its bad to give your company to your kids now
its bad to give your company to your kids now
Author
Discussion

tinman0

Original Poster:

18,231 posts

271 months

Wednesday 15th March 2006
quotequote all
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/business/4

You couldn't make this stuff up.

Apparently, its not right that family firms stay in the hands of the families that built them.

The words "sod off" spring to mind.

Ecks Ridgehead

4,285 posts

259 months

Wednesday 15th March 2006
quotequote all
tinman0 said:
Apparently, its not right that family firms stay in the hands of the families that built them.


That's not what the article says at all.

Simpo Two

93,103 posts

296 months

Wednesday 15th March 2006
quotequote all
Actually they have a point. Is it likely that Mr X's son is really going to be the best candidate for, say, Marketing Manager when compared to 50 others? Chance are they'll be employing him for his relationship, not his ability.

esselte

14,626 posts

298 months

Wednesday 15th March 2006
quotequote all
This is what it's all about.....

from the bbc page

"It would also raise about £250m a year for government spending....."

Let's tax it,that should make things better!


_Batty_

12,268 posts

281 months

Wednesday 15th March 2006
quotequote all
Simpo Two said:
Actually they have a point. Is it likely that Mr X's son is really going to be the best candidate for, say, Marketing Manager when compared to 50 others? Chance are they'll be employing him for his relationship, not his ability.


your point?
its his firm not anyone elses.
if he wants the company to go down the pan then fine.

M.Crozier son of
I.Crozier son of
J.Crozier of
J.Crozier Builders Ltd, founded in 1932-current

alfaman

6,416 posts

265 months

Wednesday 15th March 2006
quotequote all
but there is not much logic for exempting privately owned firms from IHT , when other peoples lifetime earnings doing similar work in a large corporation ARE annihilated by IHT.

IMHO - IHT should be abolished completely for everyone , or the threshold raised to at least £3m ish ( for everyone)

esselte

14,626 posts

298 months

Wednesday 15th March 2006
quotequote all
alfaman said:
but there is not much logic for exempting privately owned firms from IHT , when other peoples lifetime earnings doing similar work in a large corporation ARE annihilated by IHT.

IMHO - IHT should be abolished completely for everyone , or the threshold raised to at least £3m ish ( for everyone)


I suppose if all the assets are in a company then forcing the new owner to sell to pay IHT could close the company and put people on the dole?(I may be talking rubbish here)

alfaman

6,416 posts

265 months

Wednesday 15th March 2006
quotequote all
esselte said:
alfaman said:
but there is not much logic for exempting privately owned firms from IHT , when other peoples lifetime earnings doing similar work in a large corporation ARE annihilated by IHT.

IMHO - IHT should be abolished completely for everyone , or the threshold raised to at least £3m ish ( for everyone)


I suppose if all the assets are in a company then forcing the new owner to sell to pay IHT could close the company and put people on the dole?(I may be talking rubbish here)


agreed , I guess the way round it would be to massively gear up the business , and gift the cash raised to ones dependants within the 7 year rule .

.... but IHT is still immoral for everyone IMHO

Parrot of Doom

23,075 posts

265 months

Wednesday 15th March 2006
quotequote all
I wouldn't put faith in somebody who said that Wal-Mart was a well run company.

tinman0

Original Poster:

18,231 posts

271 months

Wednesday 15th March 2006
quotequote all
Simpo Two said:
Actually they have a point.


No they don't.

What i do with my company when i retire is my business and no one elses.

Don

28,378 posts

315 months

Wednesday 15th March 2006
quotequote all
alfaman said:
but there is not much logic for exempting privately owned firms from IHT , when other peoples lifetime earnings doing similar work in a large corporation ARE annihilated by IHT.

IMHO - IHT should be abolished completely for everyone , or the threshold raised to at least £3m ish ( for everyone)


Lets say you have a firm. Dad owns 30% Son owns 30% Nephew owns 30% Cousin owns 10%.

Lets say its doing very well. Its worth a lot of money. Dad wants to retire. He has to *sell* the shares at a fair value to either someone else OR the current shareholder. He'll be taxed on the Capital Gain.

Lets say he dies. Leaves the shares to his Son and nephews. The shares are valued. Inheritance Tax becomes due. EricMc can probably correct - but as I understand it transferring shares in valuable limited companies does attract tax?

timmy30

9,325 posts

258 months

Wednesday 15th March 2006
quotequote all
Pre Budget BBC Labour Spinning Quango said:
But the Centre for Economic Performance (CEP) said the benefits of family management are usually lost if control is passed to the children of founders.

It said inheritance tax should be used to discourage the practice.


Why not go the whole hog, on the death of the founder, ownership of family firms could be automatically trnasferred to the government, who could then appoint an 'independant asset allocation council' that would appoint new owners on socially just lines ( using quotas for gender and ethinic mix of course ).

Ecks Ridgehead

4,285 posts

259 months

Wednesday 15th March 2006
quotequote all
tinman0 said:
Simpo Two said:
Actually they have a point.


No they don't.

What i do with my company when i retire is my business and no one elses.


Quite right. It doesn't say anywhere in the article that people will be prevented from giving their company to their children.

DieselJohn

2,114 posts

287 months

Wednesday 15th March 2006
quotequote all
I kind of see the point. As evil as inheritance tax is there is no particular reason that family businesses should be exempt.

angrys3owner

15,855 posts

260 months

Wednesday 15th March 2006
quotequote all
More meddling b0ll0cks from our government that's not needed - to55ers!

Why can't they just leave us hard working with morals types alone and sort the real problems - oh I know it's too hard to sort them so lets just stitch up those we can get nice and easy. Makes me sick.

JonRB

80,227 posts

303 months

Wednesday 15th March 2006
quotequote all
DieselJohn said:
I kind of see the point. As evil as inheritance tax is there is no particular reason that family businesses should be exempt.
Perhaps. However, it is more complicated than that. If a father employs his son who works his way up the company management hierarchy over a number of years and then is appointed the MD when his father retires, then apart from the nepotism I really can't see a problem and I can't see how greedy Gordon can justify getting his trotters into this other than the fact that he's running out of things to tax.

However, it is an imbalance, I agree. But balance should be brought by abolishing Inheritance Tax, not trying to tax this scenario.


>> Edited by JonRB on Wednesday 15th March 16:21

timmy30

9,325 posts

258 months

Wednesday 15th March 2006
quotequote all
DieselJohn said:
I kind of see the point. As evil as inheritance tax is there is no particular reason that family businesses should be exempt.


I see the point too, pre budget spin for a tightening of the rules on inheritance tax, but seeing as this is a progressive business friendly government rather than a authoritarian socialist government they will be doing it in the best interests of business rather than to grab more private wealth and extend state control of the economy, yes of course

TeamD

5,060 posts

263 months

Wednesday 15th March 2006
quotequote all
Awww bollox to this, I'm gonna knock the wife up a few more times and quit my job, there's no point in doing otherwise.

catso

16,570 posts

298 months

Wednesday 15th March 2006
quotequote all
timmy30 said:
Pre Budget BBC Labour Spinning Quango said:
It said inheritance tax should be used to discourage the practice.





No surprise there then.......

Simpo Two

93,103 posts

296 months

Wednesday 15th March 2006
quotequote all
_Batty_ said:
Simpo Two said:
Actually they have a point. Is it likely that Mr X's son is really going to be the best candidate for, say, Marketing Manager when compared to 50 others? Chance are they'll be employing him for his relationship, not his ability.


your point?
its his firm not anyone elses.
if he wants the company to go down the pan then fine.

M.Crozier son of
I.Crozier son of
J.Crozier of
J.Crozier Builders Ltd, founded in 1932-current


My point is exactly what I stated. If you failed to understand it, you just proved my point.

>> Edited by Simpo Two on Wednesday 15th March 16:53