First direct vs smile
Author
Discussion

Althalus

Original Poster:

344 posts

270 months

Monday 27th March 2006
quotequote all
I'm looking to shift my accounts into an online bank, what are people’s opinions of smile and first direct.

From what I can see the rates at fd are a bit better than at smile but you only get those rates if you pay in over £1000 a month and don't make any withdrawals.

Pro and cons?

I’m sick of banks messing me around!

mrs puggit

143 posts

276 months

Monday 27th March 2006
quotequote all
Had both - no problems with either. FD don't have a horrid call system ("Select from the following 9 choices" etc) you just go straight through. I do like the Smile website but a word of warning pay a bill online & it doesn't leave your account until the next business day!

You might also want to consider Cahoot? Very good interest rates & money leaves the account that day. Puggit swears by them, which is why I'm in the process of signing up.

Jaglover

46,849 posts

266 months

Monday 27th March 2006
quotequote all
I haven't used either.

But I do have both loan and savings accounts with Cahoot and Egg; and both have good, simple to use, websites

Raffles

1,931 posts

261 months

Monday 27th March 2006
quotequote all
You'll never know how good a bank can possibly be until you go with First Direct.

They are very good on the phone, if you need a branch just go into HSBC. Phone is 24hrs a day too, which can be suprisingly handy. Never had to be put on hold before getting through to a real person who speaks perfect English!

r5gttgaz

7,897 posts

251 months

Monday 27th March 2006
quotequote all
I've been with FD now for over 4 years, absolutly fantastic and always helpful be it on the phone or getting emergency money, being abroad etc.

Couldnt recommend them enough.

ding dong

514 posts

306 months

Monday 27th March 2006
quotequote all
Again, recommend FD without any hesitation. Rang them from Oz once with a transaction problem and they simply rang me straight back, sorted problem within a minute. Can honestly say in over 10 yrs I have never had reason to grumble once.

fozzi

3,773 posts

271 months

Monday 27th March 2006
quotequote all
No experience of Smile, Cahoot or Egg.. but have no need of them, as I too am an extremely content First Direct customer... can not recommend them enough!!

My current First Direct portfolio includes offset mortgage, savings account, current account and credit card... all completely 100% trouble free!

touchingcloth

11,706 posts

270 months

Monday 27th March 2006
quotequote all
I have been with Smile since very soon after they first launched and love them. I actually moved from First Direct because of their charges for going overdrawn (quite a hefty charge as soon as you step over even by a few quid and further charges for every transaction after that), other than that they were very good. At the time I was with FD I was younger and more foolish and often tripped over my overdraft limit and often didn't realise until some time later - smile charges were a lot less. I tend to not go over anymore anyway so I suspect if I was with FD now I would be very happy with them. If I remember correctly FD would not put a block on you using your card if over your limit, they would just let you carry on (I guess so they could reap the charges), smile cuts off right on the limit so yes you might get turned down in a shop which is embarrassing, but at least you get a sharp reminder that you have hit your OD limit.

nwtony

3,011 posts

259 months

Monday 27th March 2006
quotequote all
I changed from barclays to Smile and have had no problems at all. All transactions go through no problem, easy to deal with, phone support of you need it on an easy to remember number, web site clearly laid out. never tried FD so can't comment on them. Good to have an up to date statement on demand so you can be sure what has and hasn't gone out. With Smile you get the Co-op ethical policies too, which may or may not influence your decision.