Revenge II (a moral dilema)
Revenge II (a moral dilema)
Author
Discussion

Kentish

Original Poster:

15,169 posts

265 months

Wednesday 8th March 2006
quotequote all
A long story but when we bought our house we paid full asking for it as the owners kept negotiating loads of stuff which wasn't included in the price but we could buy from them because they were moving to the US.

Anyway, on the day we complete (they've already jetted off) we get to the house and everything they sold us isn't there and lots of other fixtures such as the kitchen had also gone. The place was also filfthy.

Needless to say we were gutted!

They didn't allow us to go back and look around for about 2 months prior to completion so we had no idea it would be like that.

The cost of repairs was around £10,000, we couldn't pursue them because they had moved to the states and British courts have no jurisdiction (sp?)

Anyway, they must have redirected their post as we had nothing for them at all come to us by post until recently, hence I accidentally opened a letter from their bank and now have their card and their PIN thinking initially that it was the one I had ordered from my bank.

It would be so tempting to go and get our money back!

But I can't, it would be wrong and theft .....although in effect they actually stole from us but I am very tempted to leave their card and PIN number in a dodgy old pub somewhere in town.

What would you do?

hughesieII

12,802 posts

313 months

Wednesday 8th March 2006
quotequote all
Kentish said:

What would you do?


remove the post and go freaking mad on the card....

simpo two

93,085 posts

296 months

Wednesday 8th March 2006
quotequote all
Didn't it say in the contract exactly what was included and what wasn't? Surely you have a breach of contract case, and even if they're in the US they're still British citizens.

Kentish

Original Poster:

15,169 posts

265 months

Wednesday 8th March 2006
quotequote all
hughesieII said:
Kentish said:

What would you do?


remove the post and go freaking mad on the card....


I'll burn or shred it as at least it'll be hassle for them to obtain another and if they forget to mention their new address I'll shred the new one too

ehyouwhat

4,606 posts

249 months

Wednesday 8th March 2006
quotequote all
hughesieII said:
Kentish said:

What would you do?


remove the post and go freaking mad on the card....




Seriously though, I'm not sure I'd go batty on the card myself because, if you were discovered, then you wouldn't have a leg to stand on. The courts WOULD have jurisdiction here, and I'm not entirely convinced that revenge and retribution would hold up well in court.

Now leaving the card and PIN in a dodgy pub...oh yes!

towman

14,938 posts

270 months

Wednesday 8th March 2006
quotequote all
Write to them........

"Dear Scumbag,

thank you very much for the card which we received in the post today. I assume you are now having pangs of guilt over the fixtures and fittings which you stole from us when we completed the house purchase.

It is gratifying to note that people eventually do the decent thing. Could you please advise us of the credit limit on the card as we will be careful not to exceed the approximate £10,000 it will cost to return the house to the condition we were expecting.

All receipts will of course be forwarded.

Love and kisses

happy homeowners.



However, do not use the card!

Kentish

Original Poster:

15,169 posts

265 months

Wednesday 8th March 2006
quotequote all
simpo two said:
Didn't it say in the contract exactly what was included and what wasn't? Surely you have a breach of contract case, and even if they're in the US they're still British citizens.


It did give details in the contract but regardless of their citizenship we'd have had a struggle and it would have cost more money to pursue them than they stole. It wasn't regarded as a serious crime and therefore a US judge wouldn't have given it the time of day, so we were told.

GOM

1,650 posts

259 months

Wednesday 8th March 2006
quotequote all
Not a lawyer, but under Law of Contract the sale is governed by the Laws of England and Wales and you can pursue for breach of contract. Stand to be corrected but I think this is correct.

JR

14,332 posts

289 months

Wednesday 8th March 2006
quotequote all
towman said:
Write to them........

"Dear Scumbag,

thank you very much for the card which we received in the post today. I assume you are now having pangs of guilt over the fixtures and fittings which you stole from us when we completed the house purchase.

It is gratifying to note that people eventually do the decent thing. Could you please advise us of the credit limit on the card as we will be careful not to exceed the approximate £10,000 it will cost to return the house to the condition we were expecting.

All receipts will of course be forwarded.

Love and kisses

happy homeowners.



However, do not use the card!

Apart from why not have a man of straw use the card? Just make sure that you don't conspire with him. What could they sue you for?

Kentish

Original Poster:

15,169 posts

265 months

Wednesday 8th March 2006
quotequote all
ehyouwhat said:
hughesieII said:
Kentish said:

What would you do?


remove the post and go freaking mad on the card....




Seriously though, I'm not sure I'd go batty on the card myself because, if you were discovered, then you wouldn't have a leg to stand on. The courts WOULD have jurisdiction here, and I'm not entirely convinced that revenge and retribution would hold up well in court.

Now leaving the card and PIN in a dodgy pub...oh yes!


Anger would make me want to but time has passed and I'm more chilled about it now so I'll chuck 'em on the fire tonight.

Oh yes, the best part ......they were both Bib

Not very nice people at all, ours neighbours had huge problems with them and they sold us land alongside the house that they didn't own, we found out in the nick of time before moving in. Might have guessed they'd chore everything out of the house.

Don

28,378 posts

315 months

Wednesday 8th March 2006
quotequote all
That is a humoungous moral dilemma, my friend.

Every fibre of my being says these Scumbags took you for 10K and you have the opportunity to get it back. Even though I know it to be wrong.

Revenge is a dish best served cold.

Purely hypothetically speaking...Given that the card ends up in a dodgy pub. Who's to know who withdrew the cash on it? Do ATMs take pictures these days?

rude girl

6,937 posts

290 months

Wednesday 8th March 2006
quotequote all
towman said:
Write to them........

"Dear Scumbag,

thank you very much for the card which we received in the post today. I assume you are now having pangs of guilt over the fixtures and fittings which you stole from us when we completed the house purchase.

It is gratifying to note that people eventually do the decent thing. Could you please advise us of the credit limit on the card as we will be careful not to exceed the approximate £10,000 it will cost to return the house to the condition we were expecting.

All receipts will of course be forwarded.

Love and kisses

happy homeowners.



However, do not use the card!


That's brilliant!

Nick P

29,977 posts

282 months

Wednesday 8th March 2006
quotequote all
towman said:
Write to them........

"Dear Scumbag,

thank you very much for the card which we received in the post today. I assume you are now having pangs of guilt over the fixtures and fittings which you stole from us when we completed the house purchase.

It is gratifying to note that people eventually do the decent thing. Could you please advise us of the credit limit on the card as we will be careful not to exceed the approximate £10,000 it will cost to return the house to the condition we were expecting.

All receipts will of course be forwarded.

Love and kisses

happy homeowners.



However, do not use the card!



thats the kiddy to do.....they'll think about what they have done then ...maybe

Zod

35,295 posts

289 months

Wednesday 8th March 2006
quotequote all
Don't even think of using the card. It would be theft.

You do have a contractual claim against them and would probably get summary judgement. The problem would be enforcement. Are they never coming back to the UK? If they are, an outstanding judgment would really ruin their return.

>> Edited by Zod on Wednesday 8th March 18:47

Ian_S

1,077 posts

275 months

Wednesday 8th March 2006
quotequote all
post their american address, or pm, and ill see they get some nice suprises.

Mrs Fish

30,018 posts

289 months

Wednesday 8th March 2006
quotequote all
Ian_S said:
post their american address, or pm, and ill see they get some nice suprises.


Let's not.

towman

14,938 posts

270 months

Wednesday 8th March 2006
quotequote all
Kentish said:
Oh yes, the best part ......they were both Bib


Did they move away to be USBiB?

A carefully worded letter to their boss (I`m trying to find Mr & Mrs X, who skipped UK after stealing stuff from my house etc) might be great revenge.

Nick P

29,977 posts

282 months

Wednesday 8th March 2006
quotequote all
reminds me of a radio programme i used to listen to called Talksport....they did a phone in once on how people had bought their houses, only to be ripped off when they took possession........some of the calls amazed me.

A few examples:

1)couple turned up to house and ALL windows and doors were missing.!!!
2)couple turned up and the previous owner had taken ALL the wallpaper with her!!!
3)bloke was in house working upstairs after being in house for 3 or so months, when he heard banging downstairs....it turned out to be previous owner trying to take a door he had left behind and realised he wanted after all!!!
4)one couple arrived and the house was covered in faeces when it had been immaculate on viewing!!!
my personal favourite
5)a couple took possession of the house late at night, when they awoke in the morning and looked outside, the previous couple had taken the GARDEN!!!!! and had left only mud....even the turf was gone!!!

moral of the story is.......get a watertight contract with all items listed.

or rent

Gruffy

7,212 posts

290 months

Wednesday 8th March 2006
quotequote all
I'd find the most personable homeless person in the area and ask them to see that the letter gets put in the bin.

Gruffy

polus

4,343 posts

256 months

Wednesday 8th March 2006
quotequote all
Don’t use the card and don’t give it away. They will only claim theft so its not revenge on them but on a bank which has nothing to-do with the issue.

I like the idea of sending the letter saying that you're going to screw them over. Might make them think but then if they had the cheek to do this then they probably don’t care anyway.

I don’t understand why they would be so selfish (well I do but I just think it’s despicable).

Mrs Fish said:
Ian_S said:
post their american address, or pm, and ill see they get some nice suprises.


Let's not.


Quite right, email him the address in private