Environmentalism as Religion?
Discussion
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/sci/tech/4
So that explains why they are all nutters, it's a religion
bbc said:
VIEWPOINT
By Martin Livermore
Environmentalism has become a religion, writes Martin Livermore in this week's Green Room; humans should take off their hair shirts, and enjoy the lifestyles which progress has created.
Hippies on peace bed. Image: BBC
With the decline of Christianity and Marxism, environmentalism has taken the place of religion for many
We humans have an uneasy relationship with the natural world.
It seems to me that one of the main reasons for this is that we regard ourselves as apart from Nature; as unnatural by definition.
In reality, Homo sapiens is just one more species.
Admittedly, a few key evolutionary advantages make us remarkably adaptable and, currently, the ultimate generalist; but it still makes us part of Nature, and our use of human ingenuity is every bit as natural as a spider's web or a swallow's migratory pattern.
Nevertheless, our very intelligence sometimes makes us realise how little of the natural world we truly understand, and puts us in awe of the forces of Nature.
In past times, this awe would have been ever-present. In modern cities we may be less aware, but it only takes a hurricane or tsunami to remind us.
This feeling of powerlessness before the forces of Nature led to early forms of religion.
Although they were replaced in time by the current great world religions, in a strange way we are returning to our earlier beliefs.
Deifying Nature
In the West, with the decline of organised Christianity and the discrediting of Marxism, environmentalism has taken the place of religion for many.
In the words of Frank Lloyd Wright "I believe in God, only I spell it Nature". Googling "environmentalism as religion" returns 854,000 hits.
Rich societies cure environmental problems like urban smog
The new orthodoxy teaches that Mankind is guilty of Original Sin by despoiling Eden (the pre-Industrial world).
This guilt must be assuaged by repairing the damage and protecting all other forms of life.
For the deepest Greens, the only real solution is the disappearance of our species from the Earth - the ultimate sacrifice - and for many others a much smaller "optimum" population of humans is a desirable goal.
I have to admit that, in this case, the word "natural" doesn't seem appropriate; what other species would want to become less rather than more successful?
Progress made
In fact, all species affect their environment to a greater or lesser degree.
Termites build complex homes, beavers construct dams to alter the flow of streams and grazing animals profoundly alter the balance of plant species.
People do the same. The difference is that we have a uniquely greater capacity to do so.
But, as this capacity has grown, so has our awareness of the consequences, and our ability to make rational choices between options.
So, in the last half-century, environmental quality in the developed world has improved greatly by almost any measure.
Britons may regret the death of the whale which swam up the Thames recently, but a generation ago it would probably have died in the polluted water well before it got within sight of London.
But in most other respects, it is really impossible to say that an effect on the environment is either "good" or "bad".
At the risk of sounding post-modernist, these terms just represent value judgements; why is a dormouse better than a rat?
And when we try to manage the environment actively - to do what is "right" - the result isn't always what we expect.
Well-meant but misguided efforts to conserve bison in Yellowstone Park by culling wolves led to an unsupportable population increase followed by collapse.
Today, wolves are being encouraged once again.
Actively preventing forest fires (because they are "bad"causes a build up in brushwood. When this inevitably does catch fire, the results are far more destructive than if periodic blazes had been allowed.
We may think that hill farming or low-input arable farming are good because they create ecological niches for wildlife and landscapes which are visually pleasing; but they represent profound changes to the "natural" environment.
Organic farming creates as much dislocation to the ecology of a field as does more conventional management.
So, let us get our perspective right.
We are as much a part of Nature as any other species, and we need to stop feeling guilty about our impact on the environment.
Not many of us, given the choice, would encourage the wanton destruction of habitats or species, but surely our first priority must be the needs of poorer members of our own species.
That is the law of Nature.
Martin Livermore is an independent consultant, with a background in industry, covering a range of science communication and policy issues.
The Green Room is a series of opinion articles on environmental issues running weekly on the BBC News website.
So that explains why they are all nutters, it's a religion
Aye, beem happening for some time.
Google on Prof Deepak Lal and you might find his lecture in Delhi where he described the environ mentalists as new crusaders, environmentalism as the white man's new burden" and calls for the green mob to be resisted as they will be ruinous for poor countries.
A britprof who was once a bigwig in the IPCC openly calls for greenhouse gas emission reductions as it will fight materialism and help with the salvation of the world.
Go figure! At least in contrast the hangdog Jonathon Porritt is openly tolalitarianist in his support of green aims, declaring capitalism as his enemy, with taxation as a legitimate weapon of the state and redistribution of wealth at national and individual level a fundamental aim.
Think about the impact of the latest econutter calls for Gordy to set a carbon budget and for individuals to have carbon credits - literally as a carbon credit card.
The 'carbon cost' of EVERYTHING woould be determined e.g. emissions as a result of production and transportation of goods (etc etc etc) and we would only be allowed to 'consume' our allocated amount. Wealth would be pointless as nobody could spend it - - without buying carbon credit from poorer folk who couldn't (yet) afford to spend it. This would be tantamount to goving money away to chavs. Brilliant - for redistribution. Bad - for anything such as fairness or encouraging enterprise. At national level carbon would limit GDP. So whether religion or polictics are used (as s2art says) we're stuffed.
And it's all based on a SHAM.
These people are absolutely clueless f
g twa
ing ars
oles who should be sterilised and locked away for the duration.
Google on Prof Deepak Lal and you might find his lecture in Delhi where he described the environ mentalists as new crusaders, environmentalism as the white man's new burden" and calls for the green mob to be resisted as they will be ruinous for poor countries.
A britprof who was once a bigwig in the IPCC openly calls for greenhouse gas emission reductions as it will fight materialism and help with the salvation of the world.
Go figure! At least in contrast the hangdog Jonathon Porritt is openly tolalitarianist in his support of green aims, declaring capitalism as his enemy, with taxation as a legitimate weapon of the state and redistribution of wealth at national and individual level a fundamental aim.
Think about the impact of the latest econutter calls for Gordy to set a carbon budget and for individuals to have carbon credits - literally as a carbon credit card.
The 'carbon cost' of EVERYTHING woould be determined e.g. emissions as a result of production and transportation of goods (etc etc etc) and we would only be allowed to 'consume' our allocated amount. Wealth would be pointless as nobody could spend it - - without buying carbon credit from poorer folk who couldn't (yet) afford to spend it. This would be tantamount to goving money away to chavs. Brilliant - for redistribution. Bad - for anything such as fairness or encouraging enterprise. At national level carbon would limit GDP. So whether religion or polictics are used (as s2art says) we're stuffed.
And it's all based on a SHAM.
These people are absolutely clueless f
g twa
ing ars
oles who should be sterilised and locked away for the duration.I posted a link on another thread, leading to an article showing how 'environmentalism' is killing people all the time. Credible stuff, very down to earth and not pie in the sky or even CO2 in the clouds.
It's certainly not true that flying away on holiday kills an African as that 'toytown trot' Monbiot claims, but IF BLiar and Co COULD stop all warm summers and give us nowt but cold winters, it is an absolute fact that tens of thousands of brits would die premature deaths each winter. The additional toll of a severe Dec/Jan xmas and new year period as opposed to a mild one is typically 20,000 but can go 50,000 up.
It's certainly not true that flying away on holiday kills an African as that 'toytown trot' Monbiot claims, but IF BLiar and Co COULD stop all warm summers and give us nowt but cold winters, it is an absolute fact that tens of thousands of brits would die premature deaths each winter. The additional toll of a severe Dec/Jan xmas and new year period as opposed to a mild one is typically 20,000 but can go 50,000 up.
turbobloke said:It is an absolute fact that nearly 35,000 people were killed (mostly in France) in the 2003 heatwave (the hottest European summer for >500 years).
it is an absolute fact that tens of thousands of brits would die premature deaths each winter. The additional toll of a severe Dec/Jan xmas and new year period as opposed to a mild one is typically 20,000 but can go 50,000 up.
bbc said:Googling for "potatoes as religion" returns more than 2,000,000 hits. "Britney spears as religion" gets more than four million.
Googling "environmentalism as religion" returns 854,000 hits.
bbc said:Martin Livermore may want to go and tell that to the Chilean farm workers (exposed to pesticides that are banned in the US) whose children are being born with a skyrocketing rate of congenital deformities.
Organic farming creates as much dislocation to the ecology of a field as does more conventional management.
>> Edited by polar_ben on Monday 6th March 17:01
polar_ben said:
turbobloke said:It is an absolute fact that nearly 35,000 people were killed (mostly in France) in the 2003 heatwave (the hottest European summer for >500 years).
it is an absolute fact that tens of thousands of brits would die premature deaths each winter. The additional toll of a severe Dec/Jan xmas and new year period as opposed to a mild one is typically 20,000 but can go 50,000 up.
Oh dear. Out of the mouths of babes and True Believers.
Death By Environmentalism said:
Whenever environmentalists prevent the building of hydroelectric power dams in the Third World, they boast of having prevented the flooding of land and the destruction of wildlife and habitat. What is seen are romanticized TV shows depicting herds of elephants, giraffes, and antelope roaming the vast plains of Africa, narrated with manic enthusiasm by the Animal Planet cable network's Crocodile Hunter, to whom every snake and slug is "a real beauty!" And what is also seen are the press conferences where green groups crow about having spared these critters from a man-made ecological holocaust.
What is not seen are the countless human lives they have taken. By depriving Third World people access to the electricity that Western environmentalists take for granted, those people remain mired in poverty, darkness, wretched sanitation, and the resulting diseases and malnutrition that take millions of lives each year. Thanks to the environmental movement, these hapless people's Hobbesian existence will remain nasty, brutish, and short.
Yet few will ever attribute their enduring miseries to environmentalism. Few will link the next plague, famine, or disaster back to green culprits living in New York or Washington.
The chain of causes and effects seems too difficult to trace. Difficult, but not impossible. Let's take a recent horrible example: the deaths of some 15,000 people in France during this past summer's European heat wave.
The French Heat Wave Deaths
According to an Associated Press report (September 9, 2003): "The heat baked many parts of Europe, killing livestock and fanning forest fires, but experts said the heat was more severe in France because temperatures did not drop at night, meaning those exhausted from the daytime heat enjoyed no respite when the sun went down."
However, the high temperatures alone do not explain mass deaths in a modern nation. After all, summer temperatures in the American West soar frequently above 100 degrees Fahrenheit—as they did again this year—without corresponding heat-related deaths. Indeed, climatologist Patrick J. Michaels pointed out August 20, 2003, "the mean summer temperature in Paris is the same as in Detroit, Chicago, and Denver, and when these American cities heat up to record levels…there's no proportional number of excess deaths." What, then, was so different about France?
The Associated Press story gives the following clue: "The bulk of the victims—many of them elderly—died during the height of the heat wave, which brought suffocating temperatures of up to 104 degrees in a country where air conditioning is rare."
This prompts an obvious question: Why is air conditioning so rare in a technologically sophisticated country like France?
In an interview, Michaels told me that a major reason is the impact of environmentalism on government energy policy. To address the alleged threat of global warming, France, along with the rest of the European Union, has imposed steep energy taxes in order to reduce energy consumption. As a result, Michaels explained, energy costs to consumers in France are about 25 percent higher than to consumers in the United States. At the same time, average incomes in France are considerably lower than those in America, which, in relative terms, makes electricity there all the more expensive.
Sure enough, the high energy taxes have worked exactly as the environmentalists planned: they have reduced energy consumption. Seeking ways to cut their electric bills, French citizens realized that air conditioners consume more energy than almost any other household appliance. For the poor and the elderly, especially, air conditioning simply became unaffordable. So, by the millions, they decided to forgo the amenity that environmental taxes made so expensive. Air conditioning, so universal in America, became in France an indulgence of the well-to-do. As Dr Chantal de Singly, director of the Saint-Antoine hospital in Paris, put it in Le Monde (August 19, 2003), the heat wave revealed two classes of French citizens: "the France of the air conditioned versus the France of the overheated."
And the hottest summer for ~500 years means there was a hotter one ~501 years ago - before factories and cars and with a far lower atmospheric carbon dioxide content. Go figure.
Edited to add - and there's a bit of a difference between 15000 and 35000, what source was used for that?
>> Edited by turbobloke on Monday 6th March 17:19
'But still, the French remain maddeningly ambivalent about the technology. Not for the admirable environmental reason that the process generates more heat than cool. It just seems excessive, obese and McDonald's-ish. The only time it is needed is in July and August, when any proper Frenchman is by the sea or buried deep in some rural dell.
To admit air conditioning into France would be to admit American and Asian work practices. Before you knew it, everyone would be on two weeks' holiday a year and forgoing a proper lunch for a sandwich at their desk.'
http://snipurl.com/n8rq
To admit air conditioning into France would be to admit American and Asian work practices. Before you knew it, everyone would be on two weeks' holiday a year and forgoing a proper lunch for a sandwich at their desk.'
http://snipurl.com/n8rq
Are environmentalists the new imperialists?
In a spirited attack on the new cultural imperialism of international greens his inaugural Julian Simon Lecture at the Liberty Institute in Delhi prof Deepak Lal said:
The Green movement is a secular religion filling the void created in the West by the retreat of faith in traditional religions. Its aim is to create a new "white man's burden" and impose its values on the world. The former religious crusades for saving souls has given way to new green crusades for supposedly saving the planet. This new imperialism needs to be resisted — its claim is to save the environment, but its practical effect in many instances will be ruinous for poor countries.
Some commentary on how the green crusaders spread their malign influence.
In May, 1999, Evan DeLucia and colleagues published an article in the journal Science showing the fertilising effect of increased atmospheric carbon dioxide on trees. In a letter to the editor, Bert Bolin, who happened to be the first head of the IPCC, wrote: "In the current, post-Kyoto international political climate, scientific statements about the behaviour of the terrestrial carbon cycle must be made with care..." Translation by US scientist Patrick Michaels: "Scientists had better consider NOT publishing results that might undermine support for Kyoto. Signed, the Boss." If they don't, the 'favoured' True Believer grant-receiving reviewers acting as gatekeepers for the global warming industry will then abuse the peer-review process and cause lengthy delays - particularly if a climate beanfeast is in the offing. It would after all be a shame to cause media disquiet for the false piety of the likes of Two-Jags Prescott and Five-Homes Meacher as they enjoy 5-star hotels and multi-course banquets while the entire population of poverty stricken poor continue to starve. And for the cost of Kyoto clean drinking water could be provided to all who lack it.
Boundaries between science and religion are often blurred in treatments of climate change. The IPCC's former chief scientist Sir John Houghton wrote in 1996 that climate change is a "moral issue." He said that he agreed with the World Council of Churches "which calls upon the Government to adopt firm clear policies and targets i.e. Kyoto, and for "the public at large to accept the necessary consequences." The reduction of greenhouse gas emissions, Houghton says, will "contribute powerfully to the material salvation of the planet from mankind's greed and indifference."
Climatologist Dr Patrick Michaels comments: "This is the chilled environment in which the secular scientist now works. Leaders of the world's premier scientific organisations on climate change now publicly call for the suppression of research findings and invoke religion, and not science, as the basis for policy".
Bunch of @rse.
In May, 1999, Evan DeLucia and colleagues published an article in the journal Science showing the fertilising effect of increased atmospheric carbon dioxide on trees. In a letter to the editor, Bert Bolin, who happened to be the first head of the IPCC, wrote: "In the current, post-Kyoto international political climate, scientific statements about the behaviour of the terrestrial carbon cycle must be made with care..." Translation by US scientist Patrick Michaels: "Scientists had better consider NOT publishing results that might undermine support for Kyoto. Signed, the Boss." If they don't, the 'favoured' True Believer grant-receiving reviewers acting as gatekeepers for the global warming industry will then abuse the peer-review process and cause lengthy delays - particularly if a climate beanfeast is in the offing. It would after all be a shame to cause media disquiet for the false piety of the likes of Two-Jags Prescott and Five-Homes Meacher as they enjoy 5-star hotels and multi-course banquets while the entire population of poverty stricken poor continue to starve. And for the cost of Kyoto clean drinking water could be provided to all who lack it.
Boundaries between science and religion are often blurred in treatments of climate change. The IPCC's former chief scientist Sir John Houghton wrote in 1996 that climate change is a "moral issue." He said that he agreed with the World Council of Churches "which calls upon the Government to adopt firm clear policies and targets i.e. Kyoto, and for "the public at large to accept the necessary consequences." The reduction of greenhouse gas emissions, Houghton says, will "contribute powerfully to the material salvation of the planet from mankind's greed and indifference."
Climatologist Dr Patrick Michaels comments: "This is the chilled environment in which the secular scientist now works. Leaders of the world's premier scientific organisations on climate change now publicly call for the suppression of research findings and invoke religion, and not science, as the basis for policy".
Bunch of @rse.
Interesting - I've been thinking this for a long time too - it's the way than hard-line environmentalists cling blindly to their 'faith' clamping their hands over their ears every time they hear an opposing opinion that certifies it.
Yet another curse of postmodernism - an opinion, a science, a point of argument at best, has become tantamount to religion.
I prefer Max Weber's view - that philosophy and sociology are the true replacements for religion that hold the world's secrets. In many ways they do what religion does - provide a forum for ideas and debate and suggest a way of thrashing out a path of 'right' and 'wrong' - but without the whole 'God' stuff.
Well if these environmentalists see the Earth as their God, they'd better understand that their God doesn't necessarily like them, and can get very, very angry, even if you try to protect her.
Yet another curse of postmodernism - an opinion, a science, a point of argument at best, has become tantamount to religion.
I prefer Max Weber's view - that philosophy and sociology are the true replacements for religion that hold the world's secrets. In many ways they do what religion does - provide a forum for ideas and debate and suggest a way of thrashing out a path of 'right' and 'wrong' - but without the whole 'God' stuff.
Well if these environmentalists see the Earth as their God, they'd better understand that their God doesn't necessarily like them, and can get very, very angry, even if you try to protect her.
Turbobloke, you have a point that some environmental policies are deeply flawed, at best delaying rather than eradicating problems or causing a concatenation of events that means the cure is worse than the disease.
However
The responsibility that you point out we owe those in the developing world, we also owe to future generations. Whether we believe in climate change or not, Asthma, sterility and cancer rates have been rising massively in the last few years and I would like to do someting about it. The answer is implacably not for us to stop industrialising or for us to stop having babies as some environmentalists seem to believe. Likewise, recycling in its current form merely delays the waste of and downgrades the use of raw materials. If we do feel that we have a responsibility to the developing world and our grandchildren, then we need to look at ways to reinvent industrialisation so that products are built with their next use in mind.
Changing to infinitely recycleable design means that we can reuse materials with no loss in quality, again and again. Does this stop industrialisation? No it rejuvenates and opens up new industries. Does it affect the developing world? Only that in the materials that will inevitably still get dumped in their countries they will not have to contend with so many heavy metals and other carcinogens.
I don't think the answer to the problems that environmentalists have created is just to give up on the whole process, it is to find a way to do it better, to combine industrialisation with environmentalism. This is what we should be arguing for, if we truly believe in the value of a world beyond our own personal sphere.
Standing ready to be ripped a new one . . . .
However
The responsibility that you point out we owe those in the developing world, we also owe to future generations. Whether we believe in climate change or not, Asthma, sterility and cancer rates have been rising massively in the last few years and I would like to do someting about it. The answer is implacably not for us to stop industrialising or for us to stop having babies as some environmentalists seem to believe. Likewise, recycling in its current form merely delays the waste of and downgrades the use of raw materials. If we do feel that we have a responsibility to the developing world and our grandchildren, then we need to look at ways to reinvent industrialisation so that products are built with their next use in mind.
Changing to infinitely recycleable design means that we can reuse materials with no loss in quality, again and again. Does this stop industrialisation? No it rejuvenates and opens up new industries. Does it affect the developing world? Only that in the materials that will inevitably still get dumped in their countries they will not have to contend with so many heavy metals and other carcinogens.
I don't think the answer to the problems that environmentalists have created is just to give up on the whole process, it is to find a way to do it better, to combine industrialisation with environmentalism. This is what we should be arguing for, if we truly believe in the value of a world beyond our own personal sphere.
Standing ready to be ripped a new one . . . .
Twincam16 said:Tell that to the self declared enemy of the internal combustion engine, Al-I-Love Gaia-Gore. Have you read his (what could just about be called a) book? The man is barking.
Well if these environmentalists see the Earth as their God, they'd better understand that their God doesn't necessarily like them, and can get very, very angry, even if you try to protect her.
The aircon thing applies just as much to the UK as to France. "Only needed during July and August"? Bollocks. I use mine something like March/April to October/November, and while it is an absolute godsend to have it at all, the level of the technology available in the UK causes me to devote a long web page to ranting and raving about the shit price/performance ratio and general crapness of the units.
Gassing Station | The Pie & Piston Archive | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff




causes a build up in brushwood. When this inevitably does catch fire, the results are far more destructive than if periodic blazes had been allowed. 
