Deal or no Deal
Author
Discussion

sstein

Original Poster:

6,249 posts

285 months

Thursday 9th March 2006
quotequote all
Does anyone here actually watch this garbage.

It seems to be the biggest show on the tv at the moment, but I just cant see its appeal.

For a start EVERY SINGLE contestant on it look as if they have just wandered of the set of trisha. Secondly is all the theatrics, Noel Edmonds just tries to hype up every episode.

I've seen it twice and twice I have heard him say that the contestant is playing the game like no one has ever played before, or that their hasn't ever been a game like the one they are playing.

Yes there F***ING has, it was last night!!!

In case anyone isn't familiar with the rules, there are 20 boxes (i think), and the contestant gets one. Each box has a cash value in it, anywhere from £1 to £250,000. The contestant has to pick a box in an attempt not to uncover ones with high cash values in them. After three teh show make them an offer of £xxx to leave or play on. Repeat until they leave or theres no more boxes left. THATS IT, every bleeding show is the same.

I even seen one where Noel had all the contestants holding hands trying to make good things happen, and tries to get all psychological. Do people really fall for this stuff.


-

Stuart

scared but happy

24,147 posts

260 months

Thursday 9th March 2006
quotequote all
Can I start the Noel Edmonds slagging? As for some reason it seems to be the 'in thing' at the moment although I never understood why.

littlegreenfairy

10,134 posts

252 months

Thursday 9th March 2006
quotequote all
Some of my friends are completely obsessed with it. I just don't get it, and even though I'm a lazy student living off a diet of day time TV - I turn it off.

Carrera2

8,352 posts

263 months

Thursday 9th March 2006
quotequote all
scared but happy said:
Can I start the Noel Edmonds slagging? As for some reason it seems to be the 'in thing' at the moment although I never understood why.


Probably because he's a dwarven be-bearded clam.

Yugguy

10,728 posts

266 months

Thursday 9th March 2006
quotequote all
I liked Noel's House Party.

I'm sorry.

sstein

Original Poster:

6,249 posts

285 months

Thursday 9th March 2006
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]


No thats the thing, there is no skill to it all.

Its just randomly picking numbers between 1 and 20, and hoping they dont contain large sums.

You just want to shoot noel edmonds!!!

And apparently people have strategies?? WTF!!! YOU ARE PICKING A NUMBER BETWEEN 1 and 20 THAT IS IT!!!!

-

Stuart

Tyre Smoke

23,018 posts

292 months

Thursday 9th March 2006
quotequote all
I'm with you Stuart.

I've watched about 10 minutes of it twice now. It basically works on individual greed. The 'contestants' look like a right bunch of losers anyway.

What happens if the 'banker' makes the first offer and the contestant says yes? What happens for the rest of the hour long show?

anonymous-user

85 months

Thursday 9th March 2006
quotequote all
Tyre Smoke said:

What happens if the 'banker' makes the first offer and the contestant says yes? What happens for the rest of the hour long show?


Then they play the game as if it's still going to see if the person made the right deal or not. It's priceless!!!! Bloke yesterday did the deal at £75K ...Noel made him play on...he had £250K in his box. So he won £75K but was pissed as if he held his nerve he'd have had £250K. Priceless I tell you, priceless

>> Edited by anonymous-user on Thursday 9th March 17:08

Tuna

19,930 posts

315 months

Thursday 9th March 2006
quotequote all
The strategy is deciding when to do a deal. By being on the show you've already won somewhere between 10p and 250,000 pounds - though the odds are in favour of it being less than a grand. The skill is in trying to get more out of the banker than you have in your box - it's not easy, very few contestants manage to make the deal at the best possible time.

Of course, the theatrics and belief of some contestants that they might 'influence' the numbers makes it a bit silly, but it's no worse than watching poker.

Mr Whippy

32,453 posts

272 months

Thursday 9th March 2006
quotequote all
It takes to long.

If a show that *could* happen in 3 mins takes 30 mins then it is inherently boring!

It's arse, though my other half enjoys it, so a good excuse to sneak off to PH for a while

Dave

sstein

Original Poster:

6,249 posts

285 months

Thursday 9th March 2006
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]


Apparently one of the contestants that have been on left his or her job, eventhough the most you can win is £250,000!!! hardly bloody life changing is it. Its not as if your going to live of that for the rest of your life!!!

IDIOTS

-

Stuart

Tuna

19,930 posts

315 months

Thursday 9th March 2006
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]


In essence, yes. However, the banker is trying to out-psyche the player with unusually high or low offers depending on how well they appear to understand the game, so there's a little more going on than a purely mechanical process.

sstein

Original Poster:

6,249 posts

285 months

Thursday 9th March 2006
quotequote all
first of, is there even someone else on the phone?

secondly, I would say it probably isnt the "banker" trying to out pysche the player, I think they will be using mathematics to work out their offer as well.

and has been said before its down to greed.

And I doubt most of the people on the show could do simple mathematics.

-

Stuart

>> Edited by sstein on Thursday 9th March 17:19

anonymous-user

85 months

Thursday 9th March 2006
quotequote all
sstein said:
first of, is there even someone else on the phone?


Yes...a contestant actually spoke to him/her last week and was surprised that the banker was real!!

I had a leg op and could not walk so had nothing better to do, honest!!!

Raify

6,556 posts

279 months

Thursday 9th March 2006
quotequote all
someone said:
Man is faced with a cruel choice: Work, or daytime television.

Tuna

19,930 posts

315 months

Thursday 9th March 2006
quotequote all
sstein said:
first of, is there even someone else on the phone?


There certainly seems to be, a number of contestants have spoken to the banker and I think we've heard them laugh through Edmunds' mike.

sstein said:

secondly, I would say it probably isnt the "banker" trying to out pysche the player, I think they will be using mathematics to work out their offer as well.


Of course, but the banker has definately offered really low deals to players who look like they might be doing well. The next offer is much better (but lower than the odds) and some players will take it. It's a game of poker.

sstein said:

and has been said before its down to greed.


You could say the same of Millionaire or any other game show.

sstein said:

And I doubt most of the people on the show could do simple mathematics.


You should go on the show and clean up then

joecooool

1,020 posts

259 months

Thursday 9th March 2006
quotequote all
Damn - you guys are cheep. The US version has a case worth 3 million.

anonymous-user

85 months

Thursday 9th March 2006
quotequote all
joecooool said:
Damn - you guys are cheep. The US version has a case worth 3 million.


It's cos we don't have the ads coming on every 37 seconds

RR-Eng

5,841 posts

264 months

Thursday 9th March 2006
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]


Actually you have a number of indicators to the "value" of your box. There is the mean value of each box, but obviously this is scewed by having any particulary high or low amounts of money in the draw. In the event of the draw being scewed the banker will offer closer to the median value of the boxes.

In the later stages of the game you could use binomial probability to work it out the probability of the next three choices knocking out say some of the larger boxes which would give you some sort of mathematical advantage over a non expert player.

To do this you would have to bring along a calculator which I doubt they would let you do as it would make the show "boring" as they waited for you to calculate the answer.

With only one attempt at the game it means that it doesn't matter how good you are at probability you are still a slave to chance. All statistical "advantage plays" like card counting and the like work by setting the odds marginally in your favour and as a result require a large number of plays to make them pay off.

ehyouwhat

4,606 posts

249 months

Thursday 9th March 2006
quotequote all
The probabilities of the game are also not as straight forward as it seems. I can't be arsed to explain it here but, if you're interested, have a look (google) something called the 'Monty Hall Paradox'. It links to our particular version of 'Deal or no Deal' quite well but proves the odds are not simple to define as they may first appear.

Edited to say: I actually enjoy DOND quite a lot, although if I watched it every day of the week I'm sure it would become quite tedious. I do enjoy watching people play the later rounds of the game, and I personally think that a lot of people miss out on winning more money by simply not thinking about what they're doing. Given a high probability of winning a higher prize I'd always go for it...unless I was sat in that chair of course

>> Edited by ehyouwhat on Thursday 9th March 18:30