What degree of cheating is OK?
What degree of cheating is OK?
Author
Discussion

leftie

Original Poster:

11,838 posts

266 months

Monday 6th March 2006
quotequote all

Having watched the Chlesea/WBA saga, and the Time s campaign on dining in fotball, I got to compare football with other busineses.

I am presuming football players, managers and the board agree that cheating is OK at a certain level (diving, claiming handling the ball into the net, pulling shirts on free kicks and corner)otherwise they would put a stop to it.

I wondered where the tolerance level for cheating is in other professions? After all, even by the very high wages of footballers, the money to be made from cheating is as great if not greater in other jobs (e.g. in the city, in drug trials).

I can't imagine my profession condoning cheating or dishonesty at any level (and indeed they discipline people very quickly for even the smallest lie if caught out). If I were to pretend sometime has happended when it didn't I would never work again, the industry would hang me out to dry.

Why is sport different?

nervous

24,050 posts

261 months

Monday 6th March 2006
quotequote all
because sport doesnt matter. not one jot.

Nick P

29,977 posts

282 months

Monday 6th March 2006
quotequote all
nervous said:
because sport doesnt matter. not one jot.


thats not true......

motor racing is very important, if fact more so than debt and starvation.....to the point where my kids have to starve so i can afford a GP ticket.....

best they learn the hard way early on

Mr Beckerman

5,349 posts

258 months

Monday 6th March 2006
quotequote all
I think the most interesting comparison is between football and rugby.

Overpaid chav with the round ball gets booked/sent off and his mates decide to crowd the referee and have a bit of a barging session.

Educated gentleman with the oval inflatable gets sin binned, says sorry sir and trudges off for 10 minutes. Captain is then given a talking too and takes it back to the team. There just seems to be a greater level of respect towards the match officials in rugby.

obviously cheating goes on in both, but it's a bit more subtle (at times) in the better sport.

Raify

6,556 posts

279 months

Monday 6th March 2006
quotequote all
Football could learn a lot from Rugby. For starters, I think that only the captain should be allowed to talk to the ref. That would stop the crowding that happened at the Chelski v Brom game.

racefan_uk

2,935 posts

287 months

Monday 6th March 2006
quotequote all
I think you're all forgetting that football is the most over hyped sport on the planet with the most loyal and rabid fans in the world.

They expect results, goals, to win, every weekend, for almost what has now become all year round.

I think referees should start to use video evidence on the sidelines (like they do in American Football) and actually red card players for plain and deliberate dives and rolling around on the pitch with fake injuries.

Instant 2 match ban for it, they'd soon sharpen up their footballing talents instead of spending 2 days a week at drama school!

Oh, and I can't stand football, its a shit business (not a sport any more)

wolves_wanderer

12,959 posts

268 months

Monday 6th March 2006
quotequote all
Raify said:
Football could learn a lot from Rugby. For starters, I think that only the captain should be allowed to talk to the ref. That would stop the crowding that happened at the Chelski v Brom game.
Definately, they have rules against foul and abusive language and hassling officials, why not enforce them for a change? If players got booked every time they used bad language to an official they would eventually get the message.

Eric Mc

125,920 posts

296 months

Monday 6th March 2006
quotequote all
And, of course, no one ever cheats in rugby

Einion Yrth

19,575 posts

275 months

Monday 6th March 2006
quotequote all
wolves_wanderer said:
Raify said:
Football could learn a lot from Rugby. For starters, I think that only the captain should be allowed to talk to the ref. That would stop the crowding that happened at the Chelski v Brom game.
Definately, they have rules against foul and abusive language and hassling officials, why not enforce them for a change? If players got booked every time they used bad language to an official they would eventually get the message.
Problem is if a side is reduced to, IIRC eight men then the game has to be abandoned - with the way the chavs crowded the ref in the Baggies game, if he'd carded the lot of them, as was needed, then the game would have been off.

scared but happy

24,147 posts

260 months

Monday 6th March 2006
quotequote all
Something I have never worked out is why do the clubs have names? I mean when was the last Norwich player born in Norwich.
Overpaid backward tts with far too much money. Can someone please tell me why they are paid so much when the club itself is millions in the red and are treated as more important people in the world compared to Scientists Doctors etc.

As for cheating with all that money why not? What are they going to be fined £15,000 thats about an hours wage.

>> Edited by scared but happy on Monday 6th March 10:10

Raify

6,556 posts

279 months

Monday 6th March 2006
quotequote all
Einion Yrth said:
wolves_wanderer said:
Raify said:
Football could learn a lot from Rugby. For starters, I think that only the captain should be allowed to talk to the ref. That would stop the crowding that happened at the Chelski v Brom game.
Definately, they have rules against foul and abusive language and hassling officials, why not enforce them for a change? If players got booked every time they used bad language to an official they would eventually get the message.
Problem is if a side is reduced to, IIRC eight men then the game has to be abandoned - with the way the chavs crowded the ref in the Baggies game, if he'd carded the lot of them, as was needed, then the game would have been off.


That's why they need sin-bin in football. Letting your side go a man down for 10 minutes might* help some of the players button their lip.

*that presumes a modicum of intelligence!

Nick P

29,977 posts

282 months

Monday 6th March 2006
quotequote all
scared but happy said:
Something I have never worked out is why do the clubs have names? I mean when was the last Norwich player born in Norwich.
Overpaid backward tts with far too much money.


being an Ipswich fan, i cannot agree with you more.....you are so correct in your observation of the Norwich players being backwards twats.....

scared but happy

24,147 posts

260 months

Monday 6th March 2006
quotequote all
Nick P said:
..being an Ipswich fan..

I see by your profile you live in Norwich. I would not shout that too loudly during match day

teen_cerbera

7,927 posts

256 months

Monday 6th March 2006
quotequote all
Footballers are paid so much as most of them are born lucky. I dont disagree with them getting paid all that much money because, unless the club were stupid enough to get them selves in to financial trouble they can afford to pay the wages of their players, yours forgeting clubs dont do this out of the goodness of their hearts, they too are making a bigger profit than the players

As for cheating? did any one see Ade Akinbiyi for Sheff Utd at the weekend, blatently fouled but didnt go down in the box, the result, no penalty. After the match the manager was clearly telling him he should have gone down. How can you blame them for diving if the referee is too st to spot a real foul, in this case they are only highlighting the fact that a foul has been made, refs need to pick their game up at this level and computers and video refs could help.

JMGS4

8,935 posts

301 months

Monday 6th March 2006
quotequote all
leftie said:
I wondered where the tolerance level for cheating is in other professions?


Judging by politicians there's a very high tolerance level e.g.
Mandelscum
Blunderkit
Portaloo
Cherie (ugly witch) Blur
phony Tony bLIAR
Fatty Two Jags
Tossa Fat Jowells
and many others....
If the world was to follow their examples (which in traffic it seems to be) we are already down the pan just waiting for either the next pong or the big flush....!!!

wolves_wanderer

12,959 posts

268 months

Monday 6th March 2006
quotequote all
Einion Yrth said:
wolves_wanderer said:
Raify said:
Football could learn a lot from Rugby. For starters, I think that only the captain should be allowed to talk to the ref. That would stop the crowding that happened at the Chelski v Brom game.
Definately, they have rules against foul and abusive language and hassling officials, why not enforce them for a change? If players got booked every time they used bad language to an official they would eventually get the message.
Problem is if a side is reduced to, IIRC eight men then the game has to be abandoned - with the way the chavs crowded the ref in the Baggies game, if he'd carded the lot of them, as was needed, then the game would have been off.
Other side gets awarded the game then?

t1grm

4,657 posts

315 months

Monday 6th March 2006
quotequote all
Mr Beckerman said:
I think the most interesting comparison is between football and rugby.

Overpaid chav with the round ball gets booked/sent off and his mates decide to crowd the referee and have a bit of a barging session.

Educated gentleman with the oval inflatable gets sin binned, says sorry sir and trudges off for 10 minutes. Captain is then given a talking too and takes it back to the team. There just seems to be a greater level of respect towards the match officials in rugby.

obviously cheating goes on in both, but it's a bit more subtle (at times) in the better sport.


Or, footballer deliberately kicks or punches a player on the pitch it’s all over the news papers and he's banned for X months.

Rugby player deliberately stamps on or punches a player on the pitch it’s just good old rugger chaps having a bit of afters.

Double standards methinks.

>> Edited by t1grm on Monday 6th March 10:16

Nick P

29,977 posts

282 months

Monday 6th March 2006
quotequote all
scared but happy said:
Nick P said:
..being an Ipswich fan..

I see by your profile you live in Norwich. I would not shout that too loudly during match day


at 6 ft tall and 15 stone, i'm not too bothered!!! I wear my Ipswich shirt around naaarich and have only had the odd comment....usually about how brave i am !!! But if someone is narrowed minded enough to have a go because of the shirt i am wearing, then i'll laugh in their face, before eating their adams apple

Raify

6,556 posts

279 months

Monday 6th March 2006
quotequote all
t1grm said:
Mr Beckerman said:
I think the most interesting comparison is between football and rugby.

Overpaid chav with the round ball gets booked/sent off and his mates decide to crowd the referee and have a bit of a barging session.

Educated gentleman with the oval inflatable gets sin binned, says sorry sir and trudges off for 10 minutes. Captain is then given a talking too and takes it back to the team. There just seems to be a greater level of respect towards the match officials in rugby.

obviously cheating goes on in both, but it's a bit more subtle (at times) in the better sport.


Or, footballer deliberately kicks or punches a player on the pitch it’s all over the news papers and he's banned for X months.

Rugby player deliberately stamps on or punches a player on the pitch it’s just good old rugger chaps having a bit of afters.

Double standards methinks.



Interesting point.

minicity

1,009 posts

262 months

Monday 6th March 2006
quotequote all
My starting point is that I love football. However, I can't abide cheating in any form, in any sport. I have always taken part in sports for my own selfish satisfaction and wouldn't get the same satisfaction by cheating. Perhaps it's just me, but I've seen a heck of a lot of stamping and kicking in recent Rugby Union matches I've seen lately - I wonder if the increase in money/celebrity in the sport is the cause?

The best sportmanship always used to be in snooker where players would even own up to touching a ball when leaning across the table, when the ref hadn't seen. (Of course we don't know that this happened every time.) I don't watch snooker now. Is this still the case?

Oh - and in my profession, any form of dishonesty would be highly embarassing for the person concerend and would not be forgotten.