Health insurance, how much?
Health insurance, how much?
Author
Discussion

GreenV8S

Original Poster:

31,027 posts

315 months

Friday 24th March 2006
quotequote all
My mortgage consultant is advising me that I need health insurance. The deal is that if I'm incapacitated and unable to work, the health insurance will provide me with an income. Which seems fair enough.

The problem is the amount. I'm being advised to pay 10% of my mortgage to buy enough cover to pay 150% of the mortgage for the duration of the mortgage i.e. enough to keep the house over my head practically forever plus a small amount to live on.

This seems like a heck of a lot of money to insure against something that seems extremely unlikely i.e. me being too sick to work for the rest of my life.

The consultant is saying this is normal and sensible, but of course he is working on a commission and doesn't necessarily have my best interests in mind.

I'm not asking for advice about what I should do, but I'm interested to know whether this amount of insurance is really considered normal?

JR

14,332 posts

289 months

Friday 24th March 2006
quotequote all
Critical health insurance. I didn't bother as I thought that I was reasonably covered anyway. If you are considering this I would say use a separate adviser and more importantly what cover do you have from your existing policies? These schemes quite often subtract your existing policy/work place scheme payments from what they would pay you so may not be as generous as they seem. In short read the small print but I know that you're thorough anyway. Good luck, Jonathan

themaskedavenger

676 posts

279 months

Friday 24th March 2006
quotequote all
Most critical health cover policies that I have seen rule out more things than they cover.

If you work see what you get from your company many have some kind of policy in place.

minimax

11,985 posts

287 months

Friday 24th March 2006
quotequote all
GreenV8S said:
My mortgage consultant is advising me that I need health insurance. The deal is that if I'm incapacitated and unable to work, the health insurance will provide me with an income. Which seems fair enough.

The problem is the amount. I'm being advised to pay 10% of my mortgage to buy enough cover to pay 150% of the mortgage for the duration of the mortgage i.e. enough to keep the house over my head practically forever plus a small amount to live on.

This seems like a heck of a lot of money to insure against something that seems extremely unlikely i.e. me being too sick to work for the rest of my life.

The consultant is saying this is normal and sensible, but of course he is working on a commission and doesn't necessarily have my best interests in mind.

I'm not asking for advice about what I should do, but I'm interested to know whether this amount of insurance is really considered normal?




right, this is right up my street

there are many different ways to protect your ability to maintain your mortgage repayments, the usual ways are ASU and MPI, what you describe is MPI - it is usually taken out as a monthly payment plan that guarantees you up to 150% of your mortgage repayment (the idea is if you're completely up a certain creek without a certain instrument that you can pay your mortgage and the extra covers your bills).

it's payable as monthly non investment backed premium (it has no cash in value) and it guarantees you a payment subject to confirmation generally on diagnosis of 3 or more Functionality Assessment Tests (FATS) of a payment indexed at up to 10% per annum for the term of the mortgage/until you recover/until the mortgage term ends/until you reach age 65.

I would usually find it appropriate to recommend if you have large liabilities, you are in a dangerous job, you are self employed (sole trader or partnership usually), or you are sole bread winner.

It is by no means an appropriate policy for everyone and I suppose that I provide it in a recommendation perhaps only a few times a month.

bear in mind that the broker must prove not just your need but also the affordability, it must be documented in the statement of demands & needs that he is obliged to produce and give to you.

HTH

smirnoff

611 posts

281 months

Friday 24th March 2006
quotequote all
Where's minimax, don't tell me he's working!

Anyway.

There are 3 different types of cover, Income protection, critical illness and accident and sickness cover

They all do different things

Income protection covers long term sickness usually kicks in when your employer stops paying sick pay and can run to retirement or the end of the mortgage which ever you choose

Critical Illness cover is life insurance which pays out either a lump sum or monthly benefit on diagnosis of a "Critical Illness" it depends on the insurer what illnesses are covered.

Accident and Sickness (and Unemployment) only covers you for 1 or 2 years, and is the most expensive per pound covered, many companies try and sell block ASU which means you pay the whole lot up front and add it to the loan. Big commissions and usually very expensive.

If you would like to know what would best suit you email me though my profile.

Adrian

Ah minimax has beaten me to it!

well done thought you were slipping


>> Edited by smirnoff on Friday 24th March 13:32

minimax

11,985 posts

287 months

Friday 24th March 2006
quotequote all
JR said:
Critical health insurance.


that's a different thing...

JR said:

I didn't bother as I thought that I was reasonably covered anyway. If you are considering this I would say use a separate adviser


why use a separate adviser? no need really unless you don't like/don't trust the original adviser..

JR said:

and more importantly what cover do you have from your existing policies?


the policies that the FSA require the broker to consider for you are designed to pay off your mortgage/deal with associated issues. cover you get from your employer is designed to provide a nest egg for your family

JR said:

These schemes quite often subtract your existing policy/work place scheme payments from what they would pay you so may not be as generous as they seem. In short read the small print but I know that you're thorough anyway. Good luck, Jonathan


the schemes have to restrict payments from any scheme you have if you already have employees cover in place like for instance sick pay - they do this because they have to the policies cannot provide you with more than government stipulated levels - this is designed to stop people loading up with insurance and then the payments being so attractive that they are encouraged into not coming back to work even though they may be able to

the broker is obliged to take in to account any existing cover you may have and would be negligent if they provided you with cover that was not able to pay out fully (if you claimed) due to any other cover you may have had previously in place



>> Edited by minimax on Friday 24th March 13:36

B17NNS

18,506 posts

278 months

Friday 24th March 2006
quotequote all
I would take the advice but wouldnt give them the money.

Put the amount of the proposed premium in a high interest regular savings account (I think Barclays do 10%).

If your ill you can use it, if not you havent lost.

This does of course rely on you understanding that this money is to be used only under these specific circumstances and not TVR's etc.

minimax

11,985 posts

287 months

Friday 24th March 2006
quotequote all
B17NNS said:
I would take the advice but wouldnt give them the money.

Put the amount of the proposed premium in a high interest regular savings account (I think Barclays do 10%).

If your ill you can use it, if not you havent lost.

This does of course rely on you understanding that this money is to be used only under these specific circumstances and not TVR's etc.



well...that's a calculated risk - same as insurance really

of course, if he does do that (say premium of £80 per month) for 5 years (£4,800 plus accrued interest) and then has an accident that prevents him from completing gainful employment (I don't mean starts a job in the civil service I mean bedridden ) and his mortgage is £800 per month then that nest egg won't last long..

Philbes

4,908 posts

265 months

Friday 24th March 2006
quotequote all
Minimax - "recommend for the self-employed"

The policies I have seen state that for a self-employed person to claim they or their company must be bankrupt/in liquidation.

JR

14,332 posts

289 months

Friday 24th March 2006
quotequote all
minimax said:
why use a separate adviser? no need really unless you don't like/don't trust the original adviser..

I think that you've answered that yourself. Thanks for the clarification on the other stuff. At least I seemed to be of some use in bumping it to the top.

minimax

11,985 posts

287 months

Friday 24th March 2006
quotequote all
Philbes said:
Minimax - "recommend for the self-employed"

The policies I have seen state that for a self-employed person to claim they or their company must be bankrupt/in liquidation.



depends..

some have that qualification statement, others don't!

ASU (Accident, Sickness, Unemployment) is particularly unsuitable for the self employed as it's not underwritten up front and frankly I have a slight distrust for policies that are not underwritten up front

really, if you're self employed on a sole trader or partnership basis then income/mortgage protection may be appropriate, if you own a company with employees then i'd think very carefully about whether it would be appropriate..

the unemployment part for self employed persons is usually very difficult to pay out on

minimax

11,985 posts

287 months

Friday 24th March 2006
quotequote all
JR said:
minimax said:
why use a separate adviser? no need really unless you don't like/don't trust the original adviser..

I think that you've answered that yourself. Thanks for the clarification on the other stuff. At least I seemed to be of some use in bumping it to the top.



s'allwight

i'm just obsessed with what I do, so these threads are like the smell of fish fingers to a chap who hasn't seen a woman for 40 years

minimax

11,985 posts

287 months

Friday 24th March 2006
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]



decent cover gets indexed so remains the same in real terms

all other points valid also, a good broker will know which policies do which and what is most appropriate.

also, if the broker has done his job well in explaining his recommendation then it should be immediately apparent to the client why a particular level of cover is appropriate

minicity

1,009 posts

262 months

Friday 24th March 2006
quotequote all
I applied for a mortgage this morning and I couldn't believe it when the consultant let me walk away without even making any effort to sell me any type of insurance. Top bloke!

minimax

11,985 posts

287 months

Friday 24th March 2006
quotequote all
minicity said:
I applied for a mortgage this morning and I couldn't believe it when the consultant let me walk away without even making any effort to sell me any type of insurance. Top bloke!



or alternatively, and not meaning to sound rude, incompetent bloke!

with insurances it's important to look at what you actually need and make a decision with an open mind...

for instance, he didn't even try to requote your home insurance? pretty poor show IMHO, most brokers deal with at least a few insurers and usually get discounts that you can't get so it would've been worthwhile.. I would be questioning how committed he is to your case to be fair

smirnoff

611 posts

281 months

Friday 24th March 2006
quotequote all
I'm keeping quiet, please carry on minimax! I am enjoying this.

Except that IPB is better than MPI, you can explain that one.

Adrian

>> Edited by smirnoff on Friday 24th March 15:08