Digital Piano
Author
Discussion

xiphias

Original Poster:

5,889 posts

258 months

Monday 13th March 2006
quotequote all
Was thinking about buying a digital piano and teaching myself how to play. Thing is, I have no idea what I should be looking for in one! Initial budget is probably around 400-600 quid, worth paying more or less? It's a serious request, so I don't really want to go out and buy a keyboard.

chim_knee

12,689 posts

288 months

Monday 13th March 2006
quotequote all
Depends on whether you want it to last for as long as you play the piano or whether you can see yourself "upgrading" in the future.

If it's the former - I would recommend spending as much as you can as you'll get a better quality of keyboard/feel etc.

The best advice I can give it to go an play some. Tell the shop assistant why you want to (i.e. to start from scratch) and play it. You'll be able to feel the difference between the action/feel of the keyboards. Also, the sound they produce - some sound rubbish, some sound astonishing.

The more expensive you go often means loads of toys which you may never want/need. My personal opinon is not to have them and have the money spent on keys and sounds.

>> Edited by chim_knee on Monday 13th March 13:07

Davel

8,982 posts

289 months

Monday 13th March 2006
quotequote all
Just bought one for my daughter through the 'Rocking Rooster' website.

We bought a Yamaha YDP131 Digital Piano (I think that was the model) for about £450.

Ordered on website and delivered next day. Found small scratch on pedal box, during assembly, and they replaced it with no problem at all.

Excellent service and very impressed with price too. They had a nice Casio too, with all the whistles and bells etc., but the Yamaha sounded better with fewer distractions for a 9 year old.

You can also take your exams on this if you wish, as it has a full size keyboard with weighted effect keyboard and three pedals (accelerator, clutch and brake?)

JonRB

80,226 posts

303 months

Monday 13th March 2006
quotequote all
When my son was learning piano we did a bit of research into this.

Speaking as someone who doesn't play (before I got shot down) we discovered two big price points.
If you get a "velocity sensitive" (I think it is) keyboard then, like a piano, if you hit the key hard it's loud and it you hit it softly then it's quiet. I'd say that is essential for learning to pay the piano, and that's what we went for which was round about the £200 price point.

The second price point is where the keys are weighted to feel like a piano, and that's when it gets expensive (like £600+)

If it were me I'd go for the former to see how you go and then trade up to the latter later on.

cic450

939 posts

270 months

Monday 13th March 2006
quotequote all
Don't mean to hijack, I have been seriosly cosidering buying an upright piano and teaching myself or having lessons. I don't read music, ia that a problem?
I spoke to a lady in a music shop and she played the same tune on several different pianos/keyboards, you really can notice the difference in sound quality, unfortunately for me the best sounding one was also the most expensive!

cic.

Parrot of Doom

23,075 posts

265 months

Monday 13th March 2006
quotequote all
Personally I'd buy a full sized piano, cheap from Ebay for less than £100. That way if you realise you don't like playing the Piano, you won't have spent as much money.

chim_knee

12,689 posts

288 months

Monday 13th March 2006
quotequote all
Yep - if you want to play seriously, you need weighted keys. Playing some (no need to be embarrassed 'cos you can't play!) will let you feel the difference.

xiphias

Original Poster:

5,889 posts

258 months

Monday 13th March 2006
quotequote all
Thanks peeps. Had a look at that YDP131's specs, seem to fit the requirements based on your advice. Need to go out and play a few I guess! Any recommendations for tunes I can get the assistant to play to bring out the best in a piano?

Uriel

3,244 posts

282 months

Monday 13th March 2006
quotequote all
Parrot of Doom said:
Personally I'd buy a full sized piano, cheap from Ebay for less than £100. That way if you realise you don't like playing the Piano, you won't have spent as much money.


That's fine as long as neighbours aren't an issue. I decided to learn and thought a 'proper' piano would be way cooler than sone electric thing. But it's so loud I never play it. I'd have been much better off with something with a volume control or headphone option.

littlegreenfairy

10,134 posts

252 months

Monday 13th March 2006
quotequote all
xiphias said:
Any recommendations for tunes I can get the assistant to play to bring out the best in a piano?


Take your girlfriend who can play the piano, read music and is classically trained musician

lizzieh

187 posts

250 months

Monday 13th March 2006
quotequote all
cic450 said:
Don't mean to hijack, I have been seriosly cosidering buying an upright piano and teaching myself or having lessons. I don't read music, ia that a problem?
I spoke to a lady in a music shop and she played the same tune on several different pianos/keyboards, you really can notice the difference in sound quality, unfortunately for me the best sounding one was also the most expensive!

cic.

if you don't read music I'd recommend having lessons, at least until you find your feet so to speak. I've been playing the piano since I was 4. You'll soon pick it up...

blindswelledrat

25,257 posts

263 months

Monday 13th March 2006
quotequote all
Do you particularly need a digital piano as opposed to a normal one?
The main advantage to digital is the ability to use headphones. However a cheap digital piano looks/feels/sounds cheap.
If you are not worried about noise then I would definitely agree with what someone said about picking up a real second hand piano for a couple of hundred quid.

cic450

939 posts

270 months

Monday 13th March 2006
quotequote all
Do i need to buy a piano to have lessons?
Just thought about that, obviously i do to practice, Doh!!

cic.

xiphias

Original Poster:

5,889 posts

258 months

Monday 13th March 2006
quotequote all
littlegreenfairy said:
xiphias said:
Any recommendations for tunes I can get the assistant to play to bring out the best in a piano?


Take your girlfriend who can play the piano, read music and is classically trained musician


Didn't know you could play, and if it's as often as you play your flute then I expect you're a bit rusty I can read music as well you know

S2rr Kitty

11,876 posts

282 months

Monday 13th March 2006
quotequote all
Would recommend (as people have mentioned already) that you make sure you get weighted keys, it really does make a difference.

I bought this for my son

www.dolphinmusic.co.uk/page/shop/flypage/product_id/3898

It has 88 keys - the number of keys is also a factor (in price) but you should aim for the most possible if you're serious.



Davel

8,982 posts

289 months

Monday 13th March 2006
quotequote all
You really won't go wrong with the Yamaha.

We tried several out and the sales guy played a few different ones before we bought and, at that price, you really can't lose out.

We went to the shop but bought on the web from the same company.

It arrived flat pack but was dead easy to assemble.

- and it has everything that you'll need - and more!

mr_tony

6,351 posts

300 months

Monday 13th March 2006
quotequote all
As someone who's played piano for many years (I started aged 3 1/2) I would say weighted keys are a necessity. IDeally if you ahve space buy an old upright piano. IF you don't then YAmaha and Roland are the main ones to look at. Clavinovas are great.

As I don't currently have room for a piano having just moved in with my mrs, I want one of these next... www.clavia.se/products/nordstage/index.htm

adi

514 posts

306 months

Monday 13th March 2006
quotequote all
I'd recommend a Yamaha P series (P120 would fit into your budget). Compact & lightweight, excellent feel and sound quality. The keyboards are 'graded' in weighting - which means heavier key feel on bottom end, just like a real piano. Expect to pay £5-600 for one new.

-DeaDLocK-

3,368 posts

282 months

Monday 13th March 2006
quotequote all
JonRB said:
If it were me I'd go for the former to see how you go and then trade up to the latter later on.
And as a self-taught (but occasional performing and recording) player ("pianist" is too strong a word for me IMO), I'd say disregard this advice unless you really cannot afford the better models.



If you are at all half-serious, go for weighted keys early on. Many cheaper models these days come with the same keyboards used in actual grand acoustic pianos.

But, though this isn't what you are asking, if you can afford the space and noise problems with acoustic upright pianos, please please please get an acoustic.

The one thing even the best digital piano cannot replicate is the feel of the resonance and vibration of the strings through the wood and into your fingers - do not underestimate just how important to is and how much it adds to your enjoyment of playing.

It is like having sublime steering feel in a car like an Elise or Caterham, as opposed to some drive-by-wire Merc luxobarge.

Digital pianos lack soul.

And by the way, my main instrument is a digital piano, but only because where I used to live in an apartment and noise was a big consideration. I will get a good upright (or a grand!) the moment I can accomodate it.

-DeaDLocK-

3,368 posts

282 months

Monday 13th March 2006
quotequote all
adi said:
(P120 would fit into your budget)
I have this.

Excellent build, design, portability and keyboard, but totally let down by the samples. In the shop and at first they sound great, but you very quickly begin to notice a very distinct digital ring in the sustain of certain key notes from the middle-C upwards.

For a beginner though they're decent enough. But see my above post - acoustic acoustic acoustic!