Legal advice please
Discussion
In December 2003, my mum's partner Mike died. They were co-habiting, and had mirror wills made that named one another the sole benefactors. If they both died within 28 days of one another, the estate would be split between me and my sister, and two of Mike's siblings.
Anyway, last night my mum had gone for a drink when she ran into one of these siblings. He was quite unpleasant to my mum and started saying "I can't believe Mike didn't even leave me the price of a pint" and "I want to see the will." My mum phoned me this morning to tell me this, clearly pretty distraught at the ghoulish behaviour.
Coincidentally, the other sibling had contacted my mum about a week ago asking for a copy of Mike's death certificate, and a certificate concerning his change of name. She claimed it was because an policy was about to mature for her son, and Mike had been named as a trustee, and she needed to prove he'd passed away. Now my mum is beginning to doubt this story, and thinks she might have been deceived.
From my (admittedly brief) readings, it seems like you have little chance of contesting a will unless you're a dependant who hasn't been provided for, the wording/witnessing are poor, or you were too loopy to understand what you were signing. However, I'd like a perspective from someone who knows better than I, and perhaps some advice I can offer my mum. I've already told her to get a new will sorted out and see a solicitor pre-emptively. Any further information would be gratefully received.
Anyway, last night my mum had gone for a drink when she ran into one of these siblings. He was quite unpleasant to my mum and started saying "I can't believe Mike didn't even leave me the price of a pint" and "I want to see the will." My mum phoned me this morning to tell me this, clearly pretty distraught at the ghoulish behaviour.
Coincidentally, the other sibling had contacted my mum about a week ago asking for a copy of Mike's death certificate, and a certificate concerning his change of name. She claimed it was because an policy was about to mature for her son, and Mike had been named as a trustee, and she needed to prove he'd passed away. Now my mum is beginning to doubt this story, and thinks she might have been deceived.
From my (admittedly brief) readings, it seems like you have little chance of contesting a will unless you're a dependant who hasn't been provided for, the wording/witnessing are poor, or you were too loopy to understand what you were signing. However, I'd like a perspective from someone who knows better than I, and perhaps some advice I can offer my mum. I've already told her to get a new will sorted out and see a solicitor pre-emptively. Any further information would be gratefully received.
(having concentrated quite hard trying to remember something about inheritance law from my law finals donkeys yeras ago...)
If I have got this right it is Mike's offspring who are making the noises? If so they may not need to contest the will. A persons children can make an application for payment from an estate on the grounds that it left inadequate provision for them. "Children" can be adults - it is the relationship which matters not the age.
The scenario you describe often arises on intestacy where someone remarries, forgets or didn't know that marriage revokes a will and then dies. The estate goes to the spouse and from there to the relatives of that person - who would generally not include the offspring from an earlier marriage. Did they have their wills drawn up by a solicitor or a will writing service? A good lawyer would ask about children from previous relationship but this is often outside the scope of the £75 a pop pick and mix do it yourself schemes.
I can't recall anything about timescales but I would suspect that they have expired by now anyway but there is a chance that something could some out of the woodwork. As you say challenging the will itself requires something more that "that's not fair" but the adequate provision thing is far broader.
If you know a solicitor who does this kind of work it might be worth checking if there could be any challenges. Peace of mind could be worth investing in a couple of hours of someone's time.
If I have got this right it is Mike's offspring who are making the noises? If so they may not need to contest the will. A persons children can make an application for payment from an estate on the grounds that it left inadequate provision for them. "Children" can be adults - it is the relationship which matters not the age.
The scenario you describe often arises on intestacy where someone remarries, forgets or didn't know that marriage revokes a will and then dies. The estate goes to the spouse and from there to the relatives of that person - who would generally not include the offspring from an earlier marriage. Did they have their wills drawn up by a solicitor or a will writing service? A good lawyer would ask about children from previous relationship but this is often outside the scope of the £75 a pop pick and mix do it yourself schemes.
I can't recall anything about timescales but I would suspect that they have expired by now anyway but there is a chance that something could some out of the woodwork. As you say challenging the will itself requires something more that "that's not fair" but the adequate provision thing is far broader.
If you know a solicitor who does this kind of work it might be worth checking if there could be any challenges. Peace of mind could be worth investing in a couple of hours of someone's time.
The way I read it, it is Mike's siblings and not offspring that are making the noise (is that right?) that would assume his brother and sister... therefore unless they can prove he was not of sound mind then I cannot see any reason for them contesting (though I could be totally wrong)
cccs said:
Witchfinder might stand a chance of useful advice if you read his post.
Billnemisis - Witchfinder said siblings not offspring of Mike.
Jonna Rex - Witchfinder said "my mum's partner..co-habiting", guess that rules out marriage.
And you reckon I didn´t read? When it comes to the law, focusing on certain details is important and that´s why co-habiting doesn´t nessesarily mean that they are not married.
[quote=Jonna_Rex
And you reckon I didn´t read? When it comes to the law, focusing on certain details is important and that´s why co-habiting doesn´t nessesarily mean that they are not married.[/quote]
Yep, I agree with focusing on certain details is important. However-
Cohabitants - "A man and a woman who, although not married to each other, are living together as husband and wife" - Family Law Act 1996.
In English Law co-habiting does mean that they are not married.
And you reckon I didn´t read? When it comes to the law, focusing on certain details is important and that´s why co-habiting doesn´t nessesarily mean that they are not married.[/quote]
Yep, I agree with focusing on certain details is important. However-
Cohabitants - "A man and a woman who, although not married to each other, are living together as husband and wife" - Family Law Act 1996.
In English Law co-habiting does mean that they are not married.
quote=Jonna_Rex
And you reckon I didn´t read? When it comes to the law, focusing on certain details is important and that´s why co-habiting doesn´t nessesarily mean that they are not married.[/quote]
Jonna Rex "Interesting, in Finnish law it doesn't necessarily mean that. That's why I asked".
Now Jonna I've re-read the above and can see no mention of you asking.
And you reckon I didn´t read? When it comes to the law, focusing on certain details is important and that´s why co-habiting doesn´t nessesarily mean that they are not married.[/quote]
Jonna Rex "Interesting, in Finnish law it doesn't necessarily mean that. That's why I asked".
Now Jonna I've re-read the above and can see no mention of you asking.
My hands are up, she did ask.
Back to my original post, Witchfinder said "my mum's partner, Mike died".
Jonna "were they married?".
If they were married Witchfinder would have said "my mum's husband, Mike died".
Had Jonna read Witchfinder's post she would known they were not married.
Back to my original post, Witchfinder said "my mum's partner, Mike died".
Jonna "were they married?".
If they were married Witchfinder would have said "my mum's husband, Mike died".
Had Jonna read Witchfinder's post she would known they were not married.
cccs said:
My hands are up, she did ask.
Back to my original post, Witchfinder said "my mum's partner, Mike died".
Jonna "were they married?".
If they were married Witchfinder would have said "my mum's husband, Mike died".
Had Jonna read Witchfinder's post she would known they were not married.
And now you think your a seer. Bet you have one of those crystal balls where you can see what people will say next
Trolling belongs to the easter time. >> Edited by Jonna_Rex on Sunday 26th March 19:30
Gassing Station | The Pie & Piston Archive | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff




