Smoking 996
Author
Discussion

bermyandy

Original Poster:

2,050 posts

249 months

Sunday 4th June 2006
quotequote all
In the last 2 days, if i drive the car, then leave it parked up for a few hours, when i turn the engine back on i get quite a bit of white smoke coming out of the exhaust

Got porsche assist out to it just now, and checked the oil. While the on board oil check says the oil level is high, the dip stick says its actually just on the minimum.

Really just wondered if anyone else had come across this before? Going to the OPC this week to resolve the issue on computer oil level check as well the white smoke..

Typical!

porkernut

127 posts

246 months

Sunday 4th June 2006
quotequote all
white puffs of oil smoke on start up now & again are a traint of the car, but if it is smoking once you are driving or when fully warmed up, or doing it every time you start, it will need checking out!

Edited by porkernut on Sunday 4th June 17:15

bermyandy

Original Poster:

2,050 posts

249 months

Sunday 4th June 2006
quotequote all
only once ive warmed it up and then left it in the sun - oddly only been doing it since the weather changed

bermyandy

Original Poster:

2,050 posts

249 months

Sunday 4th June 2006
quotequote all
Just checked the oil on the now cooled down car, and on the dipstick the oil is no in the middle so spot on.

Can somone sort my knowledge here - i would have thought as the oil heats up it would expand slightly, and so if anything, would appear to have more oil? Or am i missing something?

stevegardyne

1,240 posts

246 months

Sunday 4th June 2006
quotequote all
I'd have thought the oil settling down to the nether regions of the engine after a period of time would likely be more of an influencing factor than any subtle changes in displaced volume as a result of temperature effects. Having said that it would still result in a higher level rather than a lower one so doesn't get you any further forward. I've never really considered what the likely temperature effects on stabilised synthetic oil would be but I would have though them to be minimal.

Will make a point of checking to see what the dipstick in mine tells me hot vs. cold if I remember!

hartech

1,929 posts

248 months

Monday 5th June 2006
quotequote all
How old is the car and how many miles has it covered?- Baz Hartech

bermyandy

Original Poster:

2,050 posts

249 months

Monday 5th June 2006
quotequote all
its a 51 plate, done 54k give or take

Awaiting a call from the porsche technical bit

Neilpeel59

279 posts

250 months

Monday 5th June 2006
quotequote all
under normal driving conditions my 996 doesn't use any oil and there is not a hint a smoke at start-up. However after a track thrash it smokes A LOT at start up but clears after a few miles. I'm now confident there is nothing wrong with the engine and think it may have been slightly overfilled. Apparently Shell do a "smoke free" oil? anybody heard of that?

bermyandy

Original Poster:

2,050 posts

249 months

Monday 5th June 2006
quotequote all
Tech guy wasnt sure why the on board dash was so different to the diptick, although did mention sometimes there is a slight variation.

Its going into the OPC end of this month just to get it checked over.

Now, should i get the PSE done at the same time, or do i wait to double check the car isnt dying so i dont get faced with a huge bill?

nel

4,830 posts

272 months

Monday 5th June 2006
quotequote all
bermyandy said:
Just checked the oil on the now cooled down car, and on the dipstick the oil is no in the middle so spot on.


I thought the protocol for oil level checks was the same on 996s as on my antique - get engine up to operating temperature so that oil thermostat is open, then check oil level with the engine running when it is parked on a flat surface? If so then the cooled down reading will be meaningless.

Best of luck.

clorenzen

3,846 posts

266 months

Monday 5th June 2006
quotequote all
If you have had a spirited drive earlier it is quite normal that some oil residue will burn off next time you swich the engine on. However is goes away quite quickly thereafter (30 secs of idling) so if it persists you need to check with an expert. At trackdays it is a common feature that the 996 will smoke upon restarting after a previous stint on the track.

bermyandy

Original Poster:

2,050 posts

249 months

Monday 5th June 2006
quotequote all
It goes away after a 15 seconds or so but the first time it happened (saturday) i had driven 10 miles at no more than 40mph as there as so many damn scameras!!!

Was then left for 5 hours before re-starting and getting smoke

sportsandclassic

3,774 posts

249 months

Monday 5th June 2006
quotequote all
the smoke is often caused by a faulty engine breather box....done a couple now and fixed problem...

thong

414 posts

263 months

Monday 5th June 2006
quotequote all
sportsand classic is correct,change the oil seperator ive just done one witch was smoking quite bad,perfect now,these can go bad and fill the exhaust with oil ive seen it dont let it get this bad,

Dale.

ps michel that boxster 2nd gear is great now m8 cheers.

bermyandy

Original Poster:

2,050 posts

249 months

Monday 5th June 2006
quotequote all
sportsandclassic - if it is the breather box, is that a bad thing to replace or just a minor thing?

sportsandclassic

3,774 posts

249 months

Monday 5th June 2006
quotequote all
is it a tiptronic or manual car ?

sportsandclassic

3,774 posts

249 months

Monday 5th June 2006
quotequote all
The tip car is a job and half as you are better off removing the engine to replace the breather.
The manual car is still a job and a half but can be done in situ..

bermyandy

Original Poster:

2,050 posts

249 months

Tuesday 6th June 2006
quotequote all
Tip im afraid. If it is that, is it a wear and tear item, or likely to be under warranty?

(got the porsche extended warranty)

Suppose though if the engine does have to come out for it, i could get a three letter acronymed part checked while they are it - just a passing comment, dont want to turn this thread down that route

hartech

1,929 posts

248 months

Tuesday 6th June 2006
quotequote all
It should be covered by the warranty. It is a strange device - a plastic box with a spring and a very flimsy diaphragm inside basically an empty box operated by a vacuum pipe connection opening and closing a breather to the air intake and engine casing. We have looked inside a few (cut them open) and have not yet finally decided what goes wrong but it looks like the diaphragm perforates or becomes unstuck and/or the vacuum is insufficient to operate it on tickover. Once the pipe vacuum was simply off the connection - so a simple fix - but on another occassion there was actually an engine problem behind the smoking.

Usually it is the box - but not always.

However - because the bores become oval the rings stop fitting nicely (there is a limit to how oval they can distort to fit the shape) and because the pistons are oval anyway - effectively they sit in the oval bores like a very worn piston and/or rings would - even though there will be negligible piston and actual cylinder wall wear. Typical of worn pistons or ill fitting rings however - is smoking or breather problems until the pistons expand enough to fit the bores better.

We are not yet sure if the box fails or just becomes less effective as the engine vacuum on tickover gradually deteriorates - and a new box is a temporary fix able to work again on reduced vacuum - or a permanent one - so the jury is still out on this one here.

As the engines wear I think a thicker oil is a good preventative measure helping to support the pistons more.

We have seen a few that have seized a piston on the thrust face and not the rear face. This has been interpreted by some as an indication that the old coolant has caused the problem (and they may be right) but I think it may be (or perhaps also be) the blow by past the piston on the oval face overheating the oil and reducing its effectiveness on the thrust face and leading to it picking up on the bore material. This is because it is very rare to see a piston seized on one side only and perfectly OK on the opposite face - and always this is when the bores have become about 0.1mm bigger in the thrust face direction and a similar amount narrower accross the width - at the top - so this is one of those typical problems that time may resolve. I was drawn to this conclusion after seeing a piston - not yet seized but with very thick oil becoming burnt on the thruat face at the top under the ring and realising that it had become too hot just there but nowhere else. it was like the ones seized on that face but not yet got there.

Resolving such problems is important for independents so we can help and advise our customers and when different solutions appear from different contributors - it is not a competition but just a process of everyone contributing their observations, experience and analytical skills that eventually helps everyone to resolve the problem. At the early stages few have seen every option or factor - only part of the story - and I have found reading these web details very helpful in working out clues to problems. It is not an issue in which people are competing to see who is right or wrong but instead is everyone contributing until the answers evolve for everyones benefit. Well thats how I see it anyway and I am happy to put in my thoughts even if they prove in the fullness of time to be right or wrong - the main thing is to all help each other quickly find the ansers and fix these cars at minimu cost and inconvenience.


Baz Hartech

bermyandy

Original Poster:

2,050 posts

249 months

Tuesday 6th June 2006
quotequote all
Baz, many many thanks for the reply.

It's going to the OPC in a few weeks time to see what the problem and will let you know what they tell me

Cheers