. And as for personal abuse, well I hardly think that impying that you have a chip on your shoulder ranks as the crime of the century.

Tyre Smoke

23,018 posts

292 months

Tuesday 28th February 2006
quotequote all
The £84.90 isn't a cheque you have paid in waiting to clear is it?

i.e shows as credit in your account but is actually uncleared funds?

TeamD

Original Poster:

5,060 posts

263 months

Tuesday 28th February 2006
quotequote all
Tyre Smoke said:
The £84.90 isn't a cheque you have paid in waiting to clear is it?

i.e shows as credit in your account but is actually uncleared funds?


No, it's not. It's cash that's been there for ages. There's nothing uncleared and the bank have already confirmed that the reason I wouldn't be able to withdraw it from an ATM is because it's covering payments they've already deducted from my account. I'm glad we seem to be discussing the matter at hand now rather than having a go at each other I'm not going off on one about banks, I'm just exploring an irregularity that I've noticed before but never bothered checking up on, mainly because in that past I didn't necessarily want to withdraw the money that I technically couldn't. As it happens I had a cr@p month last month and I'm short on cash hence the higher level of scrutiny on my accounts and available funds than usual. My point mainly is that moving numbers around inside a computer really isn't that hard, so there has to be something wrong here. I'm sure my customers would be most unhappy if such things happened with their FX trades.

JonRB

80,236 posts

303 months

Tuesday 28th February 2006
quotequote all
Anyone remember "JonRB's First Law of PistonHeads"?

Edit: TeamD; this is you ->

>> Edited by JonRB on Tuesday 28th February 16:52

Tyre Smoke

23,018 posts

292 months

Tuesday 28th February 2006
quotequote all
In that case, have you had a tendancy to overdraw before? Unauthorised O/D I mean? they may be (wrongly, in my opinion) be exercising an element of credit control on you?

Sorry mate, unless you bare your financial history on a public forum, there is only so much advice we can give.

Anyway, whatever happens, banks always win.

TeamD

Original Poster:

5,060 posts

263 months

Tuesday 28th February 2006
quotequote all
Tyre Smoke said:
In that case, have you had a tendancy to overdraw before? Unauthorised O/D I mean? they may be (wrongly, in my opinion) be exercising an element of credit control on you?


Nope. No OD allowance, not been over OD or OD without permission with this account/bank for years now.

Tyre Smoke said:

Sorry mate, unless you bare your financial history on a public forum, there is only so much advice we can give.


My financial history doesn't really have much to do with it, I know the "Whys" as far as they have told me, it just doesn't add up that things should work this way. I'm just applying my day to day problem solving approach to analyse the flaws of their systems. Unless, that is, it IS intentional, in which case I want to know why they would think that such behaviour is acceptable.

Tyre Smoke said:

Anyway, whatever happens, banks always win.


Maybe they do. Maybe they have a problem, if noone points it out to them, how are they to know? But equally so, if I have to draw some cash from elsewhere incurring costs/charges then if they are at fault then I don't think it's unreasonable for me to then approach them to cover my costs. After all, it is my money.

Carrera2

8,352 posts

263 months

Tuesday 28th February 2006
quotequote all
As I understand it it works thus:

Opening balance = the money in your account at 9am that day


Outstanding transactions = any cash / drafts withdrawn over a counter or ATM that day.


Available funds = the above minus any chqs, switch payments, direct debits and minus the above too obviously.

HTH

TeamD

Original Poster:

5,060 posts

263 months

Tuesday 28th February 2006
quotequote all
JonRB said:
Anyone remember "JonRB's First Law of PistonHeads"?

Edit: TeamD; this is you ->

>> Edited by JonRB on Tuesday 28th February 16:52


No, you're wrong. I was only trying to discuss these points but unfortunately some assumed that (a) I was having a rant, and (b) That I'm overdrawn, which I'm not because I already know the way that part of the system works. What I can't quite figure is whether this is deliberate or just consequential (or even incompetance).

falcemob

8,248 posts

267 months

Tuesday 28th February 2006
quotequote all
TeamD said:
falcemob said:
Could you explain that in English please.....


Okay...an example

Opening Balance 159.62 (one would expect available funds to be 159.62 yes?)
Available Balance 24.72 (ok what's going on here?)

Outstanding transactions: 50.00 cash withdrawal

Alright where's the other 84.90?

Ask bank and in answer get told ah! there is 84.90 worth of reverses against debit card transactions.

My answer, oh!, what the transactions that have already been deducted from the previous days balance to provide the opening balance of 159.62. So what's going on? They've taken money to cover all the transactions but are still restricting access to the 84.90, why? There's something wrong with the process of dealing with the debit card transactions. ie. A bug, deliberate or not? I dunno, but nevertheless something is screwed.

Clearer now?

Not realy, but I have never heard of this "Reservations" thingy before. My bank just debits what I spend on my debit card as and when the transaction is put through by the seller. I always know to the penny what will be in my account so I have never come across this before.
Sorry to sound so dense.

TeamD

Original Poster:

5,060 posts

263 months

Tuesday 28th February 2006
quotequote all
Carrera2 said:
As I understand it it works thus:

Opening balance = the money in your account at 9am that day


Outstanding transactions = any cash / drafts withdrawn over a counter or ATM that day.


Available funds = the above minus any chqs, switch payments, direct debits and minus the above too obviously.

HTH


You would expect so wouldn't you? But apparently not the case today.