Northern people who pronounce As 'Southern'
Northern people who pronounce As 'Southern'
Author
Discussion

baskey

Original Poster:

14,291 posts

257 months

Saturday 18th March 2006
quotequote all
i am originally from the north midlands/south north west if you see what i mean! I pronounce all the words that i know (!) correctly. but I pronounce A words in the northern way because i have a sort of vaguely w,cheshireish accent. e.g. bath is bath not barth or beth!

no i just want to know if it annoys anyone else when you hear someone with a northern accent using southern pronounciation.

it usually seems to be geordies in the media. i have noticed Anton Deck doing it a lot...

wedg1e

27,046 posts

296 months

Saturday 18th March 2006
quotequote all
You think that's bad? How about those savverners who put an R in NewcaRstle...

killer2005

20,650 posts

259 months

Saturday 18th March 2006
quotequote all
Wouldnt overly bother me. I'm born and brought up in Yorkshire, but with my mothers side of the family all being from south london/kent, and knowing a fair few people from the south east i do occasionally pick up some things from them.

Lois

14,706 posts

283 months

Saturday 18th March 2006
quotequote all
i've got a mashed up accent as it is. Northern people think I sound vaguely southern where as southerners think I'm strongly northern.

All my family are southerners and I was born darn sarf but been opp north for 17 years now.

Andy Mac

73,668 posts

286 months

Saturday 18th March 2006
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]

I'm messed up to. Been all over the place working with alsorts of people with all sorts of accents! Peeps from back home used to ask where i was from, which was about 5 miles away!

Matthew C

4,028 posts

268 months

Saturday 18th March 2006
quotequote all
I must have a strange mish mash despite having lived in the same area (house as well) all my life. A few times as school people asked me if I was a northerner and I've been asked at least once if I was from the west country.

baskey

Original Poster:

14,291 posts

257 months

Saturday 18th March 2006
quotequote all
killer2005 said:
Wouldnt overly bother me. I'm born and brought up in Yorkshire, but with my mothers side of the family all being from south london/kent, and knowing a fair few people from the south east i do occasionally pick up some things from them.


ah but do you generally sound like you have a whippet on a piece of string or do you have quite a bland nothingy accent that kind of swaps between north and south..?!

my missus' family are originally from gloucesterish way but they grew up in northants. but the missus went to uni in sarf and sisterinlawtobe went to uni in the north and now she sounds a bit northern and the missus sounds more southern - this is ok! it's we people cross 'the queens english' with eebygum - it sort of grates on me!


>> Edited by baskey on Saturday 18th March 22:33

killer2005

20,650 posts

259 months

Saturday 18th March 2006
quotequote all
baskey said:
killer2005 said:
Wouldnt overly bother me. I'm born and brought up in Yorkshire, but with my mothers side of the family all being from south london/kent, and knowing a fair few people from the south east i do occasionally pick up some things from them.


ah but do you generally sound like you have a whippet on a piece of string or do you have quite a bland nothingy accent that kind of swaps between north and south..?!



I'd say its a general west yorkshire accent, interspersed with bits of southerness

baskey

Original Poster:

14,291 posts

257 months

Saturday 18th March 2006
quotequote all


i think you'd be let off!

Lois

14,706 posts

283 months

Saturday 18th March 2006
quotequote all
[posh accent]I was actually having a discussion about accents whilst being chauffeured in a Lamborghini darling. Apparently your accent is set when you are 19. I guess that could be true of the major undertone but with slight variations occurring throughout life[/posh accent]

staceyb

7,107 posts

255 months

Saturday 18th March 2006
quotequote all
I'm just complete geordie people generally have a hard time understanding me on the phone an I hate the way I sound on my voicemail message it just doesn't sound like I sound to me if that makes sense.

baskey

Original Poster:

14,291 posts

257 months

Saturday 18th March 2006
quotequote all
staceyb said:
I'm just complete geordie people generally have a hard time understanding me on the phone an I hate the way I sound on my voicemail message it just doesn't sound like I sound to me if that makes sense.


woow geardie bird accent!

see that's how it should be - i think my issue is that it sounds so fake and like they are trying to fit in rather than being themselves.

as proof that people don't care i work with the sons an daughters of lords and stuff and they can tell how bright 9or not!) i am because of my vocabulary not because i try and out-posh them...!

Little Red

1,188 posts

260 months

Saturday 18th March 2006
quotequote all
I work with a Southerner who pronounces some things with a Kiwi Accent. No becomes 'Noy' Go becomes 'Goy'. They haven't explained why the do this, we assume it is just to 'an-noy' us.

staceyb

7,107 posts

255 months

Saturday 18th March 2006
quotequote all
baskey said:
staceyb said:
I'm just complete geordie people generally have a hard time understanding me on the phone an I hate the way I sound on my voicemail message it just doesn't sound like I sound to me if that makes sense.


woow geardie bird accent!

see that's how it should be - i think my issue is that it sounds so fake and like they are trying to fit in rather than being themselves.

as proof that people don't care i work with the sons an daughters of lords and stuff and they can tell how bright 9or not!) i am because of my vocabulary not because i try and out-posh them...!


Yeah I've been to meetings on site and I get the strangest looks, well apart from the ones I get from being a tiny blonde girl with a hard hat and hi-vis on, I open my mouth Geordie accent comes out and then all my ideas/opinions/whatever are just slaughtered and then I turn out to be right and its great

dilbert

7,741 posts

262 months

Saturday 18th March 2006
quotequote all
What you lot are describng as a southern accent isn't really. It's the generic, homogenous, Queens English.

A southern accent is not like the Queen's english at all. I'd say it's rarer than the northern accent myself. It's ten years since, sadly, one of the few people that I knew that spoke in a southern accent passed on.

I guess people still do exist, that speak that way, but don't blame it on us southerners.

Perhaps you should get down to the "Sunny South" and find out for yourselves!

staceyb

7,107 posts

255 months

Saturday 18th March 2006
quotequote all
dilbert said:
What you lot are describng as a southern accent isn't really. It's the generic, homogenous, Queens English.

A southern accent is not like the Queen's english at all. I'd say it's rarer than the northern accent myself. It's ten years since, sadly, one of the few people that I knew that spoke in a southern accent passed on.

I guess people still do exist, that speak that way, but don't blame it on us southerners.

Perhaps you should get down to the "Sunny South" and find out for yourselves!



I prefer northern accents have more character and are more phonetically correct then southern accents

dilbert

7,741 posts

262 months

Saturday 18th March 2006
quotequote all
staceyb said:
dilbert said:
What you lot are describng as a southern accent isn't really. It's the generic, homogenous, Queens English.

A southern accent is not like the Queen's english at all. I'd say it's rarer than the northern accent myself. It's ten years since, sadly, one of the few people that I knew that spoke in a southern accent passed on.

I guess people still do exist, that speak that way, but don't blame it on us southerners.

Perhaps you should get down to the "Sunny South" and find out for yourselves!


I prefer northern accents have more character and are more phonetically correct then southern accents

I think you're probably right. I think alot of that stems from the industrial revolution myself, the black country being the centre of much wealth. A genuine southern accent is understandable, but it's easier to understand a brummie!

I'm not talking about cokney either.

Edited to add;
I'll get my formatting right in a minute!

>> Edited by dilbert on Saturday 18th March 23:17

>> Edited by dilbert on Saturday 18th March 23:18

staceyb

7,107 posts

255 months

Saturday 18th March 2006
quotequote all
Birmingham isn't in the north or am I missing your point

dilbert

7,741 posts

262 months

Saturday 18th March 2006
quotequote all
staceyb said:
Birmingham isn't in the north or am I missing your point


I know I said Black country, but I also said industrial revolution!
I know where I shouldn't take my coals.

baskey

Original Poster:

14,291 posts

257 months

Saturday 18th March 2006
quotequote all
dilbert said:
What you lot are describng as a southern accent isn't really. It's the generic, homogenous, Queens English.

A southern accent is not like the Queen's english at all. I'd say it's rarer than the northern accent myself. It's ten years since, sadly, one of the few people that I knew that spoke in a southern accent passed on.

I guess people still do exist, that speak that way, but don't blame it on us southerners.

Perhaps you should get down to the "Sunny South" and find out for yourselves!



i live in hertforshire and work in t'west end! i wasn't blaming it on t'sutherners far from it it's weak northerners who seem to think that people will think they're 'better' by forcing something that isn't natural to them!

listen to anton deck next time they are on telly (you won't have to wait long..) and see what i mean..