Remember the plane on a conveyor...?
Remember the plane on a conveyor...?
Author
Discussion

wedg1e

Original Poster:

27,046 posts

296 months

Thursday 23rd March 2006
quotequote all
Well I was thinking, as I lounged against the rail on the Stena Explorer this afternoon (and a millpond so it was too, the Irish Sea)...
Hypothetically, if you had a ship of adequate mass, infinite power and a massive propellor, and you could make it stay stationary relative to the earth's rotational axis, would it be feasible to make the earth spin faster when you nailed the engines?

8Pack

5,182 posts

271 months

Thursday 23rd March 2006
quotequote all
Oh! No! NO! NO!No! No! No! no! no! no! no! no!no! no! no! no!........

planetdave

9,922 posts

284 months

Thursday 23rd March 2006
quotequote all
Not if they used the TVR dyno

Zad

13,024 posts

267 months

Thursday 23rd March 2006
quotequote all
No. The props would displace most of the water sideways rather than away from the craft, and would not be replaced sufficiently quickly, thus generating a really bad case of cavitation: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cavitati



up-the-dubs

4,282 posts

260 months

Thursday 23rd March 2006
quotequote all
Zad said:
No. The props would displace most of the water sideways rather than away from the craft, and would not be replaced sufficiently quickly, thus generating a really bad case of cavitation: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cavitati





Too tired to read that, but I'll post so I'll see it tomorrow afternoon. Looks interesting. One of those "I've always wondered..." topics. Cheers .

8Pack

5,182 posts

271 months

Thursday 23rd March 2006
quotequote all
"Maybe the ship going the other way would cancel it out!"....

GreenV8S

31,027 posts

315 months

Thursday 23rd March 2006
quotequote all
Yes, but since you're going to need an external force to keep the ship still you'd probably end up shifting the earth's orbit too so you wouldn't be very popular. Maybe you could get all the Chinese to jump at the same time to shift it back?

wedg1e

Original Poster:

27,046 posts

296 months

Thursday 23rd March 2006
quotequote all
Zad said:
No. The props would displace most of the water sideways rather than away from the craft, and would not be replaced sufficiently quickly, thus generating a really bad case of cavitation: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cavitati





Well OK FFS, use those propulsion modules that can swivel 360 degrees... god's teeth, do I have to think of everything?

glocko

1,813 posts

280 months

Thursday 23rd March 2006
quotequote all
On the same principle...

if you got everyone in the world facing the same direction, and got them to start jogging in a mass london marathon stylee??
No sideways deflection, all force to the rear of the feet.
Sort of an outside hamster wheel or those circus guys who run on the spot atop a big ball??
With good co-ordination you could dictate the seasons anywhere in the world? Sling a bit of rain over to Africa and we'll have a long long summer here!!!

just off to have a word with myself as to why the hell I replied to this thread!!

Mr Whippy

32,453 posts

272 months

Thursday 23rd March 2006
quotequote all
glocko said:
On the same principle...

if you got everyone in the world facing the same direction, and got them to start jogging in a mass london marathon stylee??
No sideways deflection, all force to the rear of the feet.
Sort of an outside hamster wheel or those circus guys who run on the spot atop a big ball??
With good co-ordination you could dictate the seasons anywhere in the world? Sling a bit of rain over to Africa and we'll have a long long summer here!!!

just off to have a word with myself as to why the hell I replied to this thread!!


Even better do it with cars. Line them up all facing east and then accelerate hard, while coasting back to a stop, and rinse and repeat!

Shorter days

Dave

xjsjohn

16,152 posts

250 months

Thursday 23rd March 2006
quotequote all
glocko said:
On the same principle...

if you got everyone in the world facing the same direction, and got them to start jogging in a mass london marathon stylee??
No sideways deflection, all force to the rear of the feet.
Sort of an outside hamster wheel or those circus guys who run on the spot atop a big ball??
With good co-ordination you could dictate the seasons anywhere in the world? Sling a bit of rain over to Africa and we'll have a long long summer here!!!

just off to have a word with myself as to why the hell I replied to this thread!!


All have a curry then arse to the east .......


i'll just get my coat .....

mini_ralf

9,282 posts

248 months

Thursday 23rd March 2006
quotequote all
Would need some bloody big props to displace enough water to get the the earth moving...

Conversley...... What would happen if you tried it in same direction as the earths spin?... Would we speed up? Would the days become shorter?

GreenV8S

31,027 posts

315 months

Thursday 23rd March 2006
quotequote all
glocko said:
if you got everyone in the world facing the same direction, and got them to start jogging in a mass london marathon stylee??


Anyone got time to calculate the mass of the people, inertia of the earth, if the entire population stood on the equator and started running round it, how much difference would that make to the length of a day?

mini_ralf

9,282 posts

248 months

Thursday 23rd March 2006
quotequote all
Ok.. Just did a Google. The earth travels at 1038mph at the equator.. That'll need to be some boat to be able to put up with those kind of speeds through water. Also there is the little factor that water is roughly a million times more dense than air.

Could be a difficult one to solve and engineer. Anyone know any Bugatti engineers?

gasblaster

27,598 posts

310 months

Thursday 23rd March 2006
quotequote all
GreenV8S said:
glocko said:
if you got everyone in the world facing the same direction, and got them to start jogging in a mass london marathon stylee??


Anyone got time to calculate the mass of the people, inertia of the earth, if the entire population stood on the equator and started running round it, how much difference would that make to the length of a day?


population is 6.5 billion, assume average mass 60 kg = 390 billion kg of mass.

well it's a start

mini_ralf

9,282 posts

248 months

Thursday 23rd March 2006
quotequote all
GreenV8S said:
glocko said:
if you got everyone in the world facing the same direction, and got them to start jogging in a mass london marathon stylee??


Anyone got time to calculate the mass of the people, inertia of the earth, if the entire population stood on the equator and started running round it, how much difference would that make to the length of a day?


As the earth weighs about 6x10 24th power Kgs I can't imagine that a few billion people at an average weight of say 80kg would make a significant difference..

mini_ralf

9,282 posts

248 months

Thursday 23rd March 2006
quotequote all
Damn.... I went with 80kg to allow for the Americans.

morrisman

264 posts

249 months

Thursday 23rd March 2006
quotequote all
Zad said:
No. The props would displace most of the water sideways rather than away from the craft, and would not be replaced sufficiently quickly, thus generating a really bad case of cavitation: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cavitati





No. Ships don't move 'most of the water sideways' so why should the mythical ship of infinite proportions do so?

If the ship were suitably massive it WOULD make an effect on the earths rotation. Equal an opposite etc. Just like when you stand on a log in a river and roll it with your feet (for that two tenths of a second before you get wet)

mindgam3

740 posts

267 months

Thursday 23rd March 2006
quotequote all
wedg1e said:
Well I was thinking, as I lounged against the rail on the Stena Explorer this afternoon (and a millpond so it was too, the Irish Sea)...
Hypothetically, if you had a ship of adequate mass, infinite power and a massive propellor, and you could make it stay stationary relative to the earth's rotational axis, would it be feasible to make the earth spin faster when you nailed the engines?


Yes, but it would have to be HUGE!

Same principle as having infinite amount of power in a car engine, and huge tires that were so sticky they had infinte amount of grip.

Having said that you'd probably need about 10 times what you think.

9/10 of your efforts would go into moving the earths plates and causing huge earthquakes.... then the earth would begin to move a bit faster

mini_ralf

9,282 posts

248 months

Thursday 23rd March 2006
quotequote all
mindgam3 said:
wedg1e said:
Well I was thinking, as I lounged against the rail on the Stena Explorer this afternoon (and a millpond so it was too, the Irish Sea)...
Hypothetically, if you had a ship of adequate mass, infinite power and a massive propellor, and you could make it stay stationary relative to the earth's rotational axis, would it be feasible to make the earth spin faster when you nailed the engines?


Yes, but it would have to be HUGE!

Same principle as having infinite amount of power in a car engine, and huge tires that were so sticky they had infinte amount of grip.

Having said that you'd probably need about 10 times what you think.

9/10 of your efforts would go into moving the earths plates and causing huge earthquakes.... then the earth would begin to move a bit faster


Probably fall apart in the process.