Scam or just plain cheeky?
Scam or just plain cheeky?
Author
Discussion

Nick P

Original Poster:

29,977 posts

282 months

Monday 13th March 2006
quotequote all
My wife received a phone call this morning from an 'agency' alongs the lines of;

"hello MrsP"

"hello"

"i am Jane from Cancer research and we have seen that you did the run for life, would you be interested in setting up a monthly direct debit to contribute"

"No, thankyou"

"oh......what about a yearly set amount then, say, £30?"

"No, thankyou"

"well if you just give us your details etc"

"No, thankyou, Goodbye"


I would think it's a scam, but how would they have known she did the run for life? If it is a genuine call from cancer research I would say it is pretty bloody necky to phone someone like that. Especially as we are X directory and on the books of the 'anti scammming phone call' people.....I suppose they could have got the phone number from her original registration paperwork??

Bloody hell

Parrot of Doom

23,075 posts

265 months

Monday 13th March 2006
quotequote all
Tell the person making the call to start running for her life.

cinque

833 posts

313 months

Monday 13th March 2006
quotequote all
I doubt if thats a scam.

Moreso them being cheeky bstards. Your Mrs being a 'charitable' sort, prob fits her into a 'more likely to give at a future date' sector that they then 'aggresively' canvas.

This sort of thing puts me off giving im afraid.

paulie-mafia

3,321 posts

254 months

Monday 13th March 2006
quotequote all
Yeah this pute me off giving too. I signed up for a monthly NSPCC DD once - I put £10 on the form, then they only took £2 each month, and every couple of weeks I'd get a mailer in the post including a free biro, asking me to donate more. I wrote to them and cancelled it in the end.

SKR

2,732 posts

267 months

Monday 13th March 2006
quotequote all
Friend got a call at work the other day from outfit claiming to be calling from local hospital. As his mum is in that day for a check up he drops everything to take the call.

Turns out they are from a charity trying to get donations. He is obviously not pleased, they claim that they were calling inconjunction with the local hospital and not from local hospital.

FFS if you work for a charity you are supposed to being doing charitable stuff! Not trying to shaft people into giving you money!

TeamD

5,060 posts

263 months

Monday 13th March 2006
quotequote all
SKR said:
FFS if you work for a charity you are supposed to being doing charitable stuff! Not trying to shaft people into giving you money!


I wouldn't be so sure of that these days.

Nick P

Original Poster:

29,977 posts

282 months

Monday 13th March 2006
quotequote all
I just find it a bit off-putting in this day and age, that the 'jar rattlers' can force themselves INTO your homes nowadays

luckily MrsP is quite switched on and and able to say no and send them on there way.

Its getting harder to tell an illegal scam from a genuine scam nowadays

>> Edited by Nick P on Monday 13th March 13:46

Carrera2

8,352 posts

263 months

Monday 13th March 2006
quotequote all
Nick P said:
I just find it a bit off-putting in this day and age, that the 'jar rattlers' can force themselves INTO your homes nowadays

luckily MrsP is quite switched and and able to say no and send them on there way.

Its getting harder to tell an illegal scam from a genuine scam nowadays


I DD money to Banardos and got fed up with canvass calls I used to get so I upped my subscription and told them if I recieve another call I'll cancel it. I havent' had a call for about 2 years now.

rpguk

4,520 posts

315 months

Monday 13th March 2006
quotequote all
Charity is big business these days and it is about getting as much money possible in. Sadly they are using business tactics these days.

Much as I'm uncomfortable with the agressively commercial way its gone in the past few years. These 'agencies' do bring in more money then a whole army of OAP's with collection tins ever could, no matter how good their intentions. Add to that there is a lot more red tape with collecting these days.

>> Edited by rpguk on Monday 13th March 16:01

Mattyboy101

16,664 posts

249 months

Monday 13th March 2006
quotequote all
Similar thing happened with my Dad, he already donates, but they rang him up and asked him to increase his donation from £6 a month to £10 (figures off the top of my head) and he agreed.

Later the bill came through and they had started charging him £16!!

alfaman

6,416 posts

265 months

Monday 13th March 2006
quotequote all
I used to have DD for Cancer Research.

They are very tenacious, once they have your details they will try and increase the DD every year ....gets to be a pain.

dmitsi

3,583 posts

251 months

Monday 13th March 2006
quotequote all
My problem with these canvassers is the percentage of the money that actually goes through to the charity. Now obviously you do have to pay wages, but some of them take over 50% of the money donated. My brother used to administrate for one of the companies that ran the people on the street, not only were they all very well paid, but the MD was getting serious money, well into the £100,000's.

They will say that they need to attract the right people for the job, but when you look into how they actually spread the money, a lot of the companies don't seem to know their arse from their elbow when it came to helping out the needy.

I won't give to people on the street unless they're selling me a big issue, any other charity I want to partake in is generally direct action.

TeamD

5,060 posts

263 months

Monday 13th March 2006
quotequote all
dmitsi said:
My problem with these canvassers is the percentage of the money that actually goes through to the charity. Now obviously you do have to pay wages, but some of them take over 50% of the money donated. My brother used to administrate for one of the companies that ran the people on the street, not only were they all very well paid, but the MD was getting serious money, well into the £100,000's.

They will say that they need to attract the right people for the job, but when you look into how they actually spread the money, a lot of the companies don't seem to know their arse from their elbow when it came to helping out the needy.

I won't give to people on the street unless they're selling me a big issue, any other charity I want to partake in is generally direct action.


My charity comes from buying too much fast food when pissed late at night, I guess I'm gonna get sued one day by a beggar who reckons I've done them harm by giving them a Qtr Pounder with Cheese and Fries.

Dodgey_Rog

2,025 posts

291 months

Monday 13th March 2006
quotequote all
dmitsi said:
My problem with these canvassers is the percentage of the money that actually goes through to the charity. Now obviously you do have to pay wages, but some of them take over 50% of the money donated. My brother used to administrate for one of the companies that ran the people on the street, not only were they all very well paid, but the MD was getting serious money, well into the £100,000's.

They will say that they need to attract the right people for the job, but when you look into how they actually spread the money, a lot of the companies don't seem to know their arse from their elbow when it came to helping out the needy.

I won't give to people on the street unless they're selling me a big issue, any other charity I want to partake in is generally direct action.


I'm reluctant to do that now. A friend of mine used to walk past this guy everyday in the city, one day whilst he was late in the office, happened to be walking the same route home, this "homeless" guy had packed up and was walking away when my mate followed him, he happened to take the same shortcut through some side streets. This homeless guy only walks a few more streets, takes off his shabby looking jumper, pops the boot of his late plate M3, jumps in and away he went. Apparently this guy was changing up between £200 and £300 a day in the local offy!!! course its all tax free.

So i don't tend to give to them anymore!!!

Bennem

284 posts

270 months

Monday 13th March 2006
quotequote all
I'm fed up with can shakers and them calling out " .....give for the helpless children..." or some other emotive twaddle. I'm a miserable b****d so I go up and whisper in their shell like that it is illegal to shake the can or ask for donations as that is classified as begging and I could call the local BiB and have them moved on. Amazingly they shut up for a while after that.

dmitsi

3,583 posts

251 months

Monday 13th March 2006
quotequote all
Dodgey_Rog said:
dmitsi said:
My problem with these canvassers is the percentage of the money that actually goes through to the charity. Now obviously you do have to pay wages, but some of them take over 50% of the money donated. My brother used to administrate for one of the companies that ran the people on the street, not only were they all very well paid, but the MD was getting serious money, well into the £100,000's.

They will say that they need to attract the right people for the job, but when you look into how they actually spread the money, a lot of the companies don't seem to know their arse from their elbow when it came to helping out the needy.

I won't give to people on the street unless they're selling me a big issue, any other charity I want to partake in is generally direct action.


I'm reluctant to do that now. A friend of mine used to walk past this guy everyday in the city, one day whilst he was late in the office, happened to be walking the same route home, this "homeless" guy had packed up and was walking away when my mate followed him, he happened to take the same shortcut through some side streets. This homeless guy only walks a few more streets, takes off his shabby looking jumper, pops the boot of his late plate M3, jumps in and away he went. Apparently this guy was changing up between £200 and £300 a day in the local offy!!! course its all tax free.

So i don't tend to give to them anymore!!!


Yeah, I'm a bit dubious of some of them, I know it's for the homeless, or at risk of being homeless, but there will always people who abuse the system. I do buy the Big Issue, but always from 1 of 3 people locally. One is very honest, and has said on a good day it can work out at anything between 15-20p/h, which is pretty good in anyones book. Though other days he'll sell very little.

vipers

33,525 posts

259 months

Monday 13th March 2006
quotequote all
Parrot of Doom said:
Tell the person making the call to start running for her life.


Tell them to hang on whilst you start the tape recorder...

blueyes

4,799 posts

283 months

Monday 13th March 2006
quotequote all
I had a call from somebody selling ad space on a calendar on behalf of the local police.

Told them our company had already donated £60 in speeding fines and so they could stick their ad space up their arse.


Which was nice.

morrisman

264 posts

249 months

Monday 13th March 2006
quotequote all
alfaman said:
I used to have DD for Cancer Research.

They are very tenacious, once they have your details they will try and increase the DD every year ....gets to be a pain.

Lets face it, if they didn't ask openly, cheekily or even in your face, then 99.999% of people wouldn't give a cent. Is it really that hard to just say 'no' when you don't want to give?

Mrs Trackside

9,299 posts

264 months

Monday 13th March 2006
quotequote all
morrisman said:
alfaman said:
I used to have DD for Cancer Research.

They are very tenacious, once they have your details they will try and increase the DD every year ....gets to be a pain.

Lets face it, if they didn't ask openly, cheekily or even in your face, then 99.999% of people wouldn't give a cent. Is it really that hard to just say 'no' when you don't want to give?

Since my dad was diagnosed with prostrate cancer and I was diagnosed with pre-cancerous cells two years ago, I've given £2 a month to cancer research. Like someone else said, I kept getting letters with a free pen asking me for more money (about one every two months) and then I got a phone call asking if I'd like to increase my subscription. I was very polite and told them that I'd love to give more, but couldn't afford to (which is true), but that if I saw an increase in my disposal income I'd be happy to increase the payment myself via online banking. The woman was quite pushy and kept trying to get me to increase my donation. In the end, I told her that I strongly objected to my donations being spent on marketing being sent to me and that if I received one more letter or phone call, I would cancel my subscription altogether. I haven't heard a thing since.