Your country needs you .........
Your country needs you .........
Author
Discussion

Richard92c2

Original Poster:

464 posts

291 months

Thursday 6th February 2003
quotequote all
Well, I suppose with all the warmongering taking place over the last few days/weeks/months It brings up a thought in my mind that is just too important to leave be ...

Should war break out with North Korea/Iraq (and whomever else feels like being hero's) and the USA (and Britain)are you prepared to act against them. I remember too well from growing up in a war torn country, We had no choice, we were called to arms. If you did not agree to bear arms against your enemy, they locked you up in a prison for two years...

Question is though, would you voluntarily take up arms to preserve and protect your country and folk??



>>> Edited by Richard92c2 on Thursday 6th February 13:10

plotloss

67,280 posts

298 months

Thursday 6th February 2003
quotequote all
If god forbid it was ever required then without question yes.

Matt.

andymadmak

15,534 posts

298 months

Thursday 6th February 2003
quotequote all
yes

Eric Mc

125,342 posts

293 months

Thursday 6th February 2003
quotequote all
Only if I felt the cause was just and moral. I'm not convinced that the current planned operation falls into that category. Anyway, I'm too old now so I'd probably be the equivalent of a Captain Mainwaring.

sadoksevoli

1,232 posts

285 months

Thursday 6th February 2003
quotequote all
Of course I would - gladly.

But I don't think the Army's bureaucracy would ever cope with any sudden need for troops - at present it takes a minimum of six weeks to process entry (or re-entry in my case) into the TA - they make the Passport Office or DVLA shine as beacons of efficiency.

dontlift

9,396 posts

286 months

Thursday 6th February 2003
quotequote all

would you voluntarily take up arms to preserve and protect your country and folk??


If we ran out of oil I would be there like a shot, lets face it this has nothing to do with protecting our country - we arnt being invaded......

Jinx

12,008 posts

288 months

Thursday 6th February 2003
quotequote all
Yep, cannon fodder is a definite step up the ol'career ladder.

elanturbo

565 posts

290 months

Thursday 6th February 2003
quotequote all
Not if I thought that this was was only about oil and furthering the careers of scumbag politicians.

However, the situation seems to be getting more complicated by the day and recent intelligence from the americans, should it be verified, is quite disturbing.

Agent006

12,058 posts

292 months

Thursday 6th February 2003
quotequote all
I'd try as hard as i could to do something like intelligence or logistics or something like that. I'd be the world's crappest soldier.

gsxrblue

238 posts

294 months

Thursday 6th February 2003
quotequote all
Heaven help us if the last line of defence is us lot.

drux

66 posts

288 months

Thursday 6th February 2003
quotequote all


Question is though, would you voluntarily take up arms to preserve and protect your country and folk??



Yes "To protect Queen, Country and old Blighty"
but not to help Tony and George save face

CarZee

13,382 posts

295 months

Thursday 6th February 2003
quotequote all
No I bloody wouldn't.

If anyone thinks I'm going to take up arms on behalf of a group of countries run by people with their own private agendas and a complete disregard for me & mine, they can think again.

When Billy L get's the warpaint on and sits in the trenches trying to get the sandf out of his SA80, I'll go along, but so long as him and Bush are sat in bunkers in London & DC, I'm not interested.

Me going abroad to sort out the fcuk ups of the UN, EU, NATO, Blair, Major, Thatch, Bush, Bush, Reagan & Clinton is not going to happen. Fcuk 'em!

Richard92c2

Original Poster:

464 posts

291 months

Thursday 6th February 2003
quotequote all
The question was not one to catch anyone out, or prove manhood or macho'ism, I had a debate with some chaps here at work and asked the same question, Got a really mixed bag of answers ..Most were "very brave and macho "yeah, we'll go kick their asses", some were "fence sitters" "I'll only go if I am called up" (and they would go out kicking and screaming) and others said absolutely not "Fcuk that, I wont risk my life for someone elses"... then there were the few (simple minded) that said they would stay home and take care of the woman!

I am a trained combat soldier and would go and fight to protect my coutry and people!

dave_s13

14,015 posts

297 months

Thursday 6th February 2003
quotequote all
With people knowing what they know now as opposed to what they knew during the 1st & 2nd world wars I don't think the system could cope.
The number of objectors staying at home on the grounds of not wanting to end up like that torso in Saving Private Ryan would be huge, there'd be no room to lock em all up.......I suppose you could shoot them instead though........

Deester

1,607 posts

288 months

Thursday 6th February 2003
quotequote all
Not a fcuking chance.

See CarZees' post.

Deester.

TheLemming

4,319 posts

293 months

Thursday 6th February 2003
quotequote all
Fortunately we are unlikely to get into a war requiring massive amounts of cannon fodder, which lets be honest, is pretty much all conscrpts or troops with a couple of weeks training are good for.

The current strategy seems to be "bomb them for a couple of weeks, then send in one or two lads to accept the surrender."

A gross generalisation of course, but the role of he infantry is now that of highly trained comparatively small formations (small compared to those of past wars of course).

The force multipliers of heavy naval, air and artillery support make a small force more effective than one many times larger.

(Compare the sizes of the infantry and armoured forces verses their opposition in the first gulf war, Iraqi divisions were smashed by forces a fraction of their size in manpower. Then again in some instances they also surrendered to passing supply helicopters...)

Yertis

19,682 posts

294 months

Thursday 6th February 2003
quotequote all
I'd go. I wouldn't be able to look my folks in the eye if I went "conchy". But I'm too old now, so it's easy for may to say that. Ask me again 20 years ago.

t1grm

4,657 posts

312 months

Thursday 6th February 2003
quotequote all
I would if I thought there was a genuine threat to the British mainland being invaded (i.e. a couple of million enemy troops sitting in northern France or Eastern Europe) but otherwise no. I don't want to be a pawn in some politicians game of grand strategy. Plus I'm a coward and don't want to get shot

loudpedal

3,945 posts

297 months

Thursday 6th February 2003
quotequote all
I would go if conscrpted but I would volunteer if the UK was directly threatened...