Creationism to be taught in UK science lessons
Creationism to be taught in UK science lessons
Author
Discussion

branflakes

Original Poster:

2,039 posts

269 months

Plotloss

67,280 posts

301 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
Miss, miss, can you explain how a whale which has a digestive and jaw system specifically created to harvest massive amounts of krill from the water managed to swallow and then regurgitate a man please miss?

Oh and while you're at it, men and dinosaurs at the same time? In Mr Davies' geography class last week we learned about fossils and he said that dinosaurs were around millions of years before man...

Bunch of arse.

up-the-dubs

4,282 posts

260 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
Don't agree with that at all. It's not a science for a start. Secondly, children should be brought up in the faith and belief of their parents until such time as they are old eneough to decide for themselves. Differing points of view sould not be forced upon them in a scientific environment where it could very easily be understood to be fact. I'm all for kids learning about other cultures and religions in order to reduce religious hatred through misunderstanding them, but it's not fact and should not be treated that way.

Andy Mac

73,668 posts

286 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
Shouldn't that be confined to RE lessons?

scorp

8,783 posts

260 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
Has anyone read the article before they start to bitch? It says there will be a DEBATE on the subject, e.g. science will conclusively prove that ID is a load of cod.

Lion-O

242 posts

259 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
I have no problem with this being taught in RE, but this should absolutely be kept out of the science class. If they insist on this being in the science curriculum then I think there should be a dedicated PH campaign to get the Flying Spaghetti Monster in there too.

www.venganza.org/

planetdave

9,922 posts

284 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
I can see how the creationists get such a following.

I had a quick look at some of their stuff (written by a professor of mathematics) and it was top notch...well beyond the grasp of an ordinary man on the street with its theories backed up with stunning statistics (OK...mindnumbing) and some interesting ideas of how genetics work.

I didn't give it a proper look since it was obviously cretinist (sic) bollox and a waste of my intellect (cough splutter etc.)

These people should be taken as a serious menace (no - not me you bassoon)

bga

8,134 posts

282 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
After reading the article I cannot see how this could be interpreted in any other way than to add context to science - which is arguably one of the most important parts of the discipline.

It is no different to geography teachers telling kids that way back when people used to think that the earth was flat.

IMO a complete piece of non-news trading on the back of the intelligent design stuff that was going through the news a couple of months ago.

Andy Mac

73,668 posts

286 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
Do people still think the world is flat? I don't recall people still thinking the earth was flat, and being 'taught'/suggested it as an alternative.

(Please no links to the flat earth society!)

Witchfinder

6,388 posts

283 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
Aha! Now we see the REAL reason behind global warming!

FunkyGibbon

3,864 posts

295 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
bga said:
After reading the article I cannot see how this could be interpreted in any other way than to add context to science - which is arguably one of the most important parts of the discipline.

It is no different to geography teachers telling kids that way back when people used to think that the earth was flat.

IMO a complete piece of non-news trading on the back of the intelligent design stuff that was going through the news a couple of months ago.



Spot on.

Yugguy

10,728 posts

266 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
In addition to the above it's a repost anyway.*




*actually I've no idea if it is or not but let's face it just about everything is now.

Andy Mac

73,668 posts

286 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
including posts confirming a repost.. I've seen them before!

johnph

1,097 posts

260 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
Try reading the article - it said they would be debated NOT taught as science.

IMO we should teach Creationism, Evolution, and ID and let people make up thier own minds.

Andy Mac

73,668 posts

286 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
johnph said:
Try reading the article - it said they would be debated NOT taught as science.

IMO we should teach Creationism, Evolution, and ID and let people make up thier own minds.

On what basis will it be debated??? 'These people over here think their invisible friend made it all, 6000 years ago'... 'Someone made it way back.. Not sure when'... Or 'These are what we have gleaned from sientific data? Thus we have this data, that data, etc'. Where is the debate? What evidence is there of a creator, and what evidence is there of Intelligent design?

kmchapman

53 posts

250 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
johnph said:
Try reading the article - it said they would be debated NOT taught as science.

IMO we should teach Creationism, Evolution, and ID and let people make up thier own minds.


There is a lot of talk about "people making up their own minds" on these religious threads. As I said in another thread - how about we teach atheism and then let people make up their own minds later? It uses the same definition of open-minded as the religious are proposing.

Yugguy

10,728 posts

266 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
Cos you can't prove God DOESN'T exist anymore than you can prove he DOES so neither atheism nor belief are factual.

Plotloss

67,280 posts

301 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
Yugguy said:
Cos you can't prove God DOESN'T exist anymore than you can prove he DOES so neither atheism nor belief are factual.


No but its absolute fact that man and dinosaurs were not around at the same time thus disproving the world in 6 days bollox.

Andy Mac

73,668 posts

286 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
Can't dissprove it? That old chestnut. Can't dissprove that there is a giant purple turtle with 91 legs, driving a chariot made of cheese out there in the universe somewhere, but I know it is made up.

bga

8,134 posts

282 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
Andy Mac said:
johnph said:
Try reading the article - it said they would be debated NOT taught as science.

IMO we should teach Creationism, Evolution, and ID and let people make up thier own minds.

On what basis will it be debated??? 'These people over here think their invisible friend made it all, 6000 years ago'... 'Someone made it way back.. Not sure when'... Or 'These are what we have gleaned from sientific data? Thus we have this data, that data, etc'. Where is the debate? What evidence is there of a creator, and what evidence is there of Intelligent design?


Likely on the basis that this is what people have believed for years but scientific evidence points otherwise. Getting kids to think about, debate this stuff & reach conclusions based on evidence is valuable learning - more so than identifying the structure of a red blood cell for example (unless it's A-level biology of course!)

The introduction of other concepts into subjects is never a bad thing - less insidious imo than kids being taught creation in sunday school for example