Seven dead at Cheltenham Gold Cup
Discussion
www.newsandstar.co.uk/sport/viewarticle.aspx?id=343598
So horse racing - is it cruel?
News and Star said:
Probe as toll rises to seven
SEVEN horses have died so far in a “very regrettable” death toll at this year’s Cheltenham Festival, organisers have confirmed.
As racegoers today prepared for the highlight of the meeting – the world-famous Gold Cup – it emerged that five animals died yesterday, in the worst single tally at the Festival for some 20 years.
Two animals died in the first two days, while three horses – Millenaire, Basilea Star and Mr Babbage – all died in yesterday’s fifth race. The other two - Holy Orders in the third and Olaso in the last – broke bones in their legs, and were destroyed.
The course is to mount an investigation, and there will be post mortem examinations for all the animals, but animal rights group, Animal Aid, called for the public to withdraw support from the meeting.
So horse racing - is it cruel?
fozzi said:
Why do they feel the need to destroy horses when they break a leg?... Seems a bit extreme to me, you wouldn't do that to your dog!!
Because a break in a horses leg is very serious, they are on thier feet constantly and the breaks don't heal properly.
They are not always destroyed though.
fozzi said:
ali_kat said:Why not?... Please explain this, it really does baffle me.
Remember, most horses get put down for breaks in legs, they just can't mend them.....
The main reason is that is impossible to keep a horse restrained for the necessary period that is required for their leg to heal properly. There is no way to keep them still, and to stop them from further damaging the leg. If it's a minor break then it is sometimes possible, but generally there is no way that the leg will be able to heal, as it won't be rested properly.
Sam
vixpy1 said:
Nope.. Horse Racing is not cruel.
However, i would be examing the condition of the turf at cheltenham because its almost always a factor in these things.
I have to agree here. There are a number of facters here. However horses actually really enjoy the jumping. A friend of mine who trains 'point to point' horses had one die on the course only two weeks ago. It was very distressing for her; but we had to remind her it ccan go wrong! She should know as she is the trainer.
Must admit that I stopped going to the horse racing when one fell in front where I was watching - about 15 ft away. The sight of it standing shivvering with it's front leg bent and dangling is something I will never forget.
The course marshalls were very quick with trailer & screens, but even though we ran back to the car park, the sound of the shot could still be heard.
The course marshalls were very quick with trailer & screens, but even though we ran back to the car park, the sound of the shot could still be heard.
samwilliams said:Thanks for that.. appreciate the explanation.
fozzi said:The main reason is that is impossible to keep a horse restrained for the necessary period that is required for their leg to heal properly. There is no way to keep them still, and to stop them from further damaging the leg. If it's a minor break then it is sometimes possible, but generally there is no way that the leg will be able to heal, as it won't be rested properly.
ali_kat said:Why not?... Please explain this, it really does baffle me.
Remember, most horses get put down for breaks in legs, they just can't mend them.....
Sam
Horse racing is not cruel and those that say it is often don't know much about it.
These horses are bred to race, and love doing so... sure some can be tricky and look like they don't want to run when going away from the stands(Deenos Beeno comes to mind) but soon prick their ears again when they catch sight of the stands or stables...
Most horses also carry on running and jumping even when they've shipped their jockey, surely they'd say sod this and stand still if they hated it that much.
It's very sad, but sometimes it happens... and for the number that are in training a very small number are killed.
These horses are bred to race, and love doing so... sure some can be tricky and look like they don't want to run when going away from the stands(Deenos Beeno comes to mind) but soon prick their ears again when they catch sight of the stands or stables...
Most horses also carry on running and jumping even when they've shipped their jockey, surely they'd say sod this and stand still if they hated it that much.
It's very sad, but sometimes it happens... and for the number that are in training a very small number are killed.
Gassing Station | The Pie & Piston Archive | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



