Definition of Poverty
Discussion
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/business/4
This gets my goat. The definition of poverty.
In todays society its a moving target - but why? Poverty is not a moving target - its a constant. The constant should be defined as having a roof over your head, food on your table and a warm bed at night. These are basic needs that a human needs - everything else is a bonus.
People like Evan Davis have obviously never seen real poverty for themselves, as they still view it as a proportion of wealth. Heaven help the guy if he was ever to compare a poor person in Africa against a poor person in the UK. Maybe the TV, Sky+, the council flat, and the 40 a day habit of the poor UK person would give him some clues.
Evan Davis said:
The fundamental problem is that if everybody in Britain gets 2% richer each year, the poverty line rises as quickly as the incomes of the poor. So there is no progress on the poverty target.
This gets my goat. The definition of poverty.
In todays society its a moving target - but why? Poverty is not a moving target - its a constant. The constant should be defined as having a roof over your head, food on your table and a warm bed at night. These are basic needs that a human needs - everything else is a bonus.
People like Evan Davis have obviously never seen real poverty for themselves, as they still view it as a proportion of wealth. Heaven help the guy if he was ever to compare a poor person in Africa against a poor person in the UK. Maybe the TV, Sky+, the council flat, and the 40 a day habit of the poor UK person would give him some clues.
I used to act for a Housing Authority in posession claims for non payment of rent. You'd be amazed at the amount of designer jeans and trainers I saw on people who couldn't afford to pay their rent having already received their Housing Benefit direct!! I once had a lady explaining to me at great length that she'd had to buy her boys new school uniforms and couldn't therefore pay her rent (for the last 8 months?) - she then asked where she could go for a fag 

there was an item on the telly the other day with a family who had only £40 a week to buy food and stuff for the family of 4. on the one hand i did feel sorry for them, on the other i couldn't help but think that if he was willing to travel a bit further to a place of work he might actually get a job...
..if i have to travel 2 hrs a day to get to and from work i don't see why other people can't!
..if i have to travel 2 hrs a day to get to and from work i don't see why other people can't!
tinman0 said:
The definition of poverty.
In todays society its a moving target - but why? Poverty is not a moving target - its a constant. The constant should be defined as having a roof over your head, food on your table and a warm bed at night. These are basic needs that a human needs - everything else is a bonus.
i completely understand where you are coming from, but 1 point:
you say that poverty is a constant (roof, food, bed, which is fair enough), but each year the price of those constants increase by about 2% for most people, therefore surely poverty cant be a constant.
but i agree that our level of "poverty" with designer clobber is stupid.
I really resent the fact that I give a portion of my salary every month to the government, who in turn gives some of that to a pikey who has Sky Digital, a House, Designer cloths, Smoking habit, drinks a lot and has no intention of working.
If you up these peoples benefits even further where is their incentive to go out work and earn a good living for themselves.
For some living of benefits is a career option and its wrong!
And as long as you measure poverty as a percentage of income you can never get rid of it until everyone is paid the same!
-
Stuart
If you up these peoples benefits even further where is their incentive to go out work and earn a good living for themselves.
For some living of benefits is a career option and its wrong!
And as long as you measure poverty as a percentage of income you can never get rid of it until everyone is paid the same!
-
Stuart
OK,
I've read that poverty is under 60% of average salary, take average salary of £26k.
That gives you poverty if you are earning below £15,600 which is £12,120 after tax, NI (if i did my sums right).
I think if people cant live off a £1000 a month then they are clearly living beyond their means.
OK, it may not be a great life, but surely £1k a month is enough for the essentials. House / Shelter / Food / Non designer clothes
-
Stuart
I've read that poverty is under 60% of average salary, take average salary of £26k.
That gives you poverty if you are earning below £15,600 which is £12,120 after tax, NI (if i did my sums right).
I think if people cant live off a £1000 a month then they are clearly living beyond their means.
OK, it may not be a great life, but surely £1k a month is enough for the essentials. House / Shelter / Food / Non designer clothes
-
Stuart
speedychrissie said:
i completely understand where you are coming from, but 1 point:
you say that poverty is a constant (roof, food, bed, which is fair enough), but each year the price of those constants increase by about 2% for most people, therefore surely poverty cant be a constant.
but i agree that our level of "poverty" with designer clobber is stupid.
in that respect poverty is not a constant.
however, poverty should not be measured against average earnings.
sstein said:
OK, it may not be a great life, but surely £1k a month is enough for the essentials. House / Shelter / Food / Non designer clothes
Mortgage: £400 (pretty low, but let's say you've borrowed 60K over 25 years - that'd put you in a 2 bed terrace in a poor Northern town)
Council Tax: £100
Food: £150 (You *can* feed a small family on that much, but it'd be pretty poor fare)
Gas: £25
Electricity: £25
TV Licence: £8
Home Insurance: £30
Telephone: £20
Clothing: £80 (should be enough)
So that's £840 per month, before you take into account the cost of travelling to work (a cheap, basic car would probably cost you about £180 per month to run, including petrol, tax, insurance and servicing)
It's possible, but it'd be a pretty poor standard of living - there'd be nothing left over to pay into a pension, save up, have a holiday, decorate the house, cover unexpected bills, buying Christmas pressies, etc... Of course you'd probably get some benefits to top this up, but it's easy to see why so many are happy with a council house and dole money.
EDIT: I'd like to point out that I don't think the problem is poor salaries, it's the cost of living. Council tax should be half what it is. A basic 2 bed terrace shouldn't cost any more than £40K really, and a decent 3 bed detatched shouldn't be any more than £100K
>> Edited by Witchfinder on Saturday 11th March 19:30
john75 said:
Throught Poverty was something like have and income of less than 75% of the average wage which in the UK is around £23k so someone earning under £16k would be living in Poverty.
I thought 75% of the national average was the point at which graduates have to start paying back student loans....... didn't realise there were so many graduates in poverty. The UN should do something about it!
Witchfinder said:
sstein said:
OK, it may not be a great life, but surely £1k a month is enough for the essentials. House / Shelter / Food / Non designer clothes
Mortgage: £400 (pretty low, but let's say you've borrowed 60K over 25 years - that'd put you in a 2 bed terrace in a poor Northern town)
Council Tax: £100
Food: £150 (You *can* feed a small family on that much, but it'd be pretty poor fare)
Gas: £25
Electricity: £25
TV Licence: £8
Home Insurance: £30
Telephone: £20
Clothing: £80 (should be enough)
So that's £840 per month, before you take into account the cost of travelling to work (a cheap, basic car would probably cost you about £180 per month to run, including petrol, tax, insurance and servicing)
You dont need a car, if you cant afford it use the bus.
On that income I doubt you will have a mortgage, you will be in a council house. So there is more money saved. I dont know what council house rent is, it must be less than a mortgage??
But like i said, life aint going to be great. But if you want a good life then go out and work for it. Dont expect the government to top-up your earnings through benefits just so you can have SkyTV and a nice holiday!
-
Stuart
MilnerR said:
john75 said:
Throught Poverty was something like have and income of less than 75% of the average wage which in the UK is around £23k so someone earning under £16k would be living in Poverty.
I thought 75% of the national average was the point at which graduates have to start paying back student loans....... didn't realise there were so many graduates in poverty. The UN should do something about it!
You pay back the student loan on any income over £15,000 ( i think ).
-
Stuart
sstein said:
You dont need a car, if you cant afford it use the bus.
Pure comedy gold! Driving to work is FAR cheaper than taking the bus if you live outside London.
sstein said:
On that income I doubt you will have a mortgage, you will be in a council house. So there is more money saved. I dont know what council house rent is, it must be less than a mortgage??
Will you? Do you know what the waiting lists are like for a council house? Yes rent is fairly cheap, but ultimately it's money into a black hole and you're not guaranteed to get a council house.
sstein said:
But like i said, life aint going to be great. But if you want a good life then go out and work for it. Dont expect the government to top-up your earnings through benefits just so you can have SkyTV and a nice holiday!
No, but a break once a year in a caravan in Wales isn't much to ask for, nor is the ability to save for a pension or for the future. We're looking at a massive pensions deficit, and they wonder why people aren't saving for their old age! The point I'm making isn't that people should be getting free money, but that the cost of living is stupidly high.
Do you think someone earning a low salary doesn't work hard to earn it?
Evan Davis said:
The fundamental problem is that if everybody in Britain gets 2% richer each year, the poverty line rises as quickly as the incomes of the poor. So there is no progress on the poverty target.
Not true. This statement implies a constant relationship between the average income and the poverty income. This relationship can and does change over time.
Consider-
A population consisting of a large peasant class and a small wealthy class.
A population living under a Scandinavian style welfare state.
Obviously the relationship between the rise in average earnings and the rise in income amongst the poor is variable. So progress can be achieved even if the described method of measuring poverty is used.
tinman0 said:
People like Evan Davis have obviously never seen real poverty for themselves, as they still view it as a proportion of wealth.
Evan Davis is only reporting the 'official definition' of poverty, which is of course cooked up by naive socialists.
It just shows how stupid/out of touch they are, and unfortunately they happen to run the country...
Witchfinder said:
sstein said:
OK, it may not be a great life, but surely £1k a month is enough for the essentials. House / Shelter / Food / Non designer clothes
Mortgage: £400 (pretty low, but let's say you've borrowed 60K over 25 years - that'd put you in a 2 bed terrace in a poor Northern town)
Council Tax: £100
Food: £150 (You *can* feed a small family on that much, but it'd be pretty poor fare)
Gas: £25
Electricity: £25
TV Licence: £8
Home Insurance: £30
Telephone: £20
Clothing: £80 (should be enough)
You COULD live without a TV or telephone if you tried really hard... but then I could modify your 'poor northern town' costs by pointing out that my Council Tax is £72 and home insurance £22 which would offset the TV/phone. Gas and electricity about right. Clothes I dunno, no kids to worry about now
(£80 a week, probably...
) Mind you I wouldn't fancy a £400 mortgage, I might have to go back to working 5 day weeks

Gassing Station | The Pie & Piston Archive | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



