2007 M3 or Lotus Exige S?
Discussion
2007 M3 or Lotus Exige S?
I am young and single, so I don't mind the discomfort of the Exige. However, the price is not cheap for 1800cc Toyota engine. Sometimes i think it's a rip off. If I pay some more I can buy a M3. The point is I guess the M3 can't catch up a Lotus on mountain roads, but I know the engine must be a master piece. Usually, I just driving alone or with a girl and love to fast running on mountain roads. I test drive the Std exige and that's not fast enough for my taste. I am drivng a STi right now.
Exige S
Love the looks, handling and it's great for mountain raods, but 1800cc Toyota engine for that price???
M3
I am not sure I will like the look or not, I don't like the coupe so.....
Love BMW handling and wonderful V8....
Any comments?
I am young and single, so I don't mind the discomfort of the Exige. However, the price is not cheap for 1800cc Toyota engine. Sometimes i think it's a rip off. If I pay some more I can buy a M3. The point is I guess the M3 can't catch up a Lotus on mountain roads, but I know the engine must be a master piece. Usually, I just driving alone or with a girl and love to fast running on mountain roads. I test drive the Std exige and that's not fast enough for my taste. I am drivng a STi right now.
Exige S
Love the looks, handling and it's great for mountain raods, but 1800cc Toyota engine for that price???
M3
I am not sure I will like the look or not, I don't like the coupe so.....
Love BMW handling and wonderful V8....
Any comments?
yep - one is a 2 seater sports car the other is a 3 series BMW with a big engine
...im not sure I would even have the 2 cars on the same list to consider !
if you want big engine feel/noise, in a sportscar then Id look at a TVR Sagaris
..the 3 series Beemer is for when you grow older, have kids and can only have one car....or you get one on the company car list - treat yourself to a real sportscar
...im not sure I would even have the 2 cars on the same list to consider !
if you want big engine feel/noise, in a sportscar then Id look at a TVR Sagaris
..the 3 series Beemer is for when you grow older, have kids and can only have one car....or you get one on the company car list - treat yourself to a real sportscar

Maybe best is buy a Lotus Exige S for now and tune it to lets say 280hp and have fun and first hand experience...
Then end of 2007 try and or buy the M3 with V8 that would be a masterpiece too
or even wait till 2008 and buy the new M3 V8 CSL....1250kg and 460hp??
On the moment I still drive a S54 Z3 M coupe(E46 M3) that realy is a masterpiece too when you take price, sporty feeling, reliability(new engines) fuel consumption with a 343ps car, and a good build quallity, I have driven and owened more then 116 cars in my 25 years of driving and this is my 3trd M coupe(also had a M roadster but not that stif) it realy is a almost perfect allrounder when you also drive a lot motorways!
But when driving a lot country roads and curves the Exige S with some tuning and the nice Lotus badge is a very very nice car to own and better drive too
GTRene
Then end of 2007 try and or buy the M3 with V8 that would be a masterpiece too
or even wait till 2008 and buy the new M3 V8 CSL....1250kg and 460hp?? On the moment I still drive a S54 Z3 M coupe(E46 M3) that realy is a masterpiece too when you take price, sporty feeling, reliability(new engines) fuel consumption with a 343ps car, and a good build quallity, I have driven and owened more then 116 cars in my 25 years of driving and this is my 3trd M coupe(also had a M roadster but not that stif) it realy is a almost perfect allrounder when you also drive a lot motorways!
But when driving a lot country roads and curves the Exige S with some tuning and the nice Lotus badge is a very very nice car to own and better drive too
GTRene
GTRene said:
Maybe best is buy a Lotus Exige S for now and tune it to lets say 280hp and have fun and first hand experience...
Then end of 2007 try and or buy the M3 with V8 that would be a masterpiece tooor even wait till 2008 and buy the new M3 V8 CSL....1250kg and 460hp??
On the moment I still drive a S54 Z3 M coupe(E46 M3) that realy is a masterpiece too when you take price, sporty feeling, reliability(new engines) fuel consumption with a 343ps car, and a good build quallity, I have driven and owened more then 116 cars in my 25 years of driving and this is my 3trd M coupe(also had a M roadster but not that stif) it realy is a almost perfect allrounder when you also drive a lot motorways!
But when driving a lot country roads and curves the Exige S with some tuning and the nice Lotus badge is a very very nice car to own and better drive too![]()
GTRene
woo...280hp? is that possible? i think that cost alot...
my plan is buy a new car next yr and have that for 2-3 years. so thats good for the M3 because that is still the latest model in the next 5-6 yrs. However, i guess the Lotus S3 will coming out soon??
ExigeS said:
woo...280hp? is that possible? i think that cost alot...
my plan is buy a new car next yr and have that for 2-3 years. so thats good for the M3 because that is still the latest model in the next 5-6 yrs. However, i guess the Lotus S3 will coming out soon??
Yep thats possible and not that expensive, even a bit more...but that cost more and maybe needs expensive parts...
But if you wanted to buy your car in 2007...better wait because the gossips are going for the new Elise/Exige S3 in 2007 and that car would also a bit bigger me thinks, and standard some more power, and better lights
and even maybe the gulwing type doors in the Exige... So if you like to buy in 2007...wait till the end of the year then you know more...
GTRene
GTRene said:
ExigeS said:
woo...280hp? is that possible? i think that cost alot...
my plan is buy a new car next yr and have that for 2-3 years. so thats good for the M3 because that is still the latest model in the next 5-6 yrs. However, i guess the Lotus S3 will coming out soon??
Yep thats possible and not that expensive, even a bit more...but that cost more and maybe needs expensive parts...
But if you wanted to buy your car in 2007...better wait because the gossips are going for the new Elise/Exige S3 in 2007 and that car would also a bit bigger me thinks, and standard some more power, and better lightsand even maybe the gulwing type doors in the Exige...
So if you like to buy in 2007...wait till the end of the year then you know more...
GTRene
S3? thats nice. seriously i really want to own a new model. so you guess the S3 elise/exige are coming out together? waitting is fine, but at least with some photos. do you have any photos about the S3? by the way, gulwing is very nice!
nope no photo's yet...that will take some time I guess, maybe in august or sept we know a bit more, though its gona be a bit larger.
And most of the time they will not come out together...S1 was Elise first, folowed by a Exige some years later.
S2 was Elise first, also folowed by a Exige some years later...
But if they bring gulwing type doors, this could mean the Exige would be more different from the Elise then it is now...and for a change will come out in the same year?
But nothing certain ofcorse and most are deep? secrets
GTRene
>> Edited by GTRene on Monday 24th April 18:56
And most of the time they will not come out together...S1 was Elise first, folowed by a Exige some years later.
S2 was Elise first, also folowed by a Exige some years later...
But if they bring gulwing type doors, this could mean the Exige would be more different from the Elise then it is now...and for a change will come out in the same year?
But nothing certain ofcorse and most are deep? secrets
GTRene
>> Edited by GTRene on Monday 24th April 18:56
The two cars from my view are so totally different it's not really possible to compare them, firstly there is a huge price difference, M3 is likely to come in at £50K (I've got one on order as a daily driver) for the price point it's more a comparison to a Noble really.
From a driving point of view it's a very different experience, on track there is no way an M3 can stay with an Exige even the CSL can't hold onto a supercharged Exige. The feel and feedback is totally different, the BMW will always feel aloof where the Lotus totally involves.
As for the engines, yes it's a toyota engine (or Yamaha if you want to be accurate) I've owned all sorts of cars that I've used hard on track and the engine in the Lotus with the Supercharger really does deliver on track and suits the car well. BMW don't always get it right, I had a V8 M5 that needed a new engine under warranty and then an M Coupe that needed a new engine then an M3 that needed a new engine, the CSL I had was great though (well except two flywheel/clutches....) New BM engine do seem to need a year or so before they are reliable these days if used hard.... the BMW boys can confirm this, I love the cars but don't expect the engines to be bullet proof!
If it's mainly a road car and you want to have all the toys, gadgets and electronic safety systems (the Lotus only offers traction control, very different to DSC on a BMW), the BMW is for you, however if you want driving involvement, the Lotus is the way to go.
From a driving point of view it's a very different experience, on track there is no way an M3 can stay with an Exige even the CSL can't hold onto a supercharged Exige. The feel and feedback is totally different, the BMW will always feel aloof where the Lotus totally involves.
As for the engines, yes it's a toyota engine (or Yamaha if you want to be accurate) I've owned all sorts of cars that I've used hard on track and the engine in the Lotus with the Supercharger really does deliver on track and suits the car well. BMW don't always get it right, I had a V8 M5 that needed a new engine under warranty and then an M Coupe that needed a new engine then an M3 that needed a new engine, the CSL I had was great though (well except two flywheel/clutches....) New BM engine do seem to need a year or so before they are reliable these days if used hard.... the BMW boys can confirm this, I love the cars but don't expect the engines to be bullet proof!
If it's mainly a road car and you want to have all the toys, gadgets and electronic safety systems (the Lotus only offers traction control, very different to DSC on a BMW), the BMW is for you, however if you want driving involvement, the Lotus is the way to go.
ExigeS said:
do you think that orange car from autoexpress is the S3 ELISE? how do you know about the S3 thing? that cool... do you think they're going to use the same chassis and yota again?
Orange car from autoexpress? don't know that one, but I think its that car with some VX crossings? nope thats not a new S3.
There's not much news around the S3 but for what I've heard and read across the net its gona be a bit larger and they study to use gulwing type doors, but me thinks a bit different then the M250 kind...I would like such idea though! and with those lightweight stuf they have its not that difficult and will add a lot sexe peal? to such small sporty car
and also a better acces depeds of how far they let the doors go into the roof...a bit GT40 doors but then go up instead of just open and when a car stands close you can't get in cause of such door...up is the way to go
about the chassis and engine I don't know, but my guess is also a bit different! a bit wider, longer, more lightweight alu stuff and a bigger engine as option...
GTRene
Just test drive a standard Exige today.
It is fun and quick !!
Can't believe after run-in this car has much better performance.
The first one I drive has only 112KM.
Today that one has 7000KM and it is much faster.
I really love the Exige !!
The Toyota engine is not bad at all.
Up to 8,500 rpm !! Woo...
Real GOOD!
It is fun and quick !!
Can't believe after run-in this car has much better performance.
The first one I drive has only 112KM.
Today that one has 7000KM and it is much faster.
I really love the Exige !!
The Toyota engine is not bad at all.
Up to 8,500 rpm !! Woo...
Real GOOD!
i ran an s2 elise for a couple of years then moved to an m3. at the time i obviously thought it was the right thing. but after a year of ownership i found the performance of the m3 very good but to be honest its still a boring family car. infact the only things to like were the lsd and the engine. other than that it was a 316!
so i needed to get myself another sportscar and recently purchased a naturally aspirated s2 exige. i don't regret selling the m3 for one second. please don't make the same mistake that i did!
so i needed to get myself another sportscar and recently purchased a naturally aspirated s2 exige. i don't regret selling the m3 for one second. please don't make the same mistake that i did!

swilding said:
i ran an s2 elise for a couple of years then moved to an m3. at the time i obviously thought it was the right thing. but after a year of ownership i found the performance of the m3 very good but to be honest its still a boring family car. infact the only things to like were the lsd and the engine. other than that it was a 316!
so i needed to get myself another sportscar and recently purchased a naturally aspirated s2 exige. i don't regret selling the m3 for one second. please don't make the same mistake that i did!
Yup! Exige is very fun to drive!!
I used to have a 316ti M before, the handling was great. However, FR BMW is really different than the MR Lotus. Both are great, but the Lotus is more exciting.
>> Edited by ExigeS on Wednesday 26th April 19:47
speedyellow said:
From a driving point of view it's a very different experience, on track there is no way an M3 can stay with an Exige even the CSL can't hold onto a supercharged Exige. The feel and feedback is totally different, the BMW will always feel aloof where the Lotus totally involves.
I'm not sure that is a very fair appraisal of a CSL. They are amazing cars, and personally speaking, I'm not at all convinced a supercharged Exige would keep with one although thats just an impression I've built on the trackdays I've attended so hardly conclusive.
>> Edited by DanH on Thursday 27th April 01:40
Gassing Station | Elise/Exige/Europa/340R | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff





