Discussion
I am considering an Elise as a track day car, and for the occasional blat in the Peak District (I admit that I am also considering a Porsche 968CS and a Caterham) but would like advice on whether an S1 or S2 is the best bet (and which of the myriad models?). I note that S2 prices appear to be coming down and I must admit that the Toyota engine apeals to me over the K-Series. Any thoughts?
Having tracked both the K-series and VVC engines, my distinct preference is for the Toyota powered option. It's genuinely fun to manage the tight powerband of the variable valve timing.
Oh, and if you can find one in budget, the extra downforce of the exige is a joy. (Though aftermarket aerodynamics are available for the elise - no idea of their effectiveness).
Tol
Oh, and if you can find one in budget, the extra downforce of the exige is a joy. (Though aftermarket aerodynamics are available for the elise - no idea of their effectiveness).
Tol
S1's start at about £9000 and 111R's (Toyota Engined S2's) Start at about 19 grand, so you can't really compare the two cos for £19k you could get a Honda'd S1 that'd dwarf the 111R in terms of ouright performance. The S2's that seem to be dropping are the standard 1.8 K series ones, R's are holding their value pretty well.
(p.s. be a man and get an s1...)
(p.s. be a man and get an s1...)
Have a look on the "Buyers Guide" thread:
www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?t=284992&f=15&h=0
Links to all sorts on there. At this stage most use might be
www.elises.co.uk/models/index.html
www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?t=284992&f=15&h=0
Links to all sorts on there. At this stage most use might be
www.elises.co.uk/models/index.html
Thanks, and I'm afraid that that means that I can't afford a Toyota engined model (or a Honda engined conversion, which would be my ideal). Depending on who you talk to, the K Series is either problematical (I guess that's why there are so many elise for sale at 40-50K miles!) or one of the best engines ever designed.
I am nervous, though, as I don't want to buy a car and then have to start having engine rebuilds. Perhaps the 968CS is favourite after all!!!!!! However, if I assume that I do go down the K engined route, back to the original question - S1 or S2 for a car that will be driven on the road (very occasionally) but will be also used on half a dozen track days a year?
I am nervous, though, as I don't want to buy a car and then have to start having engine rebuilds. Perhaps the 968CS is favourite after all!!!!!! However, if I assume that I do go down the K engined route, back to the original question - S1 or S2 for a car that will be driven on the road (very occasionally) but will be also used on half a dozen track days a year?
For the proposed use you would do well to consider the following:
S1 - Sport 135, Sport 160, 111S
S2 - 135R, 111S, 111R or Exige
...or if you can find one, a Honda/Audi/Duratec converted car which will astound you with regard to performance.
Pound for pound I'd recommend a good S1 if it's not a daily driver. Save your money for upkeep and trackdays!
Edited to say:
I've just realised that the above's not particularly helpful as I've listed the most popular variants... well for good reason really. Personally I'd say check out the S1 Sport 135 (if you can find one), the S1 Sport 160 or the S2 135R. Great cars, don't be scared of the K-series.
S1 - Sport 135, Sport 160, 111S
S2 - 135R, 111S, 111R or Exige
...or if you can find one, a Honda/Audi/Duratec converted car which will astound you with regard to performance.
Pound for pound I'd recommend a good S1 if it's not a daily driver. Save your money for upkeep and trackdays!
Edited to say:
I've just realised that the above's not particularly helpful as I've listed the most popular variants... well for good reason really. Personally I'd say check out the S1 Sport 135 (if you can find one), the S1 Sport 160 or the S2 135R. Great cars, don't be scared of the K-series.
Edited by S Works on Wednesday 19th July 09:23
Go and sample both and you make your mind up. *Most* of the differences are aesthetic.
I wouldn't worry too much about the K-Series engine if I were you, it is no worse than any other engine out there. Some people are very vocal about perceived short-comings of it but it is an old trusted design, parts are cheap and knowledgable people are plentiful. Maintenance is simple too.
How cheap will a 968 be to maintain ?
What is your budget BTW ?
I wouldn't worry too much about the K-Series engine if I were you, it is no worse than any other engine out there. Some people are very vocal about perceived short-comings of it but it is an old trusted design, parts are cheap and knowledgable people are plentiful. Maintenance is simple too.
How cheap will a 968 be to maintain ?
What is your budget BTW ?
968's are nice cars but the bills can be rather scary!!! my mate's got one (his dad's old one) and I would cry if I got some of the bills he gets!!
there's nothing wrong with a standard K series Elise, my S1 is just a 1.8 K with induction kit/exhaust and it's magic. And it's reliable (ignore the fact that it's burning a bit of oil on start up...)
there's nothing wrong with a standard K series Elise, my S1 is just a 1.8 K with induction kit/exhaust and it's magic. And it's reliable (ignore the fact that it's burning a bit of oil on start up...)
I am looking at spending £10-12K. I know that I can get a 968CS for that (Through an independent porsche specialist friend of mine). The 968 is largely bullet proof and rated as one of the best handling cars ever by many of the mags; I can get it maintained for £40-45 per hour. I do have a hankering after an elise, though. Can't afford an exige!
andy97 said:
I am looking at spending £10-12K. I know that I can get a 968CS for that (Through an independent porsche specialist friend of mine). The 968 is largely bullet proof and rated as one of the best handling cars ever by many of the mags; I can get it maintained for £40-45 per hour. I do have a hankering after an elise, though. Can't afford an exige!
I get my Elise maintained at £20 per hour. It's a very basic car really, just awkward to work on.
We had a 944 Turbo - that was scary when it went wrong.
I'd go for a decent spec Elise over the 968CS any day - the 968 is based on the 944 chassis which was on the go in 1982 - it is good but it was the final evolution of the breed. At 12k, if your alternative is a Porsche, you'll be better putting your money into an S2. Don't be scared by mileage on an Elise, but make sure it's been maintained and serviced. Bear in mind that, on a commute, an Elise will do about 40mpg (I had 55 once...) whereas the 968 will do about, what, 25mpg? With petrol at £1 a litre that makes a big difference.
Remember, that the Elise is also rated as one of the best handling cars....I would certainly argue that it has far better steering (both feel and response) than the 968
They're different types of car - drive them and see which you prefer. Either way, you'll be on a winner
So long as you don't rag the K series from cold every day you won't experience any problems with it.
The only real issue with them is Head Gasket Failure but even then its only £500 all in by an approved dealership- budget this in as a worst case scenario & you cant go wrong.
I imagine the Porsche & Elise will be lightyears apart in handling - i know the porsche was great in its time buty i've owned & driven a lot of cars & nothing comes even close to the Elise until youre talking caterham, Lotus &'s etc.
Judging by your previous posts - buy with your heart & get a Lotus
The only real issue with them is Head Gasket Failure but even then its only £500 all in by an approved dealership- budget this in as a worst case scenario & you cant go wrong.
I imagine the Porsche & Elise will be lightyears apart in handling - i know the porsche was great in its time buty i've owned & driven a lot of cars & nothing comes even close to the Elise until youre talking caterham, Lotus &'s etc.
Judging by your previous posts - buy with your heart & get a Lotus
Seems odd that people worry about the K-series engine, there must be how many 10,000s of them pulling along old rovers, mgs and land rovers with well over 100k miles without any trouble.
The elise also weights a good bit less than any of the other cars using the engine so should have less stress put on it.
Colin
The elise also weights a good bit less than any of the other cars using the engine so should have less stress put on it.
Colin
cjm said:
The elise also weights a good bit less than any of the other cars using the engine so should have less stress put on it.
Colin
....except that they probably get revved a lot harder than the average rover installation, which is much harder on the engine than pulling a heavier weight. Agree with sentiments though, people seem to just assume the K is a crap engine because it's a rover. I love the VVC K in my 111S. Perfect balance of power, economy, leightweight and reliability.
andy97 said:
I am looking at spending £10-12K. I know that I can get a 968CS for that (Through an independent porsche specialist friend of mine). The 968 is largely bullet proof and rated as one of the best handling cars ever by many of the mags; I can get it maintained for £40-45 per hour. I do have a hankering after an elise, though. Can't afford an exige!
For that budget it will be a leggy 968CS probably in need of some work. 968 engine is not regarded as bullet proof as the 944 often requiring top-end overhaul due to camteeth wear.
If it was my 12 grand budget I would opt for:
'98 S1 40000ish miles £9000
Nitron Suspension/geo £1500
Balance for Tuition, bits & bobs etc
I've got an early S2 - it's fabulous!
don't be put off by the engine. - the only real downside is the tendency to blow head gaskets, but even this is a bit over-emphasised, and as someone's said, it's only a £500 bill at a dealer to get that fixed. - it's a great engine, loads of torque for its size, very light, and perfect for the elise - also plenty of upgrade options!
For what you're describing, though, I'd have to recomend a lotus-7 type car like a caterham, westfield, tiger, etc etc. -
I bought the elise cos i'd be using it almost exclusively on the roads up here in scotland -and on the roads it's infinately better, great manners, comfort, roadholding on the rough bits etc etc. - different league..
.. but on the track, my Tiger R6 (which i sold to buy the elise) was FAR better, and much more fun! - I paid £13K for a factory built tiger R6, carbon fibre body, tuned 2L zetec engine, about 300bhp per tonne - on the track that takes a lot of beating! - on the road, though, it was quite a handfull at times, and with no windscreen it wasn't the most wife-friendly!
the choice is yours, but if you want a road machine, i'd save for an S2 (better comfort and manners than an S1), bit if you're after a track day beast, get a top spec lotus-7 style kit car (second hand under 10K and REALLY REALLY cheap to run! - i used to pay £250 a year fully comp on the Tiger age 24 and i'm over £800 on the lotus age 27. - go figure!)
A.
don't be put off by the engine. - the only real downside is the tendency to blow head gaskets, but even this is a bit over-emphasised, and as someone's said, it's only a £500 bill at a dealer to get that fixed. - it's a great engine, loads of torque for its size, very light, and perfect for the elise - also plenty of upgrade options!
For what you're describing, though, I'd have to recomend a lotus-7 type car like a caterham, westfield, tiger, etc etc. -
I bought the elise cos i'd be using it almost exclusively on the roads up here in scotland -and on the roads it's infinately better, great manners, comfort, roadholding on the rough bits etc etc. - different league..
.. but on the track, my Tiger R6 (which i sold to buy the elise) was FAR better, and much more fun! - I paid £13K for a factory built tiger R6, carbon fibre body, tuned 2L zetec engine, about 300bhp per tonne - on the track that takes a lot of beating! - on the road, though, it was quite a handfull at times, and with no windscreen it wasn't the most wife-friendly!
the choice is yours, but if you want a road machine, i'd save for an S2 (better comfort and manners than an S1), bit if you're after a track day beast, get a top spec lotus-7 style kit car (second hand under 10K and REALLY REALLY cheap to run! - i used to pay £250 a year fully comp on the Tiger age 24 and i'm over £800 on the lotus age 27. - go figure!)
A.
Gassing Station | Elise/Exige/Europa/340R | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff





S1 Sport 160!!!!
