Jules Verne was an IDer.
Discussion
Yugguy said:
Check it out.
M.Verne said:
Formerly, in prehistoric days, land animals
(quadrupeds, apes, reptiles, birds) were built on a gigantic scale.
Our Creator cast them using a colossal mold that time has gradually
made smaller.
I think you will find that many of that era were. Darwins idea had yet to be fully understood by the bulk of the population. We know better now, apart from a few dingbats that is.
Jules Verne, author of fine books of an imaginary nature. Obviously one of the great storytellers of the age. Not exactly my number one choice for a rational assessment of the origin of species though. Horses for courses and all that. I think Mr Darwin with a side order of Gregor Mendelev would be more appropriate for such a task. Ironic that Mendelev was a monk 

Yugguy said:The two authors you mention were scientists first and writers second. Their works moved beyond "sci-fi" into the realms of "speculative fiction".
I think personages such as Arthur C Clarke and Isaac Asimov would resent/have resented your implication that a writer of science fiction cannot therefore have a valid opinion on science fact.
Jules Verne never let science get in the way of a good story though. He knew at the time that the idea of shooting men to the moon with an enormous gun was ludicrous but didn't let it stop him. Asimov or Clarke, in contrast, wouldn't have written such a story as it would have been anathema to them.
>> Edited by JonRB on Thursday 9th March 15:54
M.Verne said:
Formerly, in prehistoric days, land animals (quadrupeds, apes, reptiles, birds) were built on a gigantic scale. Our Creator cast them using a colossal mold that time has gradually made smaller.
That's in the same league as Gary Larson's cartoon of God making snakes out of plasticine and saying 'Gee, these critters are easy to make!'
It might fool a Christian though...
Jinx said:
s2art said:
No loser, but no scientist either.
He probably was a scientist - the accepted theory of the time was ID based on the watchmaker analogy.
I dont know when he made that quote, but the theory of evolution was accepted by most (not all) biologists by the end of the 19th century.
Yugguy said:
No, it's from 20,000 leagues under the sea, I'm reading it at the moment.
I thought it gave an interesting insight into what was believed at the time.
Interesting, I'm sure there's something very similar in JTTCOTE - I shall go look, and report back.
L8R
No just my aged mind playing tricks. As you were.
>> Edited by Einion Yrth on Thursday 9th March 16:40
Gassing Station | The Pie & Piston Archive | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff






