Does the UK need to replace the Trident missile system?
Does the UK need to replace the Trident missile system?
Author
Discussion

alltorque

Original Poster:

2,646 posts

300 months

Tuesday 14th March 2006
quotequote all

Apparently they're becoming obsolete by 2020.

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk_politic

Does the uk need a nuclear deterrent? Would you feel more vulnerable without them?

pistonsleeper

563 posts

248 months

Tuesday 14th March 2006
quotequote all
Yes! Mainly because of 1980's technology needs to be replaced with 21st century technology!

TeamD

5,060 posts

263 months

Tuesday 14th March 2006
quotequote all
pistonsleeper said:
Yes! Mainly because of 1980's technology needs to be replaced with 21st century technology!


Stick to the old stuff, it's more reliable and NOT made in China.

JagLover

46,848 posts

266 months

Tuesday 14th March 2006
quotequote all
alltorque said:


Does the uk need a nuclear deterrent? Would you feel more vulnerable without them?


Yes, now more than ever.

With regimes such as North Korea and (potentially) Iran possessing Nuclear weapons, and the possibility that state sponsored terrorists could obtain such weapons, they are as vital now as at the height of the cold war.

s2art

18,942 posts

284 months

Tuesday 14th March 2006
quotequote all
We need a big scarey deterent, but it doesnt have to be a Trident replacement.
How about investing all that money into bio-warfare instead?

alltorque

Original Poster:

2,646 posts

300 months

Tuesday 14th March 2006
quotequote all
I agree, but the argument is that we'd never set them off without US consent anyway. As they've got loads more than us, is it just for the 'feelgood' factor?

Nick P

29,977 posts

282 months

Tuesday 14th March 2006
quotequote all
s2art said:
We need a big scarey deterent, but it doesnt have to be a Trident replacement.
How about investing all that money into bio-warfare instead?


thats a bit naughty.we would never do that.

*realises that i get pumped full of anthrax on a regular basis*

ATG

23,875 posts

303 months

Tuesday 14th March 2006
quotequote all
Anyone have the faintest idea what they mean by "obsolete"?

Surely the purpose of a nuclear deterrent is to be able to wipe out an enemy's cities after he has already nuked ours? Trident can do that now. What is going to stop it from doing that in twenty years?

>> Edited by ATG on Tuesday 14th March 15:26

TeamD

5,060 posts

263 months

Tuesday 14th March 2006
quotequote all
ATG said:
Anyone have the faintest idea what they mean by "obsolete"?


Out of Warranty.

FourWheelDrift

92,401 posts

315 months

Tuesday 14th March 2006
quotequote all
alltorque said:

Apparently they're becoming obsolete by 2020.


I guess they have a "Best before" label like - "Half-life expected from 2020".



s2art

18,942 posts

284 months

Tuesday 14th March 2006
quotequote all
ATG said:
Anyone have the faintest idea what they mean by "obsolete"?

Surely the purpose of a nuclear deterrent is to be able to wipe out an enemy's cities after he has already nuked ours? Trident can do that now. What is going to stop it from doing that in twenty years?

>> Edited by ATG on Tuesday 14th March 15:26


I think the nukes 'sell by date' is over by then, and also they are expensive to produce. The US and UK are working on a cheaper bomb.

andymadmak

15,730 posts

301 months

Tuesday 14th March 2006
quotequote all
The answer depends on who, with our crystal ball in place, we believe we are likely to be fighting in the future.
I fully supported the British nuclear deterrent during the 60s and 70s and 80s because it worked. Our most likely foes (the soviet bloc) feared our destructive revenge should they have attacked. The policy of Mutually Assured Destruction (MAD) was enough to pull the world back from the brink time after time.
The problem with MAD is that it only works if your opponent gives a flying fig about the prospect of his/her own death. Many observers believe that the next really big war will involve the middle east or possibly even some sort of showdoen between Islam and the west. Not sure how effective a MAD policy is against that kind of enemy.
As for the Chinese of North Koreans I suspect they lie somewhere between the middle east fanatics and the cogent soviets in their attitudes to MAD.
Taking everything into account I'd go for the lowest cost upgrade route and try to extend Tridents life till 2040 or such like. After all the subs are still good, and modern technology ought to be able to make the missles and war heads a bit more flexible (and safer?)

Andy

>> Edited by andymadmak on Tuesday 14th March 15:30

alltorque

Original Poster:

2,646 posts

300 months

Tuesday 14th March 2006
quotequote all
TeamD said:
ATG said:
Anyone have the faintest idea what they mean by "obsolete"?


Out of Warranty.


A website said:


Even though the last ship, Vengeance, was commissioned only in 1999, there are practical and political pressures on the UK government to consider whether the system (ship, missile and warhead) should be replaced in about 2024. Obsolescence may arise in all three components, not least because of the computerised electronics which control them, the need for regular (nuclear) re-fuelling, and to update the navigational systems on the missiles. Because of the very long lead-time in development, the UK government has said that it will take the decision whether or not to replace Trident during the life of the current UK Parliament.


Can't they just fit Tom-Toms on them all?

Cyberhuss

1,940 posts

277 months

Tuesday 14th March 2006
quotequote all
Nick P said:
*realises that i get pumped full of anthrax on a regular basis*


You never used to be like this did you? it's like Nervous has taken over your soul..

ATG

23,875 posts

303 months

Tuesday 14th March 2006
quotequote all
s2art said:
ATG said:
Anyone have the faintest idea what they mean by "obsolete"?

Surely the purpose of a nuclear deterrent is to be able to wipe out an enemy's cities after he has already nuked ours? Trident can do that now. What is going to stop it from doing that in twenty years?

>> Edited by ATG on Tuesday 14th March 15:26


I think the nukes 'sell by date' is over by then, and also they are expensive to produce. The US and UK are working on a cheaper bomb.
If it really is the case that the maintenace cost of the existing system is higher than the cost of replacing it with something new, then I'm all for it, but does that really seem likely? Maybe the yanks are pulling the spare parts guarantee?

monkeyhanger

9,267 posts

273 months

Tuesday 14th March 2006
quotequote all
Replace it without a doubt. As long as everyone else has (or wants) them, then we'd be stupid to disarm unilaterally.

It actually makes me feel a bit old. I worked on the Trident Sub Programme at Faslane when i was an apprentice (late 80's / early 90's) very weird to hear them talk of replacing it already.

Time flies

jimbeaux

33,791 posts

262 months

Tuesday 14th March 2006
quotequote all
TeamD said:
ATG said:
Anyone have the faintest idea what they mean by "obsolete"?


Out of Warranty.


Paint scheme is out of style....it would looks extremely unfashionable flying over our allies in 80s pastels!

>> Edited by jimbeaux on Tuesday 14th March 15:51

s2art

18,942 posts

284 months

Tuesday 14th March 2006
quotequote all
ATG said:
s2art said:
ATG said:
Anyone have the faintest idea what they mean by "obsolete"?

Surely the purpose of a nuclear deterrent is to be able to wipe out an enemy's cities after he has already nuked ours? Trident can do that now. What is going to stop it from doing that in twenty years?

>> Edited by ATG on Tuesday 14th March 15:26


I think the nukes 'sell by date' is over by then, and also they are expensive to produce. The US and UK are working on a cheaper bomb.
If it really is the case that the maintenace cost of the existing system is higher than the cost of replacing it with something new, then I'm all for it, but does that really seem likely? Maybe the yanks are pulling the spare parts guarantee?


We are working on a warhead that uses a bit more tritium, a bit more plutonium etc to make it simpler and more robust. Basically we will be building Fords not Ferraris (the old style nukes were highly tuned, highly engineered brutes.)

TeamD

5,060 posts

263 months

Tuesday 14th March 2006
quotequote all
s2art said:
We are working on a warhead that uses a bit more tritium, a bit more plutonium etc to make it simpler and more robust. Basically we will be building Fords not Ferraris (the old style nukes were highly tuned, highly engineered brutes.)


Ah! And less likely to induce climate change perchance?

tinman0

18,231 posts

271 months

Tuesday 14th March 2006
quotequote all
alltorque said:
Does the uk need a nuclear deterrent? Would you feel more vulnerable without them?


we could buy a typewriter with red ink and send really nasty letters.