Scottish Parliament Building
Discussion
F.M said:
I don`t know about nice...Inside perhaps but from outside it looks like it`s been bombed or hit by an earthquake.
Holyrood House looks old and nice, Dynamic Earth looks cool (especially at night) but then that eye sore next to it is best not mentioned! Maybe some neds will get busy with a spray can - it could only improve the exterior.
Sums up the incredible waste of cash it has been. Maybe they should have spent less time picking that reception desk that cost 10's of thousands and paid attention to the structure of the building.
I think it is a worthwhile building.
Public buildings should not be boring grey boxes, they should have money spent on them to make them architecturally worthwhile. This includes things like universities, hospitals etc.
Architecture can make such a difference to people's lives that it is really important that the government pays for _good_ architecture and not grey boxes. Same with all the new residential developments planned for the southeast - make them interesting - not faux-victorian and mock-tudor houses.
Public buildings should not be boring grey boxes, they should have money spent on them to make them architecturally worthwhile. This includes things like universities, hospitals etc.
Architecture can make such a difference to people's lives that it is really important that the government pays for _good_ architecture and not grey boxes. Same with all the new residential developments planned for the southeast - make them interesting - not faux-victorian and mock-tudor houses.
D_Mike said:
I think it is a worthwhile building.
Public buildings should not be boring grey boxes, they should have money spent on them to make them architecturally worthwhile. This includes things like universities, hospitals etc.
Architecture can make such a difference to people's lives that it is really important that the government pays for _good_ architecture and not grey boxes. Same with all the new residential developments planned for the southeast - make them interesting - not faux-victorian and mock-tudor houses.
In general I'd agree, but does the reasoning above justify spending such a huge amount of taxpayers money on the building? It is a symbol alright, but sadly its a symbol of how the MSP's have dug their hands into taxpayers pockets to fund their own extravagances.
IIRC Kirsty Wark from Newsnight was on the Committee. She didn't seem to think there was anytoing wrong with it going 10x over budget. But then, she wasn't paying for it, the taxpayer was.
It's just the elite (I nearly said 'ruling classes', but they're not) busy creaming themselves in a spend-fest of free money.
It's just the elite (I nearly said 'ruling classes', but they're not) busy creaming themselves in a spend-fest of free money.
pzero64 said:
los angeles said:
pzero64 said:That's very true. And it's especially true when the client alters the specification halfway through the project build.
Budget’s are very rarely matched by true onsite costs.
Yes.
The initial budget was completely and utterly inappropriate for the design of the building. Even at the start the 'expected' cost (but not publically) was a factor of 10 more - but that wouldn't have been acceptable at the outset, so it was set low and 'slipped'. And a bit more through complete incompetence...
D_Mike said:And that's the important thing, I think.
I think it is a worthwhile building.
In my view, having a toy parliament where toy councillors play at being MPs is a mistake in itself, but if we've democratically decided we need a parliament then we should have one to be proud of.
I don't think £100 per head of population is a lot for a parliament building that will hopefully last for generations, but I'll be disappointed if we've paid £400 million for a building that's worth half that or less.
los angeles said:
huge said:He'll be tall, then. With long arms and a lot of patience. Holding up a beam while others get on with the talking and the paperwork is not an easy task.
I think my builders may be trying to fix it....havent seen the ers in 4 days ?.....
thats the fellow....last seen chortling to himself around the Wembley area of London
I love it, I think it's a great bit of architecture, though I don't know how the external concrete slabs/beams will age and colour -it may need looked after (read cleaned) from what I remember of city air.
From what I can gather, all government projects run at least 10x over budget, so nothing new there.
Pete
>> Edited by pistol pete on Wednesday 8th March 20:59
From what I can gather, all government projects run at least 10x over budget, so nothing new there.
Pete
>> Edited by pistol pete on Wednesday 8th March 20:59
Gassing Station | The Pie & Piston Archive | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff





ers in 4 days ?.....