944 or Elise
Author
Discussion

MattBucks

Original Poster:

13,179 posts

243 months

Sunday 6th August 2006
quotequote all
Hi All,

First post here after surfing the last couple of weeks.

I've managed to clear space in my garage and have got £10k to fill it. I like the Porsche marque but know I'm asking for trouble getting a 911 for that kind of money.

I'm lookng for something to have a run in now and again, maybe take over the channel for a run and track days.

I also like Elises so wonder what you'd advise, pro and cons. I guess with the Elise it would be faster and have more kudos but I'd only need to spend £5k for the 944.

Also, I briefly looked at a P plate S1 up for £10k at the local Lotus dealer. Is this on the money or a bit steep. It had 40k on the clock. The seats and door trim were a bit scuffed.

Any advice appreciated.

I'll post this on Porsche forum too.

Cheers

Matt

Edited by MattBucks on Sunday 6th August 21:09

simonk

908 posts

256 months

Sunday 6th August 2006
quotequote all
I love 911s, but like you say, not for £10k!

Not driven a 944 but imagine it will be quite "normal". An elise will probably be more of an occasion and event. Depends if you have to use the car everyday?

Simon

MattBucks

Original Poster:

13,179 posts

243 months

Sunday 6th August 2006
quotequote all
thanks..no this is for high days and holidays only.

carlymart

618 posts

245 months

Sunday 6th August 2006
quotequote all
I am a resent new elise owner and have owned 2 944s both 2.5 and s2 3.0L both handled very well but not a patch on the elise also running costs are high
I neaded a new indicator switch and is cost £250 fitted by a local spectialist
I would recommend a 94 to any one but if you can live with the impractacalitys of an elise I would go for it at the drop of a hat

Paul RN

1,168 posts

245 months

Sunday 6th August 2006
quotequote all
What about a 968, something like this? www.pistonheads.com/sales/86979.htm

Personally I think most porkas have a stigma attached to them, while a Lotus is a true enthusiasts car (you'd have to be to even try and get in it and live with it).

People wave at you, stick thumbs up, kids stand and stare as you drive past, people even let you out at junctions. I don't even need to cover driving it, just get in one its damn addictive!

S works

10,166 posts

281 months

Sunday 6th August 2006
quotequote all
You'll have more fun in an Elise.

This looks good value...
http://forums.seloc.org/classified.ph

More info and pics at...
www.jonathanedwards.pwp.blueyonder.co.uk/elise/

Edited by S works on Sunday 6th August 22:18

TIPPER

2,955 posts

250 months

Sunday 6th August 2006
quotequote all
Would have thought the 968 (particularly clubsport) would make better 'toy' than 944........

But, the Elise is the Daddy. The wear you describe is pretty normal on the S1. A local trim shop should be able to replace worn items and match up the rest to suite fairly reasonably.

Have a look through the buyers guide and remember to buy on condition. An Elise takes miles fairly well as long as its been properly serviced.

Happy hunting and hoping to hear more of you on hear!

Paul RN

1,168 posts

245 months

Sunday 6th August 2006
quotequote all
www.bell-colvill.co.uk/LotusShop/Directory.asp?Persist=&Chapter=E11

Sill re-trimm £28.29 direct from the Lotus trim factory, what more could you want.

Janitor

2,372 posts

250 months

Sunday 6th August 2006
quotequote all
Sorry mate, I may be a little biased but there is only one choice... and it's not German (yet! )

zebra

4,555 posts

245 months

Monday 7th August 2006
quotequote all
Get a caterham for under 10k and forget the 944 thing.

Zebra

gooby

9,269 posts

265 months

Monday 7th August 2006
quotequote all
You are completly misguided if you think you will get an unbiased answer. It is like asking the pope which faith is best. Stop toying with the idea of porkers for 10k. You wont get a good one and you probably wont be able to maintain it on a budget - it is hard enough with an Elise.

Is it your first performance car? Have you driven mid engine, rear wheel drive? Along with the elise there is also the M100 elan. That is a superb car!

zebra

4,555 posts

245 months

Monday 7th August 2006
quotequote all
Hang on a cotton picking minute, do you have a car?

Zebra

MattBucks

Original Poster:

13,179 posts

243 months

Monday 7th August 2006
quotequote all
I've posted this in the porsche forum too to see what they say, however I'm impressed with some of the unbiased replies so far on this thread...so thanks guys.

I've also considered a Caterham but prefer the more modern look to the Elise. I like the Elan too so that could be an alternative?

I currently own an Impreza and use a Mk5 Golf GT TDI for everyday use.



Edited by MattBucks on Monday 7th August 10:54


Edited by MattBucks on Monday 7th August 10:55

zebra

4,555 posts

245 months

Monday 7th August 2006
quotequote all
MattBucks said:
I've posted this in the porsche forum too to see what they say, however I'm impressed with some of the unbiased replies so far on this thread...so thanks guys.

I've also considered a Caterham but prefer the more modern look to the Elise. I like the Elan too so that could be an alternative?

I currently own an Impreza and use a Mk5 Golf GT TDI for everyday use.



Forget elise, Gooby's right, it will not fit into 10k.

I say again, 944 _ no no no no no no no!

Option 1; caterham for about 7k + 3k worth of work.

Option 2; save more money and buy elise. (trade girlfiend, hdtv, and definetly the golf)

Zebra

gooby

9,269 posts

265 months

Monday 7th August 2006
quotequote all
zebra said:
MattBucks said:
I've posted this in the porsche forum too to see what they say, however I'm impressed with some of the unbiased replies so far on this thread...so thanks guys.

I've also considered a Caterham but prefer the more modern look to the Elise. I like the Elan too so that could be an alternative?

I currently own an Impreza and use a Mk5 Golf GT TDI for everyday use.



Forget elise, Gooby's right, it will not fit into 10k.

I say again, 944 _ no no no no no no no!

Option 1; caterham for about 7k + 3k worth of work.

Option 2; save more money and buy elise. (trade girlfiend, hdtv, and definetly the golf)

Zebra


I will have to correct Zebby, you can get some very well sorted S1's for 10k and they will provide you with some incredible driving pleasure.

My point was it is very hard to get a good proker for 10k

zebra

4,555 posts

245 months

Monday 7th August 2006
quotequote all
Fair comment Goobmeister, no offense taken.

Zebby

MattBucks

Original Poster:

13,179 posts

243 months

Monday 7th August 2006
quotequote all
Ok..does the P plate S1 sound fair at £10k at the local dealer?

zebra

4,555 posts

245 months

Monday 7th August 2006
quotequote all
MattBucks said:
Ok..does the P plate S1 sound fair at £10k at the local dealer?


We could do with a bit more info than that?

Zebra

stsly

71 posts

246 months

Monday 7th August 2006
quotequote all
Elise for the lightness, fun and attention.

enough said!

gooby

9,269 posts

265 months

Monday 7th August 2006
quotequote all
MattBucks said:
Ok..does the P plate S1 sound fair at £10k at the local dealer?


condition
milage
Mods
Very important; was the last owner an enthuiast?
Has it had the HG done recently
What brakes? (MMC?)

etc etc, I am sure someone will add to this list .... you are best off looking at some buyers guides, sticky at the top.