Bluetooth Headsets for Handfree
Bluetooth Headsets for Handfree
Author
Discussion

goodlife

Original Poster:

1,852 posts

290 months

Friday 17th March 2006
quotequote all
My 6-year old Ericsson Bluetooth Headset has finally packed in so a new one is needed. What are considered the best ones on the market today in terms of battery life and sound quality? Looking online there seem to be 1000's of different models so (hopefully) it's PH to the rescue

NiceCupOfTea

25,608 posts

282 months

Friday 17th March 2006
quotequote all
I have a Motorola HS-850. It's pretty good. Decent standby time and the startup time is only a few secs. This means I have it switched off all the time, when the phone rings I flip it open and it's on in time to answer the call! Saves recharging it all the time.

Does get a bit confused when I end a call and make another straight away - may be my phone though (SPV). Didn't work as well with my SE P900 but I suspect that was the phone.

That's my only advice - find some reviews of the handsfree working with yout phone as they seem to varying levels of compatibility...

baskey

14,291 posts

257 months

Friday 17th March 2006
quotequote all
fugging hell, has blue tooth been available for that long?!

dealmaker

2,215 posts

285 months

Friday 17th March 2006
quotequote all

Fre@kin Bluetooth headsets are the bain of my life at the moment - why the hell aren't they all compatible with every phone!!! I thought it was a "STANDARD"?

I've got a Nokia 8800 phone at the moment and of the THREE headsets I own they ALL have one issue or another with the phone!

The Nokia HS4W simply WON'T connect to the phone (despite working fine with Sony Ericsson handsets???)

The Sony Ericcson HBH-300 won't auto connect when powered up - so you have to connect manually and it sometimes drops connection.

Tha Jabra BT800 I have connects well but doesnt seem to want to answer calls - I've lost loads of calls with it! GRRRRRR!

So my advice - try before you buy if you can becasue compatibility is a BIG issue.

I think I will try a Motorola headset (maybe the HS850 as recommended above?) next!!

nicecupoftea

25,608 posts

282 months

Friday 17th March 2006
quotequote all
I do like mine but it was awful with the SE P900. If you tried to answer the call by switching on the headset (rather than leaving it on standby) then without fail it would answer the call and drop it immediately! Rubbish!

Going with the same make isn't necessarily a guarantee either... I have also heard good things about the Jabra.

chris.mapey

4,778 posts

298 months

Friday 17th March 2006
quotequote all
dealmaker said:

Fre@kin Bluetooth headsets are the bain of my life at the moment - why the hell aren't they all compatible with every phone!!! I thought it was a "STANDARD"?

I've got a Nokia 8800 phone at the moment and of the THREE headsets I own they ALL have one issue or another with the phone!

The Nokia HS4W simply WON'T connect to the phone (despite working fine with Sony Ericsson handsets???)

The Sony Ericcson HBH-300 won't auto connect when powered up - so you have to connect manually and it sometimes drops connection.

Tha Jabra BT800 I have connects well but doesnt seem to want to answer calls - I've lost loads of calls with it! GRRRRRR!

So my advice - try before you buy if you can becasue compatibility is a BIG issue.

I think I will try a Motorola headset (maybe the HS850 as recommended above?) next!!


I hate to say it, but the fault is not the handsfree kits - its the phone.

Nokia are abysmal for not adhering to the bluetooth compatibility standards. Their idea is that it encourages you to buy their compatible bluetooth products each time you change your phone.

Vote with your feet & get shot of the Nokia...

Chris

goodlife

Original Poster:

1,852 posts

290 months

Friday 17th March 2006
quotequote all
baskey said:
fugging hell, has blue tooth been available for that long?!
I think so It's an old, old thing with a long arm and looks like one of the headsets that Lt Uhura wore in the original Star Trek! My phone is a BlackBerry, does that make a difference to the headset needed?

FortJefferson

8,237 posts

253 months

Friday 17th March 2006
quotequote all
I've got a Jabra 250 for my (Nokia 6210) it's great even though I trapped it in the glove box and broke the case when I first had it, I glued it together and it's still going strong after 2 years. It's the type that fits around the back of your ear and you can even get a crash helmet on. John

FourWheelDrift

92,402 posts

315 months

Friday 17th March 2006
quotequote all
Whenever I see someone permanently wearing a bluetooth headset in their ear I can't help but think it's a deaf-aid.

Please take them off if you aren't making or expecting to be taking calls, you look silly

FortJefferson

8,237 posts

253 months

Friday 17th March 2006
quotequote all
FourWheelDrift said:
Whenever I see someone permanently wearing a bluetooth headset in their ear I can't help but think it's a deaf-aid.

Please take them off if you aren't making or expecting to be taking calls, you look silly

I can't help thinking they look f**king stupid. I work with a guy that dose it and I'm allways taking the piss, telling him he looks like the Universal Soldier

jonesgm

265 posts

264 months

Friday 17th March 2006
quotequote all
Tried them all, headset are cr*p - caused me no end of grief, regardless of brand. Constantly failing to connect when the phone rings + high maintainance (always charging them up!)

gone for one of these www.mphone.co.uk/acatalog/visor-blade.html ...fantastic, liked them so much bought the staff one each(3) don't want to sound bigger than I am here.

other valid reason: You don't look like a real n*b when you forget to take it off when you pay for petrol!

Link also sell them

added to say www.mobileplace.co.uk/product/Visorblade_bluetooth_car_kit.html has a compatability list

>> Edited by jonesgm on Friday 17th March 23:09

nicecupoftea

25,608 posts

282 months

Friday 17th March 2006
quotequote all
Only "wear" mine when I'm actually on the phone - it lives on a lanyard round my neck. Standby is good on mine, but because of the quick startup time on mine it never needs to be in standby. Charge mine about every 2 weeks!! Always connects first time with my SPV.

jonesgm said:
Tried them all, headset are cr*p - caused me no end of grief, regardless of brand. Constantly failing to connect when the phone rings + high maintainance (always charging them up!)

gone for one of these www.mphone.co.uk/acatalog/visor-blade.html ...fantastic, liked them so much bought the staff one each(3) don't want to sound bigger than I am here.

other valid reason: You don't look like a real n*b when you forget to take it off when you pay for petrol!

Link also sell them

added to say www.mobileplace.co.uk/product/Visorblade_bluetooth_car_kit.html has a compatability list

>> Edited by jonesgm on Friday 17th March 23:09


I was looking at one of those the other day. Are they quite stealth? If it's hidden above the visor sounds good

jonesgm

265 posts

264 months

Friday 17th March 2006
quotequote all
nicecupoftea said:
I was looking at one of those the other day. Are they quite stealth? If it's hidden above the visor sounds good


It actually hangs upsidedown from the visor by a couple of magnets in the unit (you slide a metal clip onto your visor first), if you see the picture you then flip the mic down 45degs, which pairs to your phone - and away you go.

but you cannot see it from outside unless you crouch and look up.

I use a nokia 6310i works well, but a firmware upgrade on the phone now means i have to press the answer button to pair the phone to the visorblade - no sweat just one more press. the full duplex is fantastic - was very supprised, it like having a normal conversation on a phone, not fancy walkie talkies, where you cut off the other person if you speak over them. also voice recognition is a fab, you can say "home" in a happy voice, p*ssed off voice it still picks it up.

Not charged it up for a month, it goes into to a standby mode if you leave the car.

jonesgm

265 posts

264 months

Friday 17th March 2006
quotequote all
chris.mapey said:

Nokia are abysmal for not adhering to the bluetooth compatibility standards. Their idea is that it encourages you to buy their compatible bluetooth products each time you change your phone.

Chris


Spot on Chris, but I had trouble using there own brand of headset too, I have a drawer here at home full of sony, nokia, Jabra plantronic + all chargers all failed me

Gave the Jabra to my wizz kid at work "You get it working then" he said no problem... til I tried to ring him... yup if failed for him too, which is dangerouse in it's self cos you feel compelled to answer it, well i do anyway - need more self control.

Safety Engineer

107 posts

248 months

Saturday 18th March 2006
quotequote all

Had a Plantronics head set, worked well but bloody uncomfortable, have got a Jabra BT250 very comfy works well with my work phone (Nokia) and my phone (SEP910) good battery life, clear and crisp. Does what it says on the box.