Immigration point system outlined
Immigration point system outlined
Author
Discussion

JagLover

Original Poster:

46,847 posts

266 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
Seems like a step in the right direction. Though we shall have to see how the system operates in practice.

BBC said:
Immigration point system outlined

The system is likely to be similar to those used in Australia and the US
A new points-based immigration system for workers who want to come to the UK from outside the EU is to be unveiled by the Home Secretary Charles Clarke.
The scheme is designed to make it easier for highly skilled, younger workers to enter the country.

But it will be harder for low-skilled, non-EU workers to head to Britain.

Mr Clarke says the system will simplify immigration. But Conservative spokesman Damien Green thinks the government will struggle to make it work.

Doctors welcome

Like similar regimes in Australia and the US, points would be earned for factors such as qualifications, work experience and language skills.

A certain number of points would be needed to be considered for a work visa.

FIVE IMMIGRATION TIERS
Highly skilled migrants, including doctors, engineers, finance experts
Workers with qualifications matching NVQ level 3/A level, including nurses, teachers, administrators
Low-skilled workers
Students and special sectors such as sports people and employees of international companies based in the UK
Visiting workers, such as musicians, working holiday visa holders


How the points would work
The system in Australia

Highly skilled workers such as doctors, engineers and IT experts would get the most points under the system, due in place from mid-2007 at the earliest.

They will be the only group able to come to Britain without a job offer.

But skilled workers, like nurses, teachers and plumbers would be able to come to the UK if they can plug shortages in the workforce.

A person applying as a low-skilled worker would be granted entry to fill specific job vacancies for fixed periods, with guarantees that they will leave at the end of their stay.

Clear route

Other applicants would include students and special sectors such as sports people and employees of international companies based in the UK, plus visiting workers - such as musicians or those on working holiday visas.

Low skilled workers, students and visitors would only be allowed entry if their home country has a formal agreement with Britain.


The points system was first announced in February last year, but Mr Clarke is unveiling the exact requirements of the system for the first time on Tuesday.

He said the new regime would simplify the movement of people into and out of Britain and replace 80 different routes into the country.

It would work in partnership with employers and universities, and in conjunction with the introduction of biometric visas, resident's permits and passports, he said.

"The precise reason for this points-based system is instead of this very complex set of routes we have a very clear route," Mr Clarke told BBC Radio 4's Today programme.

"People will be able to apply online and fill in the forms. We will have a much better control of the situation."

'Chaotic system'

Mr Green said the Tories had been calling for a points-based system for a long time - but he had doubts that the government and the Home Office was "competent" enough to run it.

"There is a long history of headline-grabbing initiatives from the Home Office where they have talked tough on immigration and the delivery doesn't come," he told Today.

"What we have got at the moment is a fairly chaotic system where the government doesn't seem to be in possession of even the most basic facts.

"It can't tell us even to within 200,000 how many people are living in this country illegally. That's what contributes very much to the emotionalism of much of the debate around immigration."

The government wants an advisory board to decide which skills are most needed.



maxrider

2,481 posts

267 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
Common sense.... so they'll never implement it then!

scorp

8,783 posts

260 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
Why do we need all this immigration in the first place, why not fix our broken education system and teach the indigineous idiots here how to do a job instead of importing hundreds of thousands of foreigners onto our already cramped island.

timmy30

9,325 posts

258 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]




The UK Gov estimated that around 70,000 East Europeans would turn up in the UK when border restrictions came down, current homes office estimates are just under 500,000 actually turned up, un-official estimates put the figure at nearer 1,000,000.

I just hope they don't bring in skills criteria for leaving the country.......

JagLover

Original Poster:

46,847 posts

266 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]


Maybe so, but at least we can try to avoid making a bad system worse.

This is of course only the first step; the asylum system desperately needs reform, as, at present, this is the main means by which the unskilled can come to settle in the country.

r988

7,501 posts

260 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]


Quick! Shut the gate

smele

1,284 posts

315 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
I kept reading, but could not find the punchline?

peterpeter

6,438 posts

288 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
scorp said:
Why do we need all this immigration in the first place, why not fix our broken education system and teach the indigineous idiots here how to do a job instead of importing hundreds of thousands of foreigners onto our already cramped island.


would you like to run for PM??

re...the points system...its long overdue.

peterpeter

6,438 posts

288 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
scorp said:
Why do we need all this immigration in the first place, why not fix our broken education system and teach the indigineous idiots here how to do a job instead of importing hundreds of thousands of foreigners onto our already cramped island.


would you like to run for PM??

re...the points system...its long overdue.

police state

4,381 posts

251 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
peterpeter said:


re...the points system...its long overdue.



Too little, too late, the damage is done.

paracetamol

4,267 posts

275 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
scorp said:
Why do we need all this immigration in the first place, why not fix our broken education system and teach the indigineous idiots here how to do a job instead of importing hundreds of thousands of foreigners onto our already cramped island.


Its hardly cramped! ...

Intellegince as well as teaching is needed...what you have to remember is that by attracting highly skilled migrants you are talking about the top 5% of intelligence in the world.

The UK has a double benefit...

1) obvious- they add to the UK's expertise etc
2) less obvious- you take away the best and brightest from developing countries....allowing them to develop even more slowly and keeping them at bay. If I were a cynic I would suggest that call centres are another way of doing the same...take all the graduates of a developing nation and stick them in a call centre...that'll slow progress even further...