Glastonbury Tor picture
Author
Discussion

2jamesl

Original Poster:

1,346 posts

245 months

Friday 4th August 2006
quotequote all
Ok i took a picture of the glastonbury tor on my visit there yesterday and this is what it turned out like. It is my favourite out of about 100. I had to clone out about 10 people!



Although i have a problem. I have seen many pictures with that really dramatic sky and i wanted the same so i tried using the burn tool but it didnt turn out like i had hoped. Am i using the right tool and does anybody know how i can do it properly?

Heres my attempt- please ignore the lines around the castle, this took me two minutes and i quickly, i mean really quickly used the polygonal lasso tool.



Edited by 2jamesl on Friday 4th August 15:12

davidd

6,718 posts

314 months

Friday 4th August 2006
quotequote all
I would not have used the burn tool, I'd have selected the sky then used levels or curves (but then again what do I know).

I would also have lightened the rest of the picture..

D

Edited by davidd on Friday 4th August 15:40

zoidberg

8,883 posts

312 months

Friday 4th August 2006
quotequote all
maybe tilt the picture slightly so the castle is not on the p1ss

davidd

6,718 posts

314 months

Friday 4th August 2006
quotequote all


The problem is that the castle is quite dark so making it standout and look natural might be tricky..

D

V6GTO

11,579 posts

272 months

Friday 4th August 2006
quotequote all


Martin.

imperialism2024

1,596 posts

286 months

Friday 4th August 2006
quotequote all
I tried my hand in PS with it and I'll have to agree that the castle is too dark to make it stand out against a dark sky

And for 2jamesl, you may want to use the Magnetic Lasso tool to select the area, and set the feather to 3 pixels.

2jamesl

Original Poster:

1,346 posts

245 months

Friday 4th August 2006
quotequote all
thanks for all the comments.

te51cle

2,342 posts

278 months

Friday 4th August 2006
quotequote all
Have a look in Image->Adjustments menu and see if you have the Shadow/Highlight option in Photoshop CS, I know its in CS2 (in Elements 3 and above it can be found in Enhance->Adjust Lighting). If you have then it should do most of what you're looking for in recovering the building.

I'd recommend using the magic wand (Tolerance 30 with anti-alias and contiguous boxes ticked if present) to select the sky. Pick any bit, and click, then shift and click around to add to the selection. Once you have selected the whole sky (probably half a dozen clicks or so) you can feather the selection (much easier in the more detailed original !) and play about with it as desired. You could also select the grass in a similar manner and play about with it's colour too.

Overdone it, as usual, below to emphasize what can be done, you could even turn the path into a yellow brick road if you want !



Think I prefer Martin's version though !

Edited by te51cle on Friday 4th August 18:01

2jamesl

Original Poster:

1,346 posts

245 months

Friday 4th August 2006
quotequote all
im going to be brutal here.Thank-you so much but they are all horrible. I dont mean to offend anyone but they all have their problems the main one being they look fake. I just wanta dramtatic sky not a full on different style image. Again there is no nice way of saying this and i will take your comments onboard but unfortuneatly will not use them.

imperialism2024

1,596 posts

286 months

Friday 4th August 2006
quotequote all
2jamesl said:
im going to be brutal here.Thank-you so much but they are all horrible. I dont mean to offend anyone but they all have their problems the main one being they look fake. I just wanta dramtatic sky not a full on different style image. Again there is no nice way of saying this and i will take your comments onboard but unfortuneatly will not use them.


In your original post I saw what you were trying to do, and based on the photograph, I don't think it's possible to do what you're suggesting and still have it look good. There's only so much editing you can do to recover a photo...

chris.mapey

4,778 posts

297 months

Saturday 5th August 2006
quotequote all
I've just had a go.

Is this more to the brief, or not?



HTH

Chris