Here's a good reason for the water shortage
Here's a good reason for the water shortage
Author
Discussion

simpo two

Original Poster:

93,103 posts

296 months

Wednesday 15th March 2006
quotequote all
Heard on R4 this morning: one of the water companies - Thames? - filled in some of its reservoirs so houses could be built on them.

How dumb is that?

Marki

15,763 posts

301 months

Wednesday 15th March 2006
quotequote all
Dumb certainly , suprising never

polus

4,343 posts

256 months

Wednesday 15th March 2006
quotequote all
Surely theres a reason.... There MUST be a reason.

>> Edited by polus on Wednesday 15th March 11:01

alexkp

16,484 posts

275 months

Wednesday 15th March 2006
quotequote all
polus said:
Surely theres a reason.... There MUST be a reason.

>> Edited by polus on Wednesday 15th March 11:01



You will be relieved to hear that yes! There is a reason!

They got a lot of money from the sales that in the short term they could pass on as large dividends to their shareholders!

Thank goodness for that eh?

FourWheelDrift

92,402 posts

315 months

Wednesday 15th March 2006
quotequote all
polus said:
Surely theres a reason.... There MUST be a reason.


They were offered a very large brown envelope stuffed full of cash to buy the land and allow them to build their houses on cheaper brown belt land and make a bigger profit. Instead of having to go cap in hand and with an even bigger brown envelope stuffed full of even more cash to the local council for permission to build on green belt land and make less profit.

polus

4,343 posts

256 months

Wednesday 15th March 2006
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]


Thats not a reason...

polus

4,343 posts

256 months

Wednesday 15th March 2006
quotequote all
FourWheelDrift said:
polus said:
Surely theres a reason.... There MUST be a reason.


They were offered a very large brown envelope stuffed full of cash to buy the land and allow them to build their houses on cheaper brown belt land and make a bigger profit. Instead of having to go cap in hand and with an even bigger brown envelope stuffed full of even more cash to the local council for permission to build on green belt land and make less profit.


Neither is that....

Edited to add I could work that one out for myself, I was looking for a valid reason why they were not required. It seems captain corruption strikes again!

>> Edited by polus on Wednesday 15th March 11:17

alexkp

16,484 posts

275 months

Wednesday 15th March 2006
quotequote all
polus said:
FourWheelDrift said:
polus said:
Surely theres a reason.... There MUST be a reason.


They were offered a very large brown envelope stuffed full of cash to buy the land and allow them to build their houses on cheaper brown belt land and make a bigger profit. Instead of having to go cap in hand and with an even bigger brown envelope stuffed full of even more cash to the local council for permission to build on green belt land and make less profit.


Neither is that....

Edited to add I could work that one out for myself, I was looking for a valid reason why they were not required. It seems captain corruption strikes again!

>> Edited by polus on Wednesday 15th March 11:17


You know, you might be onto something there...

>> Edited by alexkp on Wednesday 15th March 11:21

polus

4,343 posts

256 months

Wednesday 15th March 2006
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]


Thanks

Im still looking for that reason...

Jaglover

46,848 posts

266 months

Wednesday 15th March 2006
quotequote all
simpo two said:


How dumb is that?


Depends on the location I suppose and how much money was raised for the company. In many areas I imagine the land the reservoir sits on is very valuable and if the money raised was used for replacing pipes, or even building a new reservoir in an area with a lower cost of land, then there would be no reduction in the amount of water they could supply.

Without knowing more of the details of these transactions we cannot judge.

alexkp

16,484 posts

275 months

Wednesday 15th March 2006
quotequote all
Jaglover said:
simpo two said:


How dumb is that?


Depends on the location I suppose and how much money was raised for the company. In many areas I imagine the land the reservoir sits on is very valuable and if the money raised was used for replacing pipes, or even building a new reservoir in an area with a lower cost of land, then there would be no reduction in the amount of water they could supply.

Without knowing more of the details of these transactions we cannot judge.


Well we can say they have reduced the number of resovoirs, and they are now threatening a water shortage.

Fewer resovoirs is likely to mean less water in reserve.

Methinks there is a slight possibility of a correlation here...

Jaglover

46,848 posts

266 months

Wednesday 15th March 2006
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]


I think there is a rather stronger correlation with the fact that for two winters in a row (the last one in particular) rainfall in the south east has been far below annual averages. From the point of view of water supplies it is winter rainfall that is important, due to the fact that in the rest of the year rain is quickly absorbed by plants or lost to evaporation.

alexkp

16,484 posts

275 months

Wednesday 15th March 2006
quotequote all
Jaglover said:
anonymous said:
[redacted]


I think there is a rather stronger correlation with the fact that for two winters in a row (the last one in particular) rainfall in the south east has been far below annual averages. From the point of view of water supplies it is winter rainfall that is important, due to the fact that in the rest of the year rain is quickly absorbed by plants or lost to evaporation.


Damn you and damn your facts and resonable logic!

While this is almost certainly a contributary factor, it remains the truth that the water network is not in a good state of repair, and collosal amounts are lost due to faulty and old watermains - while at the same time the price of the utility increases substantially as do the dividends paid to shareholders.

I'm afraid this is yet another example of a state resource and service being exploited and squeezed to make more money for a few.

In addition, given that we are an Island surrounded by water, we should have invested in a few desalination plants years ago as a standby just in case of this type of scenario.

yertis

19,742 posts

297 months

Wednesday 15th March 2006
quotequote all
I don't buy the two winters' low rainfall argument. For once I'm with KP. Capitalism gone wrong. The clue is in the name "reservoir". You don't reduce your reserves in face of a sustained increase in demand. Crazyness.

Fatboy

8,272 posts

303 months

Wednesday 15th March 2006
quotequote all
alexkp said:
Jaglover said:
anonymous said:
[redacted]


I think there is a rather stronger correlation with the fact that for two winters in a row (the last one in particular) rainfall in the south east has been far below annual averages. From the point of view of water supplies it is winter rainfall that is important, due to the fact that in the rest of the year rain is quickly absorbed by plants or lost to evaporation.


Damn you and damn your facts and resonable logic!

While this is almost certainly a contributary factor, it remains the truth that the water network is not in a good state of repair, and collosal amounts are lost due to faulty and old watermains - while at the same time the price of the utility increases substantially as do the dividends paid to shareholders.

I'm afraid this is yet another example of a state resource and service being exploited and squeezed to make more money for a few.

In addition, given that we are an Island surrounded by water, we should have invested in a few desalination plants years ago as a standby just in case of this type of scenario.

I would also like to add to that the information that of all the Water Companies, Thames water has either the worst, or second worst record for leakage and general performance - year on year.

Yes, rainfall has been lower, but that Does not absolve Thames water of their responisibilities to sort out the ridiculous number of leaks in their infrastructure.

Jaglover

46,848 posts

266 months

Wednesday 15th March 2006
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]


But then you have the issue of redundant capacity, if we build a system that can whether the worst drought without any water restrictions whatsoever then for 9/10ths of the time we have reservoirs or indeed desalination plants that we simply don't need.

As for the price increases, much of it was due to EU regulation to improve water quality and the treatment of waste. We now have cleaner beaches for example.

The general British attitude when confronted by company making a profit seems to be to ask 'what are they doing wrong?'. This attitude seems to be becoming more prevalent on PH's as well.

planetdave

9,922 posts

284 months

Wednesday 15th March 2006
quotequote all
Jaglover said:
anonymous said:
[redacted]


I think there is a rather stronger correlation with the fact that for two winters in a row (the last one in particular) rainfall in the south east has been far below annual averages. From the point of view of water supplies it is winter rainfall that is important, due to the fact that in the rest of the year rain is quickly absorbed by plants or lost to evaporation.


Not lost to plants or evaporation to any extent. What we need is steady drizzle so that the precipitation has enough time to soak into the soil and feed the water table. Heavy rain just shoots off across the surface going into the drains/rivers and thus lost. It's not helped by all and sundry in the south east doing home improvements. Adding a conservatory or patio just reduces the soil area that is free to absorb moisture. The water table lowers causing building damage and dry gardens (more watering required) and the amount of sudden run-off can cause floods.

The S.E. is a water disaster waiting to happen.


Think I'll pop out and leave my hose on in the garden. For the entire summer :smug:

esselte

14,626 posts

298 months

Wednesday 15th March 2006
quotequote all
Jaglover said:
anonymous said:
[redacted]


But then you have the issue of redundant capacity, if we build a system that can whether the worst drought without any water restrictions whatsoever then for 9/10ths of the time we have reservoirs or indeed desalination plants that we simply don't need.

As for the price increases, much of it was due to EU regulation to improve water quality and the treatment of waste. We now have cleaner beaches for example.

The general British attitude when confronted by company making a profit seems to be to ask 'what are they doing wrong?'. This attitude seems to be becoming more prevalent on PH's as well.


I suppose the difference is that we have no choice where to buy our water from unlike bread,gas,electricity etc.So the company has a captive audience and doesn't have to be competitive.(I know it's somewhat simplistic and there are organisations such as OFWAT to regulate them but you get my drift)

B16 RFF

883 posts

298 months

Wednesday 15th March 2006
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]


1) Some may or may not have made money, but the fact is that the water supply ( and sewage) infrastructure is in far better shape now than it has been for many years under public ownership.

2) Isn't hindsight wonderful?

Paul.

>> Edited by B16 RFF on Wednesday 15th March 12:06

B16 RFF

883 posts

298 months

Wednesday 15th March 2006
quotequote all
simpo two said:
Heard on R4 this morning: one of the water companies - Thames? - filled in some of its reservoirs so houses could be built on them.

How dumb is that?


Could be, but the current problem is lack of water, not storage capacity.

Paul.