Were there anti-war protestors during World War 2?
Were there anti-war protestors during World War 2?
Author
Discussion

slapmatt

Original Poster:

1,132 posts

253 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
With the ever growing anti-Iraq war, anti-Bush/Blair, anti-Guantanamo Bay sentiments it got me wondering... were there anti-war protestors during WW2?

If there were and if we'd have listened to them would we all be talking Deutsch and goose stepping to work, or would we be united, part of one central European administration?

fido

18,932 posts

286 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all

i'm guess you mean on the German side, as they were the aggressors.
i recall that there were some (Christian pastors i guess) who met untimely deaths - not the sort of stance you'd want to take in a totalitarian state.

Jaglover

46,848 posts

266 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
slapmatt said:
With the ever growing anti-Iraq war, anti-Bush/Blair, anti-Guantanamo Bay sentiments it got me wondering... were there anti-war protestors during WW2?

If there were and if we'd have listened to them would we all be talking Deutsch and goose stepping to work, or would we be united, part of one central European administration?


There were conscientious objectors in both world wars. But rather than being lazy soap dodgers, like most of the anti-war protestors, they were often brave men making a principled stand. Many became stretcher bearers (who suffered quite a high casualty rate).

>> Edited by Jaglover on Friday 10th March 10:27

billb

3,198 posts

296 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
ww2 is a bit diff to iraq etc...

timmy30

9,325 posts

258 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
slapmatt said:

would we all be talking Deutsch and goose stepping to work?


depends if you work in a German Bank really

>> Edited by timmy30 on Friday 10th March 10:31

djfish

6,018 posts

294 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
I believe there were, but they would've been regarded in the same way as conscientious objectors, people suffering from post traumatic stress and ex pats from 'enemy' countries, ie badly.

Without the use of rose tinted specs the attitudes of the general public during wartime could be considered to have been less than tolerant.

>> Edited by djfish on Friday 10th March 10:34

havoc

33,511 posts

266 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
Jaglover said:
slapmatt said:
With the ever growing anti-Iraq war, anti-Bush/Blair, anti-Guantanamo Bay sentiments it got me wondering... were there anti-war protestors during WW2?

If there were and if we'd have listened to them would we all be talking Deutsch and goose stepping to work, or would we be united, part of one central European administration?


There were conscientious objectors in both world wars. But rather than being lazy soap dodgers, like most of the anti-war protestors, they were often brave men making a principled stand. Many became stretcher bearers (who suffered quite a high casualty rate).
beat me to it.

These people were, largely, denigrated and reviled by the majority of 'patriots' (their emphasis), and the word 'conscientious' (as in 'of the conscience') was very appropriate - these people took a very brave stand despite the impact on them and their family.

C C

8,058 posts

270 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
There was of course considerable reluctance in the U.S to get involved in what many considered an exclusively European war.
Until Pearl Harbor tipped the balance.

Yugguy

10,728 posts

266 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
Lad at work's surname is Conchie, he pronounces it "conky" because his great-grandad changed the pronunciation in WW1 away from "conshie" as that was slang for conscientious objector.

minicity

1,009 posts

262 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
Jaglover said:
slapmatt said:
With the ever growing anti-Iraq war, anti-Bush/Blair, anti-Guantanamo Bay sentiments it got me wondering... were there anti-war protestors during WW2?

If there were and if we'd have listened to them would we all be talking Deutsch and goose stepping to work, or would we be united, part of one central European administration?


There were conscientious objectors in both world wars. But rather than being lazy soap dodgers, like most of the anti-war protestors, they were often brave men making a principled stand. Many became stretcher bearers (who suffered quite a high casualty rate).

>> Edited by Jaglover on Friday 10th March 10:27


Are you saying that the people that objected to fighting to save their own country from Nazis were "brave men making a principled stand" and those that object to blowing up a load of innocent civilians in Iraq are just "lazy soap dodgers"? By the way, I was pro Iraq war at the time and now think the protestors were right. I wish I had been one of them frankly. And I also know that many objectors in the World Wars took on very dangerous tasks that cost them their lives.

Yugguy

10,728 posts

266 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
A lot of people in both UK and Germany thought we should get together and fight the Russians.

JMGS4

8,936 posts

301 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
C C said:
There was of course considerable reluctance in the U.S to get involved in what many considered an exclusively European war. Until Pearl Harbor tipped the balance.


Agreed, especially when they were profitting highly from all the goods they "gave" us, old rusty WW1 destroyers etc but took a couple of wealthy islands as payment....
NOT denigrating all the guys who actually helped and laid their lives down for freedom.....

Jaglover

46,848 posts

266 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
minicity said:

Are you saying that the people that objected to fighting to save their own country from Nazis were "brave men making a principled stand" and those that object to blowing up a load of innocent civilians in Iraq are just "lazy soap dodgers"? By the way, I was pro Iraq war at the time and now think the protestors were right. I wish I had been one of them frankly. And I also know that many objectors in the World Wars took on very dangerous tasks that cost them their lives.


I am saying they were for the most part brave because they made a principled stand that they would not kill another human being regardless of the personal cost to themselves. As I mentioned many showed courage by acting as stretcher bearers under fire.

In contrast the 'peace' protesters are the dissatisfied offspring of the middle classes joining the latest 'fashionable' cause. What courage have they shown?

scorp

8,783 posts

260 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
Jaglover said:
In contrast the 'peace' protesters are the dissatisfied offspring of the middle classes joining the latest 'fashionable' cause. What courage have they shown?



You're saying that the Iraq anti-war protestors don't care about the war, and are protesting because they think it's fashionable?

editted for speeling

>> Edited by scorp on Friday 10th March 11:08

ewenm

28,506 posts

276 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
The difference between WW2 and Iraq is that WW2 had conscription - so the ordinary bloke in the street was expected to join up and fight. Those who refused often found they could help the war effort by driving ambulances, being stretcher bearers etc. As has been said, this was often done under fire, so bravery was required.

As Iraq is just a regular (and TA) forces war, thos who genuinely object do not have the opportunity to contribute. It would be interesting to see how many of the anti-war protesters would volunteer for ambulance duty in Iraq.

Tyre Smoke

23,018 posts

292 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
scorp said:
Jaglover said:
In contrast the 'peace' protesters are the dissatisfied offspring of the middle classes joining the latest 'fashionable' cause. What courage have they shown?



Your saying that the Iraq anti-war protestors don't care about the war, and are protesting because they think it's fashionable?


It's you're and yes, I think that is what he's saying.

Most of these soap dodgers couldn't point out Iraq on a globe let alone know what the causes of the war were.

For the record I was against British intervention from the start. It's not our row, and Bliar is simply bending over with his trousers down for George Dubya.

Tyre Smoke

23,018 posts

292 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
ewenm said:
The difference between WW2 and Iraq is that WW2 had conscription - so the ordinary bloke in the street was expected to join up and fight. Those who refused often found they could help the war effort by driving ambulances, being stretcher bearers etc. As has been said, this was often done under fire, so bravery was required.

As Iraq is just a regular (and TA) forces war, thos who genuinely object do not have the opportunity to contribute. It would be interesting to see how many of the anti-war protesters would volunteer for ambulance duty in Iraq.


Nailhead meet hammer.

yertis

19,741 posts

297 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
I've a theory that many modern "peace protestors" "prostestehth too much". They're fascinated with the hardware, power and mystique surrounding the military machine they affect to abhor so much. It's like a displaced penis envy.

billb

3,198 posts

296 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
ewenm said:
The difference between WW2 and Iraq is that WW2 had conscription - so the ordinary bloke in the street was expected to join up and fight. Those who refused often found they could help the war effort by driving ambulances, being stretcher bearers etc. As has been said, this was often done under fire, so bravery was required.

As Iraq is just a regular (and TA) forces war, thos who genuinely object do not have the opportunity to contribute. It would be interesting to see how many of the anti-war protesters would volunteer for ambulance duty in Iraq.


why exactely should they contribute?

timmy30

9,325 posts

258 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
Yugguy said:
A lot of people in both UK and Germany thought we should get together and fight the Russians.


Indeed. Interestingly before the War the Germans were so convinced that the UK and Germany would co-operate militarily that the Luftwaffe shared fleet numbers and details with the RAF quite openly.

It seems strange in hindsight but I can't help thinking that Hitler actually believed that following on from the expansion of the British Empire in Asia, the Western expansion of the US ( effectively a continental empire ) and it's annexation of the plains Indians territories, that the US or UK would actually not object to an Eastward expansion of Germany across the European plains, especially given the rising threat of Bolshivic Russia. IIRC correctly the treaties that bought the UK into the war or at least were the justification for the openning of hostilities dated from the two great pre- WWI power blocks of Europe....which of course dated from the alliance of Russia and it's satellite states, with the WWI allies.

Come to think of it I'm not at all convinced that the US would have given a dam about it anyway, it was only thanks to Churchill persuading them that without US intervention Russia and Communist China would overrun the so called Heartland/World Island that they joined the War in Europe.

All IMO of course and probably wrong.