Exige S2 or S1 Supercharged to 265bhp???
Exige S2 or S1 Supercharged to 265bhp???
Author
Discussion

humpy

Original Poster:

1,171 posts

250 months

Monday 24th July 2006
quotequote all
The cars up for sale and as soon as it's sold I will be Exiging

I need some advice from you good people. I had been considering getting a 2005 Exige S2 [black] with a budget of £26k. Then I came across a 2001 S1 with a supercharger conversion supposedly pushing out 265bhp for £23k - hmmmm - sounds interesting . Apparently it's a smidge quick [really?] and I'm going to drive it on Wednesday.

Don't really know much about S1's - even less about running one with that sort of engine. Just wondered what your experienced thoughts were - any guidance is gratefully received.

Ta

Edited by humpy on Thursday 27th July 21:38

shangani

3,069 posts

268 months

Tuesday 25th July 2006
quotequote all
Which SC conversion? If a turbo technics one, it is way over-priced and will blow up sooner or later. 265 bhp is low for a honda SC conversion - they make 290+ generally and are silly quick. The Audi conversion makes that sort of hp, but it is a turbo. Also v fast, but would be on the high side price-wise at 23K.

mr_c

2,508 posts

260 months

Tuesday 25th July 2006
quotequote all
I think the 265bhp will be the Turbo Technics conversion. They're meant to be quick, and while I've heard rumours of reliability problems, never seen evidence of it. And they blow flames out on the over run

An S1 Exige with a S/C honda living in the boot would fetch more than £23k, and should push out more than 265bhp.

Mad 20v

100 posts

269 months

Tuesday 25th July 2006
quotequote all
Must be talking about this one.



http://atsearch.autotrader.co.uk/www/

Its been for sale for some time now, im sure it was up for 22k last year when i was looking for my S1.

Edited by Mad 20v on Tuesday 25th July 09:13

S Works

10,166 posts

281 months

Tuesday 25th July 2006
quotequote all
If it's a TT car then that price is somewhat on the high side I'd say. What do you want the car for?

Humpy

Original Poster:

1,171 posts

250 months

Tuesday 25th July 2006
quotequote all
Good old PH.com never fails - ask a question and... Thanks for the comments.

MAD20v - yep that's the one. It is a TT conversion.

S Works - regarding usage - I will use it everyday - doing approx 10,000 miles a year. Run into Chiswick on M4 everyday from Slough - not too bad. I plan to do track days - realistically probably about 5 a year.

So thoughts are there may be a reliability issue? Does anyone know of one run reliably (or otherwise) for 24,000 miles plus?

Plus maybe overpriced at £23K? What do you think it's worth then?

Flames on overun eh?

H

S Works

10,166 posts

281 months

Tuesday 25th July 2006
quotequote all
If you're going to be doing as much mileage as you say you are then I'd say the S2 is a better bet. Get one with aircon and the sports pack(s) and you'll be fine. The S1 will be a bit raw for everyday use, and the engine could be a bit of a liability.

If it's an Exige that you want, and you're not interested in the Elise, and if budget will stretch I'd advise trying out an Exige S too.

Personally I'd say it would be sensible to also try an Elise 111R at that price point, you'll get a good deal for your money.

Humpy

Original Poster:

1,171 posts

250 months

Tuesday 25th July 2006
quotequote all
S Works said:
If it's an Exige that you want, and you're not interested in the Elise, and if budget will stretch I'd advise trying out an Exige S too.


I have tried the 240 - v good. Budget can't stretch yet to an S though. Maybe next time - it'll be that or a Noble. I did like the normal S2 I drove - liked the cam change effect - it had pipercross induction and a stage 2 pipe.

Thanks for the advice.

Mad 20v

100 posts

269 months

Tuesday 25th July 2006
quotequote all
From what you have said i wouldn’t go for the TT S1, as sworks says the S2 would be a better bet don’t get me wrong i love my S1 but if i was doing that sort of miles i would be looking for an S2 as well.

As for the Noble i looked at 2 when i was trying to find a "good" Exige and realy liked it but running cost are more than the Lotus and it's a big old car to get into car parks if you are going to use it everyday.
I would still like a 3R mind you

humpy

Original Poster:

1,171 posts

250 months

Wednesday 26th July 2006
quotequote all
I have just seen it [TT260]. Couldn't drive it because it was LASHING down with rain [monsoon like] so will have wait till next week to drive it. I appreciate the comments. The bad news is that I think I may not be able to resist. She looks and sounds FANTASTIC!!! - HELP!!!

Edited by Humpy on Thursday 27th July 08:14

S works

10,166 posts

281 months

Wednesday 26th July 2006
quotequote all
Well at least when it blows up you can console yourself that the 13k you spend on a supercharged Honda conversion will mean it's faster than the S2 you were contemplating anyway

humpy

Original Poster:

1,171 posts

250 months

Wednesday 26th July 2006
quotequote all
Are the TT conversions really THAT bad? There seems to be a lot of engine strengthening in the conversion www.turbotechnics.com/docs/cars/TT260.htm and it has a 12 mth warranty and 'they' say that there are 5-6 people they can put me in touch with that run them okay - listen to me talking myself into it - can you point me at some evidence..?

If they REALLY are prone to go pop then I'll have to knock it on the head and get an S2 but boy-oh-boy she is the mutt's nuts!! I can't give in that easily...

bogie

17,107 posts

303 months

Wednesday 26th July 2006
quotequote all
I had a TT230 - it was great and did 60K miles...then the cambelt tensioner fell off.

the TT260 was very rare and expensive - about £16K ...they did about 8 cars I think and most of them were back within 6 months ..they stopped doing them after that.

With road use I think it may last a while - with hard track use then I dont think so ......

humpy

Original Poster:

1,171 posts

250 months

Thursday 27th July 2006
quotequote all
Thanks Bogie - ouch on the cambelt tensioner! Impressive 60,000miles though gives me some hope.

I understand there was a problem with the charge cooler being mounted by the inlet manifold. Then they moved it to the chasis rail [I think]. Saw a thread on www.exiges.com which said "2 x rebuilds - run from the hills" which is slightly off-putting

I will try to get some more info from TT themselves tomorrow.

Edited by Humpy on Thursday 27th July 08:12

DSS123

351 posts

267 months

Thursday 27th July 2006
quotequote all
Humpy,

With that sort of cashola, I'd bag myself a well sorted S1 Elise (with Hard top, suspension / brake mods etc etc.... and then get it Honda'd myself.

But then I love the S1 'Liz.

You'd then have a very desirable, reliable motor, with known history which very little could touch on A/B roads!

I'm so jealous - I wish I had your problem!


Dunc

humpy

Original Poster:

1,171 posts

250 months

Thursday 27th July 2006
quotequote all
Funnily enough I had been thinking about that very thing as I was driving the 'Tony & Guy' mobile home from work - How much would all that be???

S1 Elise - £9k??
Honda conversion - ? [what's the typical bhp?]
Supercharger - ? [what's the typical bhp?]
Suspension mods, brakes, wheels & tyres - ?
Elise supersport body mods - [the exige like one? - sorry if that's wrong - I'm new to this]
Anything else I've forgotten - ???

Edited by humpy on Thursday 27th July 21:56

S works

10,166 posts

281 months

Thursday 27th July 2006
quotequote all
humpy said:
Funnily enough I had been thinking about that very thing as I was driving the 'Tony & Guy' mobile home from work - How much would all that be???


S1 Elise - £9k??
Honda conversion - ~£10k NA, ~£13k SC?
What's the typical bhp? - ~220 NA, ~300SC
Suspension mods, brakes, wheels & tyres - Nitrons £1500 fitted & geo'd, £800 for Ali bells & Pagids, Wheels dependent on style, tyres ~£400 for Toyo R888's, ~£500 for Yoko Advan Neova LTS
Elise supersport body mods - Motorsport clams are what you're after, probably about £3k fitted and sprayed I guess
Anything else I've forgotten - ??? seats (upto £1600), harnesses (~£300), harness bar (£~150 fitted)

All in you'll be looking at around £25k+ for an NA car. Better off trying to buy one already converted. It will piss all over the other cars your considering though.

dss123

351 posts

267 months

Thursday 27th July 2006
quotequote all
S works is right, about 25k for the full beans.

However, spend 10-12k on your donor and you may well be able to find something with sus' brakes, tyres already sorted??

Then you are looking at the just Honda convertion - 10k. I'd go NA first. That's 200bhp which would be good for a 4 second sprint to 60 in such a light car. You can always supercharge and remap further down the line.

Then maybe a geo.

All in for 21-22k??


Dunc

humpy

Original Poster:

1,171 posts

250 months

Thursday 27th July 2006
quotequote all
£25k? - that's within budget - I'll start looking.
Thanks for advice and help.
H

GTRene

22,798 posts

255 months

Friday 28th July 2006
quotequote all
humpy said:
£25k? - that's within budget - I'll start looking.
Thanks for advice and help.
H

there is also a nice? 17.000,-gbp asking honda converted S1 and hardtop and and and with most of the specs needed in the classifieds, its got a honda 230hp to begin with and already a special ecu thats ready for the SC(remap)...the guy lives in Zwis but I believe the car can be in the UK?? anyway see the link...

www.pistonheads.com/sales/54327.htm

GTRene


Edited by GTRene on Friday 28th July 10:21