Human rights + legal aid gravy train for lawyers?
Human rights + legal aid gravy train for lawyers?
Author
Discussion

singlecoil

Original Poster:

35,871 posts

277 months

Wednesday 8th March 2006
quotequote all
There's been a couple of cases recently that have highlighted the abuse of the legal aid system
1.the case invlolving the schoolgirl who wanted to wear religious attire to school
2.the traveller family who were evicted from a council playing field

I'm sure there are many more. Is this stuff set to continue? I guess with a lawyer prime minster who has a 'human rights lawyer' as a wife, it is


Police State

4,382 posts

251 months

Wednesday 8th March 2006
quotequote all
singlecoil said:
There's been a couple of cases recently that have highlighted the abuse of the legal aid system
1.the case invlolving the schoolgirl who wanted to wear religious attire to school
2.the traveller family who were evicted from a council playing field

I'm sure there are many more. Is this stuff set to continue? I guess with a lawyer prime minster who has a 'human rights lawyer' as a wife, it is




It's been hoing on for years, quite a number of them have had a very, very good living at the taxpayers expense, not to mention the hidden cost of succesful 'test cases' whereup it leads to changes in costly legislation; not to mention the untold hidden cost of playing the immigration system for all its worth.

scorp

8,783 posts

260 months

Wednesday 8th March 2006
quotequote all
I think ill encourage my 4yr old boy to become a lawyer when he's older, i've never seen anyone outside the world of sports and entertainment make as much money as these guys.

It's interesting how a number of Labour MP's seem to be married to lawyers/barristers, etc.

>> Edited by scorp on Wednesday 8th March 14:43

morrisman

264 posts

249 months

Wednesday 8th March 2006
quotequote all
singlecoil said:
There's been a couple of cases recently that have highlighted the abuse of the legal aid system
1.the case invlolving the schoolgirl who wanted to wear religious attire to school
2.the traveller family who were evicted from a council playing field

I'm sure there are many more. Is this stuff set to continue? I guess with a lawyer prime minster who has a 'human rights lawyer' as a wife, it is




Did I hear recently that a big time Lotto winner had been granted legal aid to fight some violence charge? Jesus, if a millionaire gets it there is a big hole in the system somewhere.

SpaceCowboy

563 posts

267 months

Wednesday 8th March 2006
quotequote all
scorp said:
I think ill encourage my 4yr old boy to become a lawyer when he's older, i've never seen anyone outside the world of sports and entertainment make as much money as these guys.


Unless he's going to end up working for a very big firm, practising in commercial work or specialising in a particularly niche area, I wouldn't bother.

Based on personal experience, I'd be more inclined to encourage him to get a trade behind him.

As for the legal aid points, it's nothing new. Didn't the Maxwell brothers get it following the pensions debacle?

Pat H

8,058 posts

287 months

Wednesday 8th March 2006
quotequote all
SpaceCowboy said:
Based on personal experience, I'd be more inclined to encourage him to get a trade behind him.
I am a solicitor.

If I had my time over again, I'd learn a trade instead.

SpaceCowboy

563 posts

267 months

Wednesday 8th March 2006
quotequote all
I too am a solicitor, practising in PI & Civil Lit.

I finish the 3rd year of my NVQ in Carpentry/Joinery at night-college in June this year. Watch this space. (no pun intended)



>> Edited by SpaceCowboy on Wednesday 8th March 15:58

>> Edited by SpaceCowboy on Wednesday 8th March 16:00

JagLover

46,848 posts

266 months

Wednesday 8th March 2006
quotequote all
The human rights act created a vast new gravy train for 'human rights' lawyers.

ATG

23,865 posts

303 months

Wednesday 8th March 2006
quotequote all
IIRC, the cost of legal aid started to get out of control in the late 1980s. More legal aid was a good thing to the extent that it made access to good representation in court more equitable. However, lowering the cost of litigation obviously encourages people to pursue cases they wouldn't risk if they were having to foot the bill themselves, so it was accompanied by a jump in the total amount of litigation.

The increased cost was not caused by lawyers jacking up their fees, but just because there were more cases being brought. Solicitors weren't getting rich doing Legal Aid work. The fees they earned from it were below the rates they charged for their other work. Most firms only undertook Legal Aid work out of goodwill.

One of the other key factors that led to an explosion in litigation and the cost of Legal Aid were the completely misguided policies introduced by the Thatcher government to "reform" the Law Society and its members. All they suceeded in doing was to undermine solicitors' professionalism. All this Claims Direct and National Accident Helpline bollox has its roots in the encouragement that was given to solicitors to advertise. Until those "reforms" the Law Society did not allow its members to advertise. I remember quite clearly the first advert I saw for a local firm. They put it up in the A&E department at the hospital. Welcome to the "where there's blame, there's a claim" culture. As the Legal Aid cost continued to spiral ever higher, the next great idea to reduce the bill was to allow solicitors to undertake cases on a "no win, no fee" basis. Of course all this did was to lower the initial cost of litigation even further and thus encourgae even more cases to be brought.

SpaceCowboy

563 posts

267 months

Wednesday 8th March 2006
quotequote all
Going back to one of the first posts, whilst Cherie Booth is obviously well known for human rights work, didn't she initially make her name through practising in Family Law?

singlecoil

Original Poster:

35,871 posts

277 months

Wednesday 8th March 2006
quotequote all
My one small anecdote relating to whether or not solicitors like doing legal aid cases was when I consulted one concerning a reasonably water tight civil case (non payment of wages). Virtually all of the questions she asked me related to my financial status rather than the case itself, and when she deduced that I didn't qualify for legal aid she lost interest and could hardly get me out of her office quick enough. Fortunately I won the case with the help of a Citizens Advice Bureau

xxplod

2,269 posts

275 months

Wednesday 8th March 2006
quotequote all
Thankfully the House of Lords ruled against the TGBs today. I mean FFS - moaning that they'd been turfed off a public park. They are scum.

DanH

12,287 posts

291 months

Wednesday 8th March 2006
quotequote all

The pay from legal aid work is shite. Don't worry, not many lawyers are queuing up to do it.

As others have said law isn't really that well paying a career unless you plan to join a top city firm, and it takes an awful lot of time + money to qualify.

Jaglover

46,848 posts

266 months

Wednesday 8th March 2006
quotequote all
DanH said:

The pay from legal aid work is shite. Don't worry, not many lawyers are queuing up to do it.

As others have said law isn't really that well paying a career unless you plan to join a top city firm, and it takes an awful lot of time + money to qualify.


For Criminal legal aid that may well be the case and I am aware payments are not as generous as they once were. But these top human rights lawyers seem to be doing very well for themselves.

>> Edited by Jaglover on Wednesday 8th March 21:15

simpo two

93,087 posts

296 months

Wednesday 8th March 2006
quotequote all
Legal Aid penalises the middle classes. The rich can fight legal battles, the poor can fight legal battles - but the middle classes cannot - they have to roll over as they have mortgages etc to pay.

Pat H

8,058 posts

287 months

Wednesday 8th March 2006
quotequote all
Jaglover said:
DanH said:

The pay from legal aid work is shite. Don't worry, not many lawyers are queuing up to do it.

As others have said law isn't really that well paying a career unless you plan to join a top city firm, and it takes an awful lot of time + money to qualify.


For Criminal legal aid that may well be the case and I am aware payments are not as generous as they opnce were. But these top human rights lawyers seem to be doing very well for themselves.
All I do is Criminal Legal Aid work.

The rates are dreadful.

The average age of criminal lawyers is creeping towards the geriatric, as it is impossible to find capable young lawyers willing to specialise in crime.

I'm getting fed up of scraping along on the bones of my arse and I am seriously thinking about what the alternatives are.

xxplod

2,269 posts

275 months

Thursday 9th March 2006
quotequote all
Absolutely right Pat. Mrs XXPLOD is a solicitor. Doesn't do crime but does do some legal aid for med-neg claims. Claimants are usually thick as pigsh1t or just plain scum, but then she does work in Camden. Legal aid rates are crap - you'd pay more per hour to the average mechanic, never mind a prestige London outfit.

singlecoil

Original Poster:

35,871 posts

277 months

Thursday 9th March 2006
quotequote all
Anyone know if the legal aid rates are published, then we can judge for ourselves if they are any good or not?

Pat H

8,058 posts

287 months

Thursday 9th March 2006
quotequote all
singlecoil said:
Anyone know if the legal aid rates are published, then we can judge for ourselves if they are any good or not?
Dunno about Family / Civil rates, but the Criminal rates are as follows:

(per hour):

Travel and Waiting: £26.30
Preparation and Attendance: £49.70
Advocacy: £62.35

Police station attendance and Crown Court rates are broadly similar.

Police State

4,382 posts

251 months

Thursday 9th March 2006
quotequote all
singlecoil said:
Anyone know if the legal aid rates are published, then we can judge for ourselves if they are any good or not?


Here you go...


Magistrates' court proceedings - Senior solicitor

Preparation £47.75 per hour-
Advocacy £56.50 per hour
Attendance at court where counsel assigned £30.50 per hour
Travelling and waiting £24.75 per hour


Crown Court and Court of Appeal - Senior solicitor

Preparation Senior solicitor £53.00 per hour
Advocacy Senior solicitor £64.50 per hour
Attendance at court where counsel assigned £42.25 per hour
Travelling & waiting £24.75 per hour

Standard/Other Fees

Jury trials (including any case prepared for trial in which no jury is sworn) £221.50
Guilty pleas £117.00
Appeals against conviction £117.00
Appeals against sentence £73.50
Committals for sentence £73.50
Standard appearance fee £46.50

Standard refresher fee
(1) Half day £81.75
(2) Full day £158.25
(3) More than a full day £238.00
Standard written work fee £30.00