Piston Heads Politics
Author
Discussion

anonymous-user

Original Poster:

85 months

Thursday 9th March 2006
quotequote all
Hi all, I see the general feeling among PHers is an anti New Labour one.Fellow posters seem fed up with spin,nepotism,broken promises,stealth taxes and political correctness gone mad.

If the election was this week I'd expect a fairly high Conservative vote from pie and piston regulars.

Does anyone remember PH during the Conservative government, or has PH allways existed under a labour government?

If we had a Conservative government would we all still complain about them as much?

Is it just in our nature to be critical about those running the country no matter how well they do it?

The Dude

6,546 posts

278 months

Thursday 9th March 2006
quotequote all
stovey said:
Is it just in our nature to be critical about those running the country no matter how well they do it?


No, but it's in our nature to be critical when Labour are, in the parlance of our time, raping the country.

combover

3,009 posts

258 months

Thursday 9th March 2006
quotequote all
I think Labour has done so much to harm the cause of the petrol head lately that a less interventionist non-Tony led government can only mean better things.

Combover

anonymous-user

Original Poster:

85 months

Thursday 9th March 2006
quotequote all
Do you think though that under a different government we would still complain as much?

slapmatt

1,132 posts

253 months

Thursday 9th March 2006
quotequote all
I think the majority of Phers are hard-working, law-abiding, tax-paying citizens, which is why they feel so ed over by Labour, who seem to be the party of high taxes, handouts and liberal bullshit.

If you go over to the Channel 4 News forum everyone on there thinks the Tories are God-awful - but that's because they're a bunch of sandal-waering, lentil-eating, Guardian readers.

Ecks Ridgehead

4,285 posts

259 months

Thursday 9th March 2006
quotequote all
stovey said:
Do you think though that under a different government we would still complain as much?


Absolutely. The problem with politics is that no party's policies ever align 100% with your own, so politics is a game of choosing the "least worst" rather then the best. As such, there will always be things that every government does that even the people who voted them in will disagree with.

simpo two

93,085 posts

296 months

Thursday 9th March 2006
quotequote all
stovey said:
Does anyone remember PH during the Conservative government

PH didn't exist back in 1997.

I was listening to them jabbering on about 'child poverty' this morning. Labour has missed its target to dole out free money to their parents to make them less poor. Trouble is, they define 'poor' as being on <60% of the average wage, which IIRC is £27K. SO you can be earning £16K and still be classed as poor. Myself and most of the self-employed people I know don't even get close to that - we call it w*nking for coins - but can't claim anything as we're self-employed and/or have savings. We have to deal with idiots in non-jobs who probably earn £40K+ but then tell us they want services but have no budget, or can we just do a bit extra for nothing. It sucks.

timmy30

9,325 posts

258 months

Thursday 9th March 2006
quotequote all
I think that if most people of PH were living in council houses, on multiple benefits, with a cash job here and there, and paying no tax then generally comments about New Labour would be overwhelmingly positive.

As it is most PHers are I suspect hard working, tax payers who have been consistently abused by this Government. The fact that is was the middle classes who voted them in, doesn't make the vistimisation any less painful.

I often think that the British middle classes have some strange kind of sado masochisitic tendency.

simpo two

93,085 posts

296 months

Thursday 9th March 2006
quotequote all
timmy30 said:
I often think that the British middle classes have some strange kind of sado masochisitic tendency.

They were duped. Blair and Co trampled all over Major and won the media.

timmy30

9,325 posts

258 months

Thursday 9th March 2006
quotequote all
simpo two said:
timmy30 said:
I often think that the British middle classes have some strange kind of sado masochisitic tendency.

They were duped. Blair and Co trampled all over Major and won the media.




I don't know, I the words of my mother, who I would wager is typical of those who swtiched sides, 'it just seemed like a nice idea to have a change, there was nothing wrong really, the tories had just been in power for such a long time'.

I suppose the old adage, it it aint broke don't fix it applies. I think one term of Labour would have done minimal damage, things have really started to go from bad to worse with their 2nd and 3rd terms, as for the 4th and 5th terms under Gordon Brown I don't think those will be much fun at all.

Don

28,378 posts

315 months

Thursday 9th March 2006
quotequote all
PH Politics is unsurprising given its demographic.

If you're interested in sports cars chances are you want to be able to buy one. Of necessity this means you feel you should be allowed to keep enough of your earnings to make you well enough off to buy something that, for many, will only ever be a distant dream.

Chances are this will reflect a person that leans towards Conservative political thinking.

We have notable exceptions on the board, too, which is fine, and makes for entertaining debate.

jonnyb

2,590 posts

283 months

Thursday 9th March 2006
quotequote all
simpo two said:
timmy30 said:
I often think that the British middle classes have some strange kind of sado masochisitic tendency.

They were duped. Blair and Co trampled all over Major and won the media.


I would agree with that. I think most of the middle classes thought that it could not get much worse than under John Major. They all seemed to forget that Labor's core policy is the re-distribution of wealth, that is what they have done.

Personally I think their tax and spend policy's have been discredited again. Record sums of cash going into the NHS and then record deficits, you have to ask where the money has gone.

I think there should be more say in how tax payers money is spent too, how much did it cost to put up the Scottish/Welsh Parliament buildings?

F.M

5,816 posts

251 months

Thursday 9th March 2006
quotequote all
Labour...Tory.....Same suits...Different faces...The same crappy Goverment.
I liked charles Kennedy while he was leading the Lib Dems..He was one of the few who done his job the way it was meant to...I wouldn`t touch them now though...

ATG

23,863 posts

303 months

Thursday 9th March 2006
quotequote all
stovey said:
Is it just in our nature to be critical about those running the country no matter how well they do it?


Yes, absolutely.

People tend to fear change. They see change around them all the time, it makes them fearful of the future and nostalgic about the past. As a result people have always been of the opinion that the country is going to the dogs, in spite of the fact that when you stand back and look at things objectively it is pretty obvious that life has been getting better. It is nice to be able to convert fear into self righteous anger, so we like to find someone to blame for the "state of the country" ... and the obvious target is "the government". I put it in quotation marks, because of course when you actually think about what any one Cabinet can achieve during their time in office, it is obviously rather limited and highly unlikely, thank god, to be able to fundamentally change the nature of the country (who would want them to be able to wield such power?). On the one hand we want the governemnt to fix everything, on the other hand we want them to leave us alone.

The current government is a classic example. Blair pretty much continued where Thatcher/Major left off. There was no dramatic shift to the left. By an historical standard, Blair's economic methods are centre-right dressed up with an extra dollop of rhetorical social conscience. The difference between New Labour and One Nation Conservatism is tiny.

Did the country reject Major's government in 1997 because of its core policies? No. It was fed up with "sleaze". And now the key criticism leveled against New Labour is one of "spin" (even in the case of Iraq, one of the main criticisms is how it was spun to the public). In both cases the criticisms are not about the substance of the policies, but about perception and emotional reaction.

Plotloss

67,280 posts

301 months

Thursday 9th March 2006
quotequote all
Don said:
We have notable exceptions on the board, too, which is fine, and makes for entertaining debate.


Splitters!

pistonsleeper

563 posts

248 months

Thursday 9th March 2006
quotequote all
NOt sure how many Nu Labia lovvies are here! One here is an active supporter of Labour and has stood for the council in Norwich! Thankfully he did not get elected!

CommanderJameson

22,096 posts

257 months

Thursday 9th March 2006
quotequote all
stovey said:
Is it just in our nature to be critical about those running the country no matter how well they do it?

Too bloody right it is. The government is in charge of too much (of our) money and too many guns for us to sit back and go "ooh, aren't they doing well?".

Constant criticism is what keeps government honest; the lack of a strong opposition is a key component of the excesses of Labour since 1997.

By anyone's measure, MPs get paid a LOT of money to do a job that they love - and a job that they could ALWAYS do better, no matter how well they might be doing.

The striving for constant improvement no matter what is what took Schumacher to 7 world titles, by way of a motoring-related example.

s2art

18,942 posts

284 months

Thursday 9th March 2006
quotequote all
[quote=ATG.

The current government is a classic example. Blair pretty much continued where Thatcher/Major left off. There was no dramatic shift to the left. By an historical standard, Blair's economic methods are centre-right dressed up with an extra dollop of rhetorical social conscience. The difference between New Labour and One Nation Conservatism is tiny.

[/quote]
Not so sure. The Tories, by instinct rather than brainpower, are just not as interventionist. NuLab, in cahoots with the EU, has increased regulatory costs by something like 70 Billion pounds since 1997, and damaged Britains ability to compete. Then there is the good old Labout habit of banning anything they dont like. And look at the latest set of dingbat, unpleasant regs they are trying to bring in (ID cards, glorification of terrorism, protecting religion etc.)

So, there is quite a difference.

pistonsleeper

563 posts

248 months

Thursday 9th March 2006
quotequote all
Hopefully the next General Election will follow the lead set by voters of Hingham in South Norfolk! They voted out the another looney lefty!


HINGHAM
(SOUTH NORFOLK) Steven Dorrington 2000 votes (45.29%)
Conservative

John William Devenney 1336 votes (30.25%)
Liberal Democrat

John Lessels Cowan 770 votes (17.44%)
Labour

Andrew Kennedy Brockbank 310 votes (7.02%)
Green

The Conservative Dorrington won and the turnout was 70.26%

off_again

13,917 posts

265 months

Thursday 9th March 2006
quotequote all
stovey said:
Do you think though that under a different government we would still complain as much?


That is the crux of the problem here - fortunately we are in a country which allows debate and free political thinking (within lines of course!). However, we have such a confrontational system that it naturally brings out the worst in people - just drawn on political lines.

In fact I have met a few people from Internet forums (or is it Fora?) who have posted up some of the most extreme views of the political spectrum, right to left. The problem is that they usually arent some form of raving left wing loonie or some sort of far right money grabbing monster. It is that dont agree with the other side and hence have to take the opposing view - regardless.

The more fundamental issue though is that as a nation we are increasingly drawn on political lines, but dont have an ability to voice our opinions. Politics have become stale and predictable and increasingly the public is suspicious of politicians. How many politicos do we have to see coming out of their £1m homes for a hard graft of 3 hours before jetting off on an international holiday? This is a personal bugbear of mine and it completely alienates the people in power and those who put them there! Security and protection is one thing - but lining your pockets whilst in / out / opposition power is just putting a wedge between them and Mr Average Wage who struggles to get on in the world....

Oh, and to answer the question - there are notable exceptions to the rule, but lets be honest though - demographically most PH members will be right-leaning rather than Grauniad reading sandalista.... its a website for sportscar fans.... hardly the refuge of the environmental friendly?