Forget planes on conveyors - try this one!
Discussion
Bicycle (of the pedal variety) standing up (with nobody sitting on it) as is its wont. The pedals cranks are vertical. If you were to push the lower pedal backwards (you are standing next to the bike), which way would the bike move?
Tried the plane puzzle on the Engineers at work, 6 replies so far. All correct with concise explanations.
One of the younger guys replied with the above... My first response was wrong. From smart arse to numpty in one fell swoop.
Anyway,have fun!
BliarOut said:
The bike will move forwards. The lower pedal will move the crank in a clockwise direction when viewed from the crank side if you push the lower pedal back, so it's moving in the normal direction of travel.
beat you by three minutes although your explanation is much better
never was any good at describing things. go on then are we correct?
Pesty said:
BliarOut said:
The bike will move forwards. The lower pedal will move the crank in a clockwise direction when viewed from the crank side if you push the lower pedal back, so it's moving in the normal direction of travel.
beat you by three minutes although your explanation is much betternever was any good at describing things.
go on then are we correct?
I've no idea, but it sounds plausible 
shake me up Judy said:
Bicycle (of the pedal variety) standing up (with nobody sitting on it) as is its wont. The pedals cranks are vertical. If you were to push the lower pedal backwards (you are standing next to the bike), which way would the bike move?
Tried the plane puzzle on the Engineers at work, 6 replies so far. All correct with concise explanations.
One of the younger guys replied with the above... My first response was wrong. From smart arse to numpty in one fell swoop.
Anyway,have fun!
Which is the "lower" crank? Right or left?
If right, the bike would go forwards as you'd effectively be pedalling, if left, it wouldn't go anywhere as the cranks would just spin.
minicity said:
shake me up Judy said:
Bicycle (of the pedal variety) standing up (with nobody sitting on it) as is its wont. The pedals cranks are vertical. If you were to push the lower pedal backwards (you are standing next to the bike), which way would the bike move?
Tried the plane puzzle on the Engineers at work, 6 replies so far. All correct with concise explanations.
One of the younger guys replied with the above... My first response was wrong. From smart arse to numpty in one fell swoop.
Anyway,have fun!
Which is the "lower" crank? Right or left?
If right, the bike would go forwards as you'd effectively be pedalling, if left, it wouldn't go anywhere as the cranks would just spin.
Ignore me - I'm talking cobblers.
minicity said:
shake me up Judy said:
Bicycle (of the pedal variety) standing up (with nobody sitting on it) as is its wont. The pedals cranks are vertical. If you were to push the lower pedal backwards (you are standing next to the bike), which way would the bike move?
Tried the plane puzzle on the Engineers at work, 6 replies so far. All correct with concise explanations.
One of the younger guys replied with the above... My first response was wrong. From smart arse to numpty in one fell swoop.
Anyway,have fun!
Which is the "lower" crank? Right or left?
If right, the bike would go forwards as you'd effectively be pedalling, if left, it wouldn't go anywhere as the cranks would just spin.
No, it works either way... pushing either pedal backward at its lowest point is the same as pushing the other... er, forward...
Gassing Station | The Pie & Piston Archive | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff




