Death Sentence for Converting to Christianity
Death Sentence for Converting to Christianity
Author
Discussion

jimbeaux

Original Poster:

33,791 posts

262 months

Tuesday 21st March 2006
quotequote all
I hope this is not really in line with the Islamic religion:

http://abcnews.go.com/WNT/story?id=17

Eric Mc

125,972 posts

296 months

Tuesday 21st March 2006
quotequote all
Is there only one "form" of Islamic Religion?

I don't think so.

Just like Christianity, it comes in quite a few hues and shades, some very tolerant and some very extremist.

>> Edited by Eric Mc on Tuesday 21st March 18:38

Rob_F

4,155 posts

295 months

Tuesday 21st March 2006
quotequote all
They take this whole imaginary friend thing quite seriously don't they?

Nutters.

Cheers,
Rob.

minimax

11,985 posts

287 months

Tuesday 21st March 2006
quotequote all
Rob_F said:
They take this whole imaginary friend thing quite seriously don't they?

Nutters.

Cheers,
Rob.






jimbeaux

Original Poster:

33,791 posts

262 months

Tuesday 21st March 2006
quotequote all
The irony here is priceless!!!(from the ABC News article)

"We will ask him if he has changed his mind about being a Christian," Mawlazezadah says. "If he has, we will forgive him, because Islam is a religion of tolerance."

"We want to know that the doctors have given him a green light on his mental state, because he is not normal when he talks," says the judge.

And the apparent norm:

"Muslim converts to Christianity have been prosecuted in other countries ruled by Islamic law. Since 1996, high-profile apostasy cases have put Christian converts on the stand in countries that include Iran, Kuwait, Saudi Arabia and the Sudan. The legal scholar, who asks to remain anonymous given the sensitivity of the topic, says, "It's a fundamental tenet under Islam that conversion to another religion is a heinous act. It has a touch of treason … there's an aspect to it of betrayal against the communal identity."







>> Edited by jimbeaux on Tuesday 21st March 19:01

nel

4,830 posts

272 months

Tuesday 21st March 2006
quotequote all
This is their version of the Spanish inquisition. Hey, be positive guys, it shows they've reached middle ages....

jimbeaux

Original Poster:

33,791 posts

262 months

Tuesday 21st March 2006
quotequote all
nel said:
This is their version of the Spanish inquisition. Hey, be positive guys, it shows they've reached middle ages....


It's all peaches and cream from here on out!

nel

4,830 posts

272 months

Tuesday 21st March 2006
quotequote all
jimbeaux said:
nel said:
This is their version of the Spanish inquisition. Hey, be positive guys, it shows they've reached middle ages....


It's all peaches and cream from here on out!


Easy mate, I was half joking...


Edited to add, "No one expects THE SPANISH INQUISITION...honheehon!"

>> Edited by nel on Tuesday 21st March 19:06

jimbeaux

Original Poster:

33,791 posts

262 months

Tuesday 21st March 2006
quotequote all
nel said:
jimbeaux said:
nel said:
This is their version of the Spanish inquisition. Hey, be positive guys, it shows they've reached middle ages....


It's all peaches and cream from here on out!


Easy mate, I was half joking...


Edited to add, "No one expects THE SPANISH INQUISITION...honheehon!"

>> Edited by nel on Tuesday 21st March 19:06


And I was being full-on sarcastic

Lion-O

242 posts

259 months

Tuesday 21st March 2006
quotequote all
Eric Mc said:
Is there only one "form" of Islamic Religion?

I don't think so.

Just like Christianity, it comes in quite a few hues and shades, some very tolerant and some very extremist.

>> Edited by Eric Mc on Tuesday 21st March 18:38


I might stick a small dispeptic toe into this sea of tolerance. I would argue that moderation in religion largely comes from scriptural ignorance. The Koran makes it pretty clear that you should make war on the unbelievers, as does the Bible which in Deuteronomy advocates the killing of your brother, spouse, neighbour or child should they embrace another religion.

The hues and shades come in when secular knowledge clashes with scriptural law. One can only be a moderate if one decides to play pick and mix seeing the parts of the holy book we like as the pure unadulterated word of god and the others as something to be ignored, if we have studied them at all.

Trying to persuade an extremist that the Koran or the Bible preaches tolerance has proven exceptionally difficult because in general their knowledge of scripture is far superior to moderates and their position is unarguably closer to the scriptural intent.

Are there different forms of Islam? Just as with Christianity, not when it really counts.

jimbeaux

Original Poster:

33,791 posts

262 months

Tuesday 21st March 2006
quotequote all
Lion-O said:
Eric Mc said:
Is there only one "form" of Islamic Religion?

I don't think so.

Just like Christianity, it comes in quite a few hues and shades, some very tolerant and some very extremist.

>> Edited by Eric Mc on Tuesday 21st March 18:38


I might stick a small dispeptic toe into this sea of tolerance. I would argue that moderation in religion largely comes from scriptural ignorance. The Koran makes it pretty clear that you should make war on the unbelievers, as does the Bible which in Deuteronomy advocates the killing of your brother, spouse, neighbour or child should they embrace another religion.

The hues and shades come in when secular knowledge clashes with scriptural law. One can only be a moderate if one decides to play pick and mix seeing the parts of the holy book we like as the pure unadulterated word of god and the others as something to be ignored, if we have studied them at all.

Trying to persuade an extremist that the Koran or the Bible preaches tolerance has proven exceptionally difficult because in general their knowledge of scripture is far superior to moderates and their position is unarguably closer to the scriptural intent.

Are there different forms of Islam? Just as with Christianity, not when it really counts.


The Christian "Extreme" has nothing on their Islam counterpart.

nwtony

3,011 posts

259 months

Tuesday 21st March 2006
quotequote all
In fairness you can see a passing resemblance with right wing christian fundementalists blowing up abortion clinics and killing doctors....

Nutters the lot of 'em. The only good thing is that no matter what, most of them are going to be wrong about their choice of god (should the imaginary friend exist) and be screwed for all eternity in the afterlife.(should it exist, which it wont).

Eric Mc

125,972 posts

296 months

Tuesday 21st March 2006
quotequote all
Is not the New Testament the foundation of Christianity rather than the Old, with Jesus' teachings as the true cornerstone. From what I've heard, Jesus was pretty tolerant and never advocated killing. In fact, he encouraged us to LOVE our enemies.

I agree that Islam is going through it's "Middle Ages" period. However, if you look carefully at history, you wull see that the Spanish Inquisition is actually from the period of the Renaissance, not the Middle Ages, and was an attempt by the Catholic Church to hang on to influential individuals who were defecting to the new more "emlightened" forms of Christianity which had just started up all over Europe.

>> Edited by Eric Mc on Tuesday 21st March 19:49

tinman0

18,231 posts

271 months

Tuesday 21st March 2006
quotequote all
nwtony said:
In fairness you can see a passing resemblance with right wing christian fundementalists blowing up abortion clinics and killing doctors....


not really because the Bible tells it followers to accept the law of the land.

whereas these death sentences have been translated into the law of the land.

also, the Old Testament isn't the whole Bible. The New Testament brings a bit of reality to the whole proceedings. The Koran though is based on the Old Testament and has no real calming influence.

Eric Mc

125,972 posts

296 months

Tuesday 21st March 2006
quotequote all
I "never expected" that response.

morrisman

264 posts

249 months

Tuesday 21st March 2006
quotequote all
jimbeaux said:
I hope this is not really in line with the Islamic religion:

http://abcnews.go.com/WNT/story?id=17


Can't quite understand why anybody has to 'convert' to anything. What, exacly, is wrong with just being a normal human being and believing in yourself??

Lion-O

242 posts

259 months

Tuesday 21st March 2006
quotequote all
Eric Mc said:
Is not the New Testament the foundation of Christianity rather than the Old, with Jesus' teachings as the true cornerstone. From what I've heard, Jesus was pretty tolerant and never advocated killing. In fact, he encouraged us to LOVE our enemies.

I agree that Islam is going through it's "Middle Ages" period. However, if you look carefully at history, you wull see that the Spanish Inquisition is actually from the period of the Renaissance, not the Middle Ages, and was an attempt by the Catholic Church to hang on to influential individuals who were defecting to the new more "emlightened" forms of Chririanity which had just started up all over Europe.


The trouble is that while the New testament is seen as more important, both testaments are still seen as the literal word of god. The bible is clear that anyone suggesting it is anything other than this should be killed.

The other problem is that while we say the New testament is the more important one, it is also the most ignored in practice. Jesus was basically a socialist peacenik. How can the religious right's hatred of big government, high taxes and wealth redistribution have any link to the man who advocated giving up ALL your possessions and redistributing them to the poor. How would their love of a strong judiciary and prison system, as well as an agressive foreign policy have fitted with Jesus' dictum to always turn the other cheek.

Jesus may well have encouraged us to love our enemies but Christianity almost never has, while pretending to follow them, Jesus's teachings have been sytematically ignored when they don't fit with the exingencies of real life.

Jimbeaux is right that Christianity doesn't seem to be as extreme as Islam at present, but that is largely because of two points.

1) Christianity has largely been the dominant religion in cultures that have a Graeco-Roman philosophical heritage. It is these values that have won out and formed our society to a far greater extent that Christianity. The bible's teaching have often been ignored when they conflict with the Enlightenment values that we practise today. Chritianity as such is in a slightly weaker position than the more theocratic states of Islam.

2) Christians can look at the coutries they inhabit and see that they effectively rule the world. Muslims look at their countries and see corrupt states that rule little. There is no real reason for Christians to disrupt the status quo as it largely benefits them and they are in a position of influence. If the tables were turned and Islam was the dominant force in the world I have no doubt that we would see Christianities more militant side coming through.

morrisman

264 posts

249 months

Tuesday 21st March 2006
quotequote all
Lion-O said:
Eric Mc said:
Is not the New Testament the foundation of Christianity rather than the Old, with Jesus' teachings as the true cornerstone. From what I've heard, Jesus was pretty tolerant and never advocated killing. In fact, he encouraged us to LOVE our enemies.

I agree that Islam is going through it's "Middle Ages" period. However, if you look carefully at history, you wull see that the Spanish Inquisition is actually from the period of the Renaissance, not the Middle Ages, and was an attempt by the Catholic Church to hang on to influential individuals who were defecting to the new more "emlightened" forms of Chririanity which had just started up all over Europe.


The trouble is that while the New testament is seen as more important, both testaments are still seen as the literal word of god. The bible is clear that anyone suggesting it is anything other than this should be killed.

The other problem is that while we say the New testament is the more important one, it is also the most ignored in practice. Jesus was basically a socialist peacenik. How can the religious right's hatred of big government, high taxes and wealth redistribution have any link to the man who advocated giving up ALL your possessions and redistributing them to the poor. How would their love of a strong judiciary and prison system, as well as an agressive foreign policy have fitted with Jesus' dictum to always turn the other cheek.

Jesus may well have encouraged us to love our enemies but Christianity almost never has, while pretending to follow them, Jesus's teachings have been sytematically ignored when they don't fit with the exingencies of real life.

Jimbeaux is right that Christianity doesn't seem to be as extreme as Islam at present, but that is largely because of two points.

1) Christianity has largely been the dominant religion in cultures that have a Graeco-Roman philosophical heritage. It is these values that have won out and formed our society to a far greater extent that Christianity. The bible's teaching have often been ignored when they conflict with the Enlightenment values that we practise today. Chritianity as such is in a slightly weaker position than the more theocratic states of Islam.

2) Christians can look at the coutries they inhabit and see that they effectively rule the world. Muslims look at their countries and see corrupt states that rule little. There is no real reason for Christians to disrupt the status quo as it largely benefits them and they are in a position of influence. If the tables were turned and Islam was the dominant force in the world I have no doubt that we would see Christianities more militant side coming through.


Just glance quickly at the quantity of people who have died painfuly in the name of christianity over the millenia and you will realise that islam has a hell of a lot more going for it than the average member of the Christian Buggerers would have you believe.

Hence the reason it is the fastest growing religion in the world.

jimbeaux

Original Poster:

33,791 posts

262 months

Tuesday 21st March 2006
quotequote all
Eric Mc said:
Is not the New Testament the foundation of Christianity rather than the Old, with Jesus' teachings as the true cornerstone. From what I've heard, Jesus was pretty tolerant and never advocated killing. In fact, he encouraged us to LOVE our enemies.

I agree that Islam is going through it's "Middle Ages" period. However, if you look carefully at history, you wull see that the Spanish Inquisition is actually from the period of the Renaissance, not the Middle Ages, and was an attempt by the Catholic Church to hang on to influential individuals who were defecting to the new more "emlightened" forms of Christianity which had just started up all over Europe.

>> Edited by Eric Mc on Tuesday 21st March 19:49


That is all true Eric; however, you are just not fitting neatly into the PC world by spouting facts and shit.....do come along sir

Eric Mc

125,972 posts

296 months

Tuesday 21st March 2006
quotequote all
Many Christians will argue that the Old Testament is NOT the literal word of God.

As always, religion itself is hardly ever the core problem, it is people and how they chose to interpret what are often quite vague "instructions" for living. These differences have led to serious trouble within single religions. Chritianity has been riddled with factional hatred for hundreds of years. And Islam is as bad - look at the way Sunni, Shi'as and other Islamic codes turn on each other. If you ask the average Sunni or Shi'a Muslim why they are different, most wouldn't be able to tell you.