Can you think of a single (current) politician you respect?
Discussion
I was chatting to colleague about this very thing today.
In years gone by there were politicians whose views I disagreed with vehemently, but I respected them because of the fact that they were "principled" - the Likes of Tony Benn, Alan Clark, etc. Such people nailed their colours to the proverbial mast and were more interested in principles than PR. However, I can't think of a current politician that is more concerned with product over packaging.
In years gone by there were politicians whose views I disagreed with vehemently, but I respected them because of the fact that they were "principled" - the Likes of Tony Benn, Alan Clark, etc. Such people nailed their colours to the proverbial mast and were more interested in principles than PR. However, I can't think of a current politician that is more concerned with product over packaging.
Gazboy said:
The only ones of recent times I liked were Mo Molam and Robin Cook, but they are both dead (and anti war- why haven't we had a PH conspiricy on that eh? Too much 9/11 that's why!)
Robin Cook? I remember being at Edinburgh Airport waiting for a delayed flight to LHR late one night. Everyone was sat around waiting for boarding, mothers with babies, disabled and old people, and he pushes his way through all of us to board first. What a lovely man. Thats not the only reason to dislike him though...
Mo Mowlam I can agree with though.
Trouble is that the power of the 'party' has overwhelmed the power of the individual MP. Local experience suggests that party whips ensure that your friendly MP will do nothing whatsoever to represent the view of their electors, but will instead toe the party line.
Add to that the trial by media that encourages ridiculous storms, resignations and quiet reinstatements, and very few MPs dare state their own opinion.
The ones that do are quite rare. Locally, David Howarth has proven to be quite good at challenging the scary police state mentality Labour so loves. Boris is always good for a laugh, and actually believes what he says. It's just a pity that the media is more interested in having a go than admitting that the basis for some of his comments are quite sound.
Add to that the trial by media that encourages ridiculous storms, resignations and quiet reinstatements, and very few MPs dare state their own opinion.
The ones that do are quite rare. Locally, David Howarth has proven to be quite good at challenging the scary police state mentality Labour so loves. Boris is always good for a laugh, and actually believes what he says. It's just a pity that the media is more interested in having a go than admitting that the basis for some of his comments are quite sound.
I had great respect for Mo Mowlem. That took a bit of a dent when she (indirectly) called me a 'f**king journalist', but it was the end of a long day and the hack I was doing the joint interview with was being a pain in the butt. So fair comment, I guess.
Her death marked the loss of a particularly positive political role model.
Her death marked the loss of a particularly positive political role model.
maxf said:I think the only MP's who are worthy of respect are the "older generation." People who you know exactly where they stand, aren't interested in sliding up the greasy pole and wouldn't be impressed by some party whip telling them which way to vote.
Tony Benn.
I don't agree with most of his views, but respect him as he appears straight forward and willing to stand up for what he believes in.
I voted for the other lot though.
turbobloke said:Disagree. I would rather someone had principles because at least then you know what you are voting for and what you will get. Compare this to Blair and his cohorts, changing position depending on the prevailing wind.
Can't agree that politicians should be respected for being wrong-minded in a principled way.
Gassing Station | The Pie & Piston Archive | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


