Gentle prod at the housing market..............
Gentle prod at the housing market..............
Author
Discussion

timmy30

Original Poster:

9,325 posts

258 months

Friday 17th March 2006
quotequote all
I know that this topic can get a little, erm emotive. And I realise that for alot of PHers property is/will be a significant investment strategy.

I just wanted to draw attention to the following letter in money week from an estate agent of all people, just pointing out some of the potential downside in the market.

www.moneyweek.com/file/6314/letters.html#househigh

Not looking for a fight, not saying the guy is right, I have property too, etc etc, donning flame retardent suit, just trying to inject a little balance into peoples perception that this market is so very different to every other.

xm5er

5,094 posts

279 months

Friday 17th March 2006
quotequote all
That guy has written my thoughts perfectly. I couldn't agree more.

timmy30

Original Poster:

9,325 posts

258 months

Friday 17th March 2006
quotequote all
Here's the highlights......

Of course if you're buying a house to live in for the long term, this isn't really anything to worry about....but if you building a property portfolio on margin, it may be.

retired estate agent and active property investor said:
There is no further upside to property prices. Prices are already too high, yields are pathetic, downside risk for most amateur investors is a tragi-comedy. People are up to their borrowing limits, many are re-scheduling loans to help make repayments on existing loans.


retired estate agent and active property investor said:
UK property is an over inflated, pumped up and very dangerous bubble, utterly dependent on hype, lies, low interest rates and excessive lending...(and compliant journalists). Low interest rates and easy money are of course unsustainable.



retired estate agent and active property investor said:
The latest method Building Societies have of keeping money pumping into property is to allow parents to borrow to help their kids buy ever more expensive property. Few people seem to have realised that the reason property keeps going up, is because the lenders keep finding ways of enabling people to borrow more and therefore pay more.

mattley

3,039 posts

253 months

Friday 17th March 2006
quotequote all
I aggree with almost all that, but it all goes wrong at the end. Demand is not there because of hype, It's there because people need somewhere to live. The flattening of prices is more down to the low inflation caused primarily by China subsidising it's business's. This practice is already reducing, and soon good old inflation will be back, this will erode debt, and we'll be off again.

Nick P

29,977 posts

282 months

Friday 17th March 2006
quotequote all
we bought an investment property a while ago (that my parents retn from me) so the mortgage is being paid. We were also considering buying more, but have now decided against it and will plough ALL our money into our own home in about 4 years when i retire from my current job.

timmy30

Original Poster:

9,325 posts

258 months

Friday 17th March 2006
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]


Totally agree, hence my disclaimer that if you're 'buying to live' with a decent deposit there's nothing too much to worry about...but if you going to jump waist deep into a leveraged position in the property market now might not be the best time to do it.

Mind you, each to their own, it's none of my business to say what people should and shouldn't do, just thought it would be of interest to some people to see both sides.

After all when you buy and sell shares and commodities, you should be open to the idea that the market may move against you. So why not for housing?

tonyvid

9,889 posts

274 months

Friday 17th March 2006
quotequote all
I have always felt that property pricing is done by the wrong people - estate agents have a vested interest in high prices so they will always push the market. I know demand fuels prices but around my way(St Neots)prices are stupid, any "non-professional" doesn't stand a chance with even the smallest flat(actually my old first home)being over 90k. Someone who is say a factory worker or shop bod is stuffed. I do think we have a higher paid perspective on PH where 200k seems like a snip but some poor buggers are going to really struggle in a distorted market.

B17NNS

18,506 posts

278 months

Friday 17th March 2006
quotequote all
I actually see prices continuing to rise.

The new homebuyers report means that people who advertise their property for sale will actually have to invest in the process (surveys etc).

This will reduce the amount of property on the market and remove the 'lets put it up for sale - if it sells great, if not, no problem'.

Less supply = higher prices.

anonymous-user

85 months

Friday 17th March 2006
quotequote all
B17NNS said:
I actually see prices continuing to rise.

The new homebuyers report means that people who advertise their property for sale will actually have to invest in the process (surveys etc).

This will reduce the amount of property on the market and remove the 'lets put it up for sale - if it sells great, if not, no problem'.

Less supply = higher prices.


Not sure I agree with your reasoning (I might though) BUT I definately agree with your comclusion that property will continue to rise.

gt

1,407 posts

289 months

Friday 17th March 2006
quotequote all
What an utter knob.

letter full of rhetorhic, no stats to back it up with, and to add insult to injury what sort of muppet says "oh and look how wonderful I am, I sold out at the top blah blah blah, you should all do the same just because I did"?

He may be right, he may be wrong, but he comes across as being so far up his own arse i doubt he'll ever see daylight again.

Davi

17,153 posts

251 months

Friday 17th March 2006
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]
agree with most of that.

One of the most noticable problems I have seen recently is that in some area's (mine particularly) demand is outstripping supply - I've been hearing this from clients for some time, but I'm now quite regularly getting calls from different people enquiring about the possibility of a BTL on the same property. I've also been hearing from estate agents that they have stopped taking sold properties off the displays because there is simply not enough new property coming on the market to replace it with. For the first time this week though, I saw a property withdrawn from market and re-issued, with an asking price £35,000 higher due to the overwhelming interest in it.

morrisman

264 posts

249 months

Friday 17th March 2006
quotequote all
garyhun said:
B17NNS said:
I actually see prices continuing to rise.

The new homebuyers report means that people who advertise their property for sale will actually have to invest in the process (surveys etc).

This will reduce the amount of property on the market and remove the 'lets put it up for sale - if it sells great, if not, no problem'.

Less supply = higher prices.


Not sure I agree with your reasoning (I might though) BUT I definately agree with your comclusion that property will continue to rise.


Overheard in an Estate Agents:

Punter: I'd like to put an offer on this house
Agent: I wouldn't bother with an offer, just give the full amount to make sure you get it.
Punter: But we don't want to pay that much.
Agent: Well, you're really just wasting my time if you try to undercut the value of the 'home'!

Notice they are always 'homes' when somebody wants to sell them.

nonegreen

7,803 posts

301 months

Friday 17th March 2006
quotequote all
The main factors supporting rising house prices are a 60 year history of underbuilding, low interest rates and an influx of immigrants who are prepared to live 30 to a house and hotbed. These conditions ensure we continue to have a glut of halfwits masquerading as property developers. The future is clear, the future is the great Euro blackmail vote. Gummint turns off immigration tap, releases land for building, consequential economic growth and rise in cost of labour = inflation so interst rates rise (I am looking forward to the screams of the property portfolio tossers)

"Interest rates in the EU are lower and the British public can have them tommorow so vote yes to the Euro or lose your home"

This has been the plan for years but its running behind due to the efforts of business which have outperformed even Browns predictions.

Oh yeah and an additional factor is frigging parents. Loads of plonkers having forced their kids to do posh and becks studies at the University of Stockport are now releasing equity from their own homes to ensure their kids have a bloody great millstone round their neck as well as totally unrealistic expectations with respect to their career in retail.

>> Edited by nonegreen on Friday 17th March 11:52

timmy30

Original Poster:

9,325 posts

258 months

Friday 17th March 2006
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]


Esecially if they don't actually undertstand the structure of the deal they have put together i.e

Essentially that have issued a floating rate bond securititised on a portfolio of income generating assets. The income from those assets will be used to pay down the original floating rate bond over time, and in the meantime they even hope to make a spread between their funding costs on the secured bond and their income from the assts ( the income being in effect determined by prevailing rate ). The sting would be any rise in the rates they have to pay on the bond, without a corresponding rise in income. I.e. a wideninng of the spread between the two rates. Capital wise, provided that they can service the IR sp ( or even profit from it ) ,I happily agree that there is no problem as whether the asset price rises or falls the asset income stream pays that off anyway, so whatever the residual value it's yours for free at the end of the period anyway.

Not saying it's a bad structure, and it comes with lots of embedded tax breaks thanks to HMT, but there are some risks, namely that IR spread, and the risk of having to liquidate the position early. And I'm not sure people fully appreciate them sometimes.

Davi

17,153 posts

251 months

Friday 17th March 2006
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]


Oh most definitely, I have a number of clients who are absolutely up to the hilt, having upped to the max LTV with F.A's every few months on portfolio's of 20,30 or more properties, yet an income insufficient so support a single bedsit in the Outer Hebrides.

Was just having a chat with my MD about this - he actually designs a great deal of the products on the BTL market today for the lenders, and his view is that although there is actually some reasonable merit to what the gent says in the orignal quote, it's several months out of date. Some of our larger more "knowledgable" clients were having similar thoughts mid last year, however nearly all now feel that there is sufficient prospective growth to no longer be overly concerned in the short to medium term.

Twincam16

27,647 posts

289 months

Friday 17th March 2006
quotequote all
Re. Lower-paid workers and BTLers.

I can see, potentially, an emergence in Britain of the dynamic that occurred in Germany in the '60s and '70s.

See, after the war there was a massive building boom in the West (obviously) to meet the demand for housing. Most of it was reasonably-priced, a lot of property tycoons made a quick buck in the late '40s and early '50s meeting these demands.

Then in the '60s and '70s, West Germany's post-war economy started to rocket. The baby-boomer population rose, and people started swarming into Germany, sometimes as gues workers, sometimes as investors, to get a slice of this new European economic pre-eminence.

Thing was, the property tycoons could barely keep up with demand. The individual tycoons were replaced with larger corporations who invested in massive public building strategies (which is why Germany is full of strangely attractive concrete edifices). However, this money had to come from somewhere. Result - house prices were (and for the most part still are) massive in Germany.

But the attitude of the people in Germany towards housing became very different. The average German rents a flat, and most of them are very agreeable indeed - they're not hovels by any means. They are smaller than the average British house, but in return, they're very well designed - open-plan, neatly packaged etc. Bringing up multiple children in one would be no trouble at all. But the key thing is this - renting is at a very reasonable rate and the legal situation is very secure.

What I can see happening in Britain are plucky individual BTLers being replaced by larger corporations with more capital readily available, who develop large groups of houses into relatively spacious open-plan flats (and, according to my Dad, converted office blocks are earmarked for this kind of treatment too - the average city has loads of them that have been for sale or to let for years).

Now, individually buying one of these in a city environment would probably be very expensive, but with a large corporation behind them, renting no longer seems like 'dead money' if you are, in return, getting somewhere really quite decent to live in that doesn't run the risk of the landlord suddenly going massively bankrupt and selling the place off.

The downside, of course, is that you'll never actually own it and as a result it won't be an asset as such, but the upside is that you won't be a slave to a mortgage so you'll have a little more disposable income (or money to put aside depending on how you see it), and when you do want to move, you can just transfer your belongings to a more suitable place, maybe in the suburbs, that is owned by a similar company and offers a similar rate of rent.

Thinking about the whole situation more, I think it's the British attitude towards house ownership in general that's causing half this problem. If you look at what the Germans, Dutch, Danish, Swedish, Polish - in fact most of Northern Europe - do, it would seem they've got the right idea regarding house ownership, and that is that long-term rental is not necessarily 'dead money', but it is in fact a fair substitute for some mortgages.

timmy30

Original Poster:

9,325 posts

258 months

Friday 17th March 2006
quotequote all
But Twincam German house prices haven't moved for a decade? It's the only West European/ Western country where they have actually declined. They're sooooo much cheaper than house prices in UK, FR, Italy.

minimax

11,985 posts

287 months

Friday 17th March 2006
quotequote all
tonyvid said:
I have always felt that property pricing is done by the wrong people - estate agents have a vested interest in high prices so they will always push the market. I know demand fuels prices but around my way(St Neots)prices are stupid, any "non-professional" doesn't stand a chance with even the smallest flat(actually my old first home)being over 90k. Someone who is say a factory worker or shop bod is stuffed. I do think we have a higher paid perspective on PH where 200k seems like a snip but some poor buggers are going to really struggle in a distorted market.


actually one of the offices in my firm has total market dominance in st neots (their words) and there is a big marketing push to talk up the housing market so they can list even more houses...they are selling them faster than they can list them (coincidentally the same as my own office)

timmy30

Original Poster:

9,325 posts

258 months

Friday 17th March 2006
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]




It is certainly a hosuing market that looks set to rise strongly, escpecially with the reforms on German mortgage lending coming this year.

minimax

11,985 posts

287 months

Friday 17th March 2006
quotequote all
morrisman said:
garyhun said:
B17NNS said:
I actually see prices continuing to rise.

The new homebuyers report means that people who advertise their property for sale will actually have to invest in the process (surveys etc).

This will reduce the amount of property on the market and remove the 'lets put it up for sale - if it sells great, if not, no problem'.

Less supply = higher prices.


Not sure I agree with your reasoning (I might though) BUT I definately agree with your comclusion that property will continue to rise.


Overheard in an Estate Agents:

Punter: I'd like to put an offer on this house
Agent: I wouldn't bother with an offer, just give the full amount to make sure you get it.
Punter: But we don't want to pay that much.
Agent: Well, you're really just wasting my time if you try to undercut the value of the 'home'!

Notice they are always 'homes' when somebody wants to sell them.



overheard in the office earlier was "we're getting so many houses going for best & final (sealed bids) that it's boring!"