Changes to British Summertime?
Discussion
www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/ld200506/ldbills/048/en/06048x--.htm
Whats the general consensus on this? From my rather ignorant point of view, it seems like a good idea to me.
Whats the general consensus on this? From my rather ignorant point of view, it seems like a good idea to me.
I can't understand why farming and fishing ever needed a different time to the rest of us, If I need to get up earlier to do something I don't stay in bed waiting for someone at Westminster to announce a daylight saving measure, I just get up and get on with it, why can't they do that?
The argument for school children is more robust.Children in the northern parts walk to school in the dark in in Winter with year round GMT+1. There's an obvious safety issue there as despite what some think a lot a children do still walk to school.
The road safety argument is bizarre. All sorts of figures get bandied around from time experiments carried out in decades ago when we changed the GMT/Summer time system before changing it back again. It's simple to prove. Just use the weeks accident figures for a fortnight either side of the change dates. If the accident figures drop when we change to Summer time and then rise again when Winter returns then the issue is proven. The marked reluctance to look at these figures, and persist in raking over decades old data from a time when driving patterns were very different, gives me an inkling that "road saety" might be a non argument and that it makes no difference at all!
Why not just split the difference and go for GMT+1/2 ?
The argument for school children is more robust.Children in the northern parts walk to school in the dark in in Winter with year round GMT+1. There's an obvious safety issue there as despite what some think a lot a children do still walk to school.
The road safety argument is bizarre. All sorts of figures get bandied around from time experiments carried out in decades ago when we changed the GMT/Summer time system before changing it back again. It's simple to prove. Just use the weeks accident figures for a fortnight either side of the change dates. If the accident figures drop when we change to Summer time and then rise again when Winter returns then the issue is proven. The marked reluctance to look at these figures, and persist in raking over decades old data from a time when driving patterns were very different, gives me an inkling that "road saety" might be a non argument and that it makes no difference at all!
Why not just split the difference and go for GMT+1/2 ?
I don't mind changing to GMT for winter. What bothers me is *how long* we leave the hour at GMT. We *could* change it back weeks earlier...
As to just leaving it on BST all year - sounds fine to me. There is a road safety issue with kids cycling home in the dark on the roads, though...
As to just leaving it on BST all year - sounds fine to me. There is a road safety issue with kids cycling home in the dark on the roads, though...
COMMENCEMENT AND EXPIRY DATE
In England, the Bill will come into force at two o'clock in the morning of 29th October 2006.
In Wales, the Bill will come into force on such day as the National Assembly for Wales decides; and it may decide not to commence the Bill at all.
In Scotland, the Bill will come into force on such day as the Scottish Parliament decides; and it may decide not to commence the Bill at all.
In Northern Ireland, if the Northern Ireland Assembly is not suspended the Bill will come into force on such day as the Assembly decides; and it may decide not to commence the Bill at all. If the Assembly is suspended, the Secretary of State will decide when the Bill comes into force; and he may decide not to commence the Bill at all.
If the Bill is not brought into force in any of Wales, Scotland or Northern Ireland, the time in that territory will remain as it is at present.
The Bill will expire at two o'clock in the morning of 25th October 2009. After that the time in the United Kingdom will return to the present time.
In England, the Bill will come into force at two o'clock in the morning of 29th October 2006.
In Wales, the Bill will come into force on such day as the National Assembly for Wales decides; and it may decide not to commence the Bill at all.
In Scotland, the Bill will come into force on such day as the Scottish Parliament decides; and it may decide not to commence the Bill at all.
In Northern Ireland, if the Northern Ireland Assembly is not suspended the Bill will come into force on such day as the Assembly decides; and it may decide not to commence the Bill at all. If the Assembly is suspended, the Secretary of State will decide when the Bill comes into force; and he may decide not to commence the Bill at all.
If the Bill is not brought into force in any of Wales, Scotland or Northern Ireland, the time in that territory will remain as it is at present.
The Bill will expire at two o'clock in the morning of 25th October 2009. After that the time in the United Kingdom will return to the present time.
Don said:
I don't mind changing to GMT for winter. What bothers me is *how long* we leave the hour at GMT. We *could* change it back weeks earlier...
As to just leaving it on BST all year - sounds fine to me. There is a road safety issue with kids cycling home in the dark on the roads, though...
Thats what lights were invented for
Don said:
As to just leaving it on BST all year - sounds fine to me. There is a road safety issue with kids cycling home in the dark on the roads, though...
At the mo the clocks are skewed to benefit kids going to school in light (apropos farmers who nobody cares for anymore). The bullshit part is that kids mostly get KSId on the way home in the dark when they are all released together and push each other off the pavement/do other really stupid shit.
+1 for me please.
Think of the kids! and I like my evenings light too
How many MORE times are they going to propose this sort of thing? *yawn*
This is what we need http://zapatopi.net/metrictime/ (or not) or go back pre-railway local time
>> Edited by scared but happy on Monday 20th March 16:41
This is what we need http://zapatopi.net/metrictime/ (or not) or go back pre-railway local time >> Edited by scared but happy on Monday 20th March 16:41
This is old hat. Anyone who isn't a recent arrival on Planet Earth will know that CET (Central European Time) was tried by Wilson or maybe Callaghan way back in the Good Old Days and abandoned as unpopular. Nothing is going to change the fact that we are in the north of the northern hemisphere and daylight is longer by far in summer than in winter. You can pretend otherwise by messing with the clocks but it is still a fact. Daft I call it. 

This gets debated every year, in winter with GMT it doesn't get light until 7:30 and it gets dark at about 4:20, so you get to go to work in the daylight but it's dark on the way home. Roll that an hour forward and it's dark whilst you go to work and it's still dark on the way home. Given the numbers of folks who get SAD I think that we should leave it as is. Perhaps they could introduce BST earlier in the year but no more.
Yeah kids walk home in the dark during GMT but without it they'd be walking to school in the dark so why is one better?
Matthew
Yeah kids walk home in the dark during GMT but without it they'd be walking to school in the dark so why is one better?
Matthew
Gassing Station | The Pie & Piston Archive | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



