No English Parliament.
Author
Discussion

GavinPearson

Original Poster:

5,715 posts

282 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
Scotland has a Parliament. So does Wales. Yet they vote on English matters.

The BBC has reported that the English are OK with this:-

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk_politic

Personally I'm not. The English are being disenfranchised.

Comments....

Darth Dave

2,253 posts

263 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
I'd only be ok with it if we got to vote on their things. That kind of defeats the object of their own (apparent) control.

The problem is things that happen in England affect the UK. Things that happen in Scotland and Wales don't.

Saddle bum

4,211 posts

250 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
The English are NOT OK with this!

Falconer, who wrote the BBC piece is a major player in the Scottish Raj that is running the whole UK for the benefit of Scotland.

Iraq has a more representitive and democratic government than England.

turbobloke

117,560 posts

291 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
Saddle bum said:
The English are NOT OK with this!

Falconer, who wrote the BBC piece is a major player in the Scottish Raj that is running the whole UK for the benefit of Scotland.

Iraq has a more representitive and democratic government than England.
Falconer? Wasn't he BLiar's room-mate at Oxford?

anonymous-user

85 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
I'm from Scotland and I'm amazed at how well Scotland is represented in Westminster.

jamieboy

5,932 posts

260 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
Saddle bum said:
Iraq has a more representitive and democratic government than England.
True, but only because England does not have a government.

Wales doesn't have a parliament either, it has an Assembly, although I'm not at all clear on the difference.

I'm Scottish, but I agree that MPs from Scottish constituencies voting on solely English things seems wrong.

If you really want an English government, ask for one, and keep asking until either you get one or the idea is put to a referendum.

Myself, I'd vote for a UK government to make rules for the UK.

Saddle bum said:
running the whole UK for the benefit of Scotland.
Specifically, what are you referring to?

>> Edited by jamieboy on Friday 10th March 09:43

Don

28,378 posts

315 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
Ahhh - the West Lothian question.

I'd be quite happy to have an English Assembly.

Provided every bugger who sat on it was, actually, an English MP. NO EXTRA POLITICIANS.

In fact - I'm amazed we haven't done this earlier. Why have a Scottish Parliament and a Welsh Assembly. Just make the Scots and Welsh MPs do it. We pay them enough.

Zod

35,295 posts

289 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
turbobloke said:
Saddle bum said:
The English are NOT OK with this!

Falconer, who wrote the BBC piece is a major player in the Scottish Raj that is running the whole UK for the benefit of Scotland.

Iraq has a more representitive and democratic government than England.
Falconer? Wasn't he BLiar's room-mate at Oxford?
anmd they are both Scots, as is Gordon Brown.

Flat in Fifth

49,021 posts

282 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
The reason this lot won't give an English assemby is because they realise that they, Labour, would not be in power.

Therefore no chance until Bliar etc kicked into touch.

Yes I think the thinking English are really not happy with this.

Zod

35,295 posts

289 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
Flat in Fifth said:
The reason this lot won't give an English assemby is because they realise that they, Labour, would not be in power.

Therefore no chance until Bliar etc kicked into touch.

Yes I think the thinking English are really not happy with this.
Driving to work this morning, I was screaming at Humphries to ask Fatty Falconer this question: "Isn't the real reason you won't allow an English Parliament the fact that it would have a natural Conservative majority?"

wolves_wanderer

12,959 posts

268 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
Mets not forget that the provinces have a much higher proportion of labour MP's than England. England is not OK with this - the Labour party is OK with this as it allows them to railroad ideas that would never get through without the Jock's support (Top up fees, foundation hospitals anyone?)

The idea that Scottish and Welsh MP's can inflict something on us English that they would never allow in their precious country is nauseating, if politicians had a shred of decency they would refuse to vote on such issues. Why bother with wasting our tax money on them anyway , if they want independance they can right off as far as I'm concerned. If they can take our money and get services we can't then I feel perfectly within my rights to say the English have paid for enough methodone for Glasgow junkies. Or they could be sensible, get rid of their little pretend parliaments and have exclusively Welsh/Scottish/English votes in Westminster for issues that will solely affect each country. Fair?

Saddle bum

4,211 posts

250 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
jamieboy said:
Specifically, what are you referring to?



It must be plain to anyone that Scotland plc would be broke if it were not for the subsidies coming from the Barnnett formula. With 55pc of the work force in the Public Sector, the money can only come from outside Scotland.

Up to recently, it was £9billion pa, which was £2 per week for person living in England. Brown intends to raise that to at least £30billion pa.

Meanwhile, the English have Foundation Hospitals, voted for by Scots MPs. These hospitals force English old people to sell their homes to get care, whilst Scots OAPs have free old age care AND heating. English students pay top-up fees, voted for by Scots MPs. Scots Universities do not not charge top-up fees, except to ENGLISH students. English Women are denied Herceptin which is readily available in Scotland.

jamieboy

5,932 posts

260 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
wolves_wanderer said:
in their precious country
no need to be so emotive
wolves_wanderer said:
the English have paid for enough methodone for Glasgow junkies.
Only really a fair pount if the total tax take for each region was exactly the same as the total tax spend in each region.
wolves_wanderer said:
Or they could be sensible, get rid of their little pretend parliaments. Fair?
Yes, a UK government governing the UK.

motco

17,669 posts

277 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all

wolves_wanderer

12,959 posts

268 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
jamieboy said:
wolves_wanderer said:
in their precious country
no need to be so emotive
Fair point, I only say that because I get the impression that they are happy to vote all sorts of unpleasantness onto the English that they would never allow on "their people."
jamieboy said:
wolves_wanderer said:
the English have paid for enough methodone for Glasgow junkies.
Only really a fair pount if the total tax take for each region was exactly the same as the total tax spend in each region.
Since this devolution nonsense started it encourages us to think of Scotland as a different country, when that country has more comprehensive public services, a say in our laws and a share of our tax money it becomes more than slightly divisive.
jamieboy said:
wolves_wanderer said:
Or they could be sensible, get rid of their little pretend parliaments. Fair?
Yes, a UK government governing the UK.
From Westminster? If so I agree completely, this current situation helps nobody and creates resentment. Unfortunately labour's big idea is divide and rule so I don't see it ending anytime soon.

blueyes

4,799 posts

283 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
You have the bunch of feckwits in the Welsh Assembly... as long as you don't mind paying for them. They are as much use as an ashtray on a motorbike.

angrys3owner

15,855 posts

260 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
I think de-evolution or whatever bo11ocks they're calling it this week it completely the wrong way to go, we should get rid of all of them and have one UK government with local councils that can get on with local matters.

motco

17,669 posts

277 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
Having finished my popcorn, I have to say that whilst I agree that the present situation is daft, I feel that the original arrangement was not perfect either. I am London born and live in the Home Counties, I have Scots and Northern English in my extended family, often visit Scotland and Wales, and love parts of both. But, when I travelled the UK prior to devolution I always noticed that although I was in say Manchester, Cardiff, Edinburgh, or wherever outside the Home Counties, the news, current affairs, 'and finallys' & more or less everything that wasn't on 'Look North' or whatever local TV spot there is, was apparently from within fifteen miles of London. I was hard from the braodcast media to believe that the UK consists of 60 million people, forty million plus of whom do not live in the south east. This vague and not so vague feeling that the UK was run for and by the south was obvious even to me, a southern visitor. I can only imagine what it felt like to always be subject to it. No wonder, then, when Mel Gibson came along in the farce called Braveheart that our Caledonian friends shouted "Yes!" to offers of devolution and their own parliament. Since then, though, we've had a National government that is so disproportionately populated and run by Scots that the situation is totally reversed. I always used to feel an amicable affinity with the other nations of the UK and never felt a them and us existed. Then all this happened and the other nations got all uppity about their nationality and now it's hard not to rebel and feel English to a disproportionate degree. The good of Great Britain has not been well served by the devolution of Scotland and Wales, but I do think the status quo had to be looked at nonetheless.

john75

5,303 posts

278 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
Would be daft to have both a Parliament for England and Regional Assemblies.

Parrot of Doom

23,075 posts

265 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
I have this mental image of the Scots and Welsh:

<sarcasm>

Scots/Welsh "WE WANT INDEPENDANCE!!!"

English "Oh, please, stay? Don't go "

</sarcasm>