Fined for putting rubbish in bin
Fined for putting rubbish in bin
Author
Discussion

Mrs Fish

Original Poster:

30,018 posts

289 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
ananova said:
Fined for putting rubbish in bin

A man has been fined £50 for putting rubbish in a bin.

Andy Tierney of Hinckley, Leicestershire was issued the fixed penalty notice for dumping two junk mail letters.

Hinckley and Bosworth Council accused him of committing "an offence under Section 87 of the Environmental Protection Act 1990. Domestic refuse from your property was dumped into a street litter bin the fixed penalty is £50."

The council classes letters as "domestic litter", which should not be dropped in public street bins.

According to The Sun Andy said: "How on earth can they fine me for being tidy? It's absolute madness.

"I could have easily chucked those letters on the ground, but I put them in the bin. What has happened is a joke. The council is barmy. I never thought you could be fined for putting rubbish in a bin - that's what they're there for."

Andy was walking from his house to his car when his postman handed him the junk mail. He opened both letters as he strolled - then dumped them in the bin on a lamppost.

Council officials traced him from the addresses on the envelopes and issued the penalty. The letter threatens Andy with further action and a conviction if he does not pay within 14 days.

Andy insisted: "There's absolutely no way I'm paying up. You get fined for chucking rubbish on the ground. You get fined for chucking rubbish in the bin. So what exactly are you supposed to do?"

A spokesman from the council said: "A fixed penalty notice is served to people who we believe have committed an offence. Our litter bins are there to keep streets tidy, as they enable the public to deposit small amounts of litter. They are not provided for household waste."

r5gttgaz

7,897 posts

251 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
Maybe he should get the postman to dump his junk mail on the pavement.

mkgriff

719 posts

312 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
Who on earth is employed to go through rubbish, in order to check that what is placed in the bin is 'allowed'?

SS2.

14,712 posts

269 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
I've just read the relevant section from the Act:

Environmental Protection Act 1990 said:
87.—(1) If any person throws down, drops or otherwise deposits in, into or from any place to which this section applies, and leaves, any thing whatsoever in such circumstances as to cause, or contribute to, or tend to lead to, the defacement by litter of any place to which this section applies, he shall, subject to subsection (2) below, be guilty of an offence.

(2) No offence is committed under this section where the depositing and leaving of the thing was—

(a) authorised by law, or

(b) done with the consent of the owner, occupier or other person or authority having control of the place in or into which that thing was deposited.

(3) This section applies to any public open place and, in so far as the place is not a public open place, also to the following places—

(a) any relevant highway or relevant road and any trunk road which is a special road;

(b) any place on relevant land of a principal litter authority;

(c) any place on relevant Crown land;

(d) any place on relevant land of any designated statutory undertaker;

(e) any place on relevant land of any designated educational institution;

(f) any place on relevant land within a litter control area of a local authority.

(4) In this section "public open place" means a place in the open air to which the public are entitled or permitted to have access without payment; and any covered place open to the air on at least one side and available for public use shall be treated as a public open place.

(5) A person who is guilty of an offence under this section shall be liable on summary conviction to a fine not exceeding level 4 on the standard scale.

(6) A local authority, with a view to promoting the abatement of litter, may take such steps as the authority think appropriate for making the effect of subsection (5) above known to the public in their area.

(7) In any proceedings in Scotland for an offence under this section it shall be lawful to convict the accused on the evidence of one witness.

I can't see anything which precludes 'domestic' litter being placed in public bins..

Unless the council are envoking section 2(b) by saying they do not authorise their bins to be used as bins

jobsworths...

puggit

49,832 posts

279 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
The letters were apparently passed to him from the postman - and therefore may not have entered his property.

I'm assuming that the councils are happy to have themselves made to look completely stupid?

Pat H

8,058 posts

287 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
His address on the letters is not proof that the items belong to him, nor that he put them there.

So unless he makes any admissions (which it sounds like he has, the daft sod...) then they shouldn't be able to prove anything.

trackcar

6,453 posts

257 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
I think you'll find it's the postman who'll get the biggest rap on the knuckles for this .. he/she's not supposed to put mail anywhere other than the mailbox to which it is addressed ..

.. back to the story, the coucil are being complete tossers over this .. unless it happens to be written on the bin that domestic waste and mail isn't to be deposited there .. if it doesn't it's hard to see how the case can stand up.

Agree with the post above .. who sorts through the rubbish to find this stuff out? beyond me ..

Darth Dave

2,253 posts

263 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
And how much does it cost to have someone to sort through the rubbish in order to fine someone a measly amount?

Bloody pedants. The irony is the chap being fined pays for this service.

puggit

49,832 posts

279 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
Reading council have warned us recently that they are starting to go through rubbish collections. However this is principly aimed at people putting items such as car batteries in the recylcing bins.

Fair play to Reading if this is the case.

But the actions of Hinckley and Jobsworth council are tantamount to a waste of public money!

scorp

8,783 posts

260 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
Sad thing about this is that no harm was caused by popping 2 letters in a bin. Just some jumped up little hitler asserting his authority, i bet that made him feel real proud.

JoolzB

3,549 posts

280 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
You could maybe understand it if he was putting an old Christmas tree in a lamppost bin but not a couple of bits of paper. Crazy people.

motco

17,669 posts

277 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
On Radio 4 this morning a council reperesentative said it was not "just two letters" but a "large carrier bag full of domestic rubbish including food waste". Once again we do not get the truth.

fidgits

17,202 posts

260 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
my god....

it a country covered by litter someone has to be truely stupid to think this up!

Mrs Fish

Original Poster:

30,018 posts

289 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
You never get the whole story from one place these day

JoolzB

3,549 posts

280 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
motco said:
On Radio 4 this morning a council reperesentative said it was not "just two letters" but a "large carrier bag full of domestic rubbish including food waste". Once again we do not get the truth.

Uturn alert!

Yep it's making a tiny bit more sense, it is annoying when you can't use a bin coz it's full up especially if matey is dumping his weeks rubbish.

C C

8,058 posts

270 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
The world’s gone mad. Or has it?

A guy from the council on Radio 4 just now said that it was more than a couple of pieces of junk mail. Apparently the chap dumped a carrier bag of household waste. (Including foo waste ).

I suppose a ‘litter bin’ is hardly the right receptacle for household waste but should this be national news. I don’t know... I think the world’s just gone mad.

minicity

1,009 posts

262 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
motco said:
On Radio 4 this morning a council reperesentative said it was not "just two letters" but a "large carrier bag full of domestic rubbish including food waste". Once again we do not get the truth.


We have amajor litter problem in my area. Frankly the place looks like a tip. One thing that makes it worse is that litter bins are emptied and a few hours later are overflowing with large plastic bags stuffed full of rubbish; clearly not waste that has actually arisen in the street.

Mrs Fish

Original Poster:

30,018 posts

289 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
So is this a drawback of people only having bins emptied every two weeks... I think the litter problem is going to get much worse.

cossie.

7,977 posts

280 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
C C said:
The world’s gone mad. Or has it?


Well, this country certainly has and it's worrying.

ehyouwhat

4,606 posts

249 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
The thing is, we don't actually know which version of events is true. In either case I'm just not convinced that the case would stand up in court. How many normal people have read the relevant section of Law that states such waste cannot be placed in the bins? No-one...partly because that specific guideline does not even exist.

Surely this has to be a simply case of 'his word against theirs', I don't see how they could have 'proof' that he deposited a bag full of domestic waste. If they can't prove he did, and if they can't prove the letters were not posted through the letterbox (which would have made them domestic waste) then he's just putting rubbish in the nearest bin

Even if the council didn't want the bins used in this way, and really wanted to hammer home this fact, they should have written to the 'criminal' and told them not to do it again, pointing out the sections of the rules that apply.

What a pathetic waste of everyones time and money. I would have contempt for any court that even tried to actively progress such a case.